The sibling species H. yedoensis Takizawa coexists sympatrically and simultaneously with H. axyridis only on pine trees in Japan. To elucidate the mechanisms enabling coexistence of these two sympatric sibling species, a laboratory experiment was performed that focused on differences in their maternal investment through eggs and the role of sibling cannibalism. The egg size (volume) of H. yedoensis was 24.91% larger than that of H. axyridis. Cluster size in H. axyridis was significantly larger than that in H. yedoensis; however, the total number of eggs and oviposition cost (by volume) per female in H. yedoensis were not significantly different from those in H. axyridis, although total number of clusters tended to be slightly higher in H. yedoensis than in H. axyridis. The percentage of undeveloped eggs per cluster in H. yedoensis was not significantly different from that in H. axyridis, whereas the percentage of developed eggs with delayed hatching per cluster was significantly larger in H. yedoensis than in H. axyridis. Moreover, the cost of sibling cannibalism per hatched larval cluster in H. yedoensis (worth 4.43 sibling eggs) was 3.36 times larger than that in H. axyridis.Therefore, maternal investment through egg and sibling cannibalism in developed eggs with delayed hatching are more intense in H. yedoensis than in H. axyridis, implying a higher larval survival rate through higher ability of prey capturing at the first instar. The results in this study suggest that the higher survival rate and accelerated development in H. yedoensis by the two maternal investments, i.e., a large egg and intense sibling cannibalism of developed eggs with delayed hatching, may play an important role in sympatric coexistence with the aggressive aphidophagous ladybird beetle H. axyridis.
I hypothesized that sibling cannibalism is one of maternal investment in that a female controls sibling cannibalism. To test the hypothesis, I conducted a laboratory experiment and field observations to investigate sibling cannibalism in relation to cluster size and cluster site in the ladybird beetle, Harmonia axyridis Pallas. In the laboratory experiment, cluster size significantly affected the number of cannibalized eggs per cluster (R2 = 0.516), while cluster size was significantly affected by the oviposition interval. Furthermore, there was a marginally significant positive relationship between cluster size and the percentage of sibling cannibalism per cluster. In the field, cluster size and the direct distance from a cluster site to an aphid colony (an indicator of intensity of non-sibling cannibalism) significantly affected the number of cannibalized eggs per cluster (R2 = 0.472). Furthermore, there was a significant positive relationship between the direct distance from a cluster to the nearest aphid colony and cluster size. However, there was not a significant relationship between the distance and the percentage of sibling cannibalism. These results may be caused by the weakness of the female's power to control sibling cannibalism. Thus, a female H. axyridis controls cluster size through the intensity of non-sibling cannibalism, which may be one of oviposition strategies in this species.
In this study, we focused on the direct (i.e., predation) and indirect (i.e., potential threat from coexisting with a larger individual) effects of cannibalism and intraguild predation (IGP) during larval stages of two sibling ladybird beetles. These effects play an important role in the coexistence of the generalist–commonHarmoniaaxyridisand specialist–rareH.yedoensis(Coleoptera: Coccinellidae). Direct predation effect of cannibalism and IGP was asymmetric in the two sibling ladybird beetles; the fourth instar larvae ofH.axyridiswere better intraguild predators than cannibals, while the reverse was true in the larvae ofH.yedoensis. Neither cannibalism nor IGP significantly affected female body weight in either species. LarvalH.axyridissurviving exposure to cannibalism or IGP had a reduced number of ovarioles as adults, whereas adultH.yedoensisovarioles were not affected. For the indirect effects, longer developmental times in males and females and a lower total number of ovarioles in females were detected inH.axyridis. InH.yedoensis, shorter developmental time of males, lighter adult weight and fewer total ovarioles in females were observed. Olfactometer choice experiments clarified that the fourth instar larvae ofH.axyridisavoided the first instar conspecific larvae, while those ofH.yedoensiswere attracted to the odors fromH.axyridisand conspecifics. Thus,H.axyridishas an avoidance mechanism only for cannibalism but not for IGP,whereasH.yedoensisdoes not have any avoidance mechanism. These different behaviors in the direct and indirect effects of cannibalism and IGP observed in the laboratory may play important roles in the coexistence of generalist–commonH.axyridisand specialist–rareH.yedoensisin natural conditions, compensating for the large handicap ofH.yedoensisat reproductive interference fromH.axyridis.
About Me
Laboratory of Forest Ecology, Graduate School of Agriculture, Kyoto University
Laboratory of Forest Ecology, Graduate School of Agriculture, Kyoto University