Hafiz Muhammad Nadir
1 and Ash Ahmed
2*
1Doctoral Researcher, Civil Engineering Group, Leeds Beckett University, UK
2Associate Professor of Civil Engineering Group, Leeds Beckett University, UK
*Corresponding author: Ash Ahmed, Associate Professor of Civil Engineering Group, UK
Submission: December 23, 2020;
Published: January 15, 2021
DOI: 10.31031/RDMS.2021.14.000848 ISSN: 2576-8847 Volume 14 Issue 5 The rivers and water streams are considered as a source of fresh drinking water for the human being on earth. The main source of water entering to these reservoirs is surface run off, snow melting and underground water. The water at the river’s mouth is generally in the form of small streams which are considered clean but as they flow down the catchment, pollutants and nutrients start to enter in larger amounts due to anthropogenic activities and advanced land use by human beings. As per inspection of chief inspector “Drinking Water Inspectorate (DWI)” in 2016, out of more than 4600 water bodies and 3700 rivers in England, only one sixth could get “good” status and two third could get “moderate” status as per European union standards. This is though a good achievement in Europe but alarming also, as all rivers are required to have achieved specified “good” standards by 2021 (extended to 2027 for some categories). This phenomenon is pronouncing more complications in drinking water reservoirs or compensatory reservoirs from where water is taken out to utility companies and treated for domestic water supply incurring an enormous cost on its treatment before human consumption. The clean water standards can be achieved only if a strict control is implemented on entry of pollutants/ nutrients from surface run off using thorough catchment scale sensitive strategies. UK has been implementing strict measures under Environment Agency (EA), Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) and other organizations like “Natural England”, “River Trust” and water utility/ supply companies to achieve desired standards of water quality in rivers by managing the whole catchment as per European union water framework directive (EU WFD) 2000.The catchment sensitive farming and nitrate vulnerable zones policies were started in 1992 and has been in full practice by implementing different stewardship schemes and fertilizers control measures in farmlands and arable lands. Ingbirchworth reservoir and Scout Dyke compensatory reservoir have been under catchment sensitive stewardship schemes to control quantities of nutrients especially nitrates and other pollutants since 2006 to maintain good quality water reservoirs for drinking and compensation to Don river. A partial success has been achieved in controlling the values of nitrates, phosphates, and suspended solids to enter from catchment farmlands by controlling the use of slurry/ fertilizers and implementation of good farming techniques. However, temporal and special variations show a variable result of presence of nitrates, phosphates and suspended solids at different streams in different times, more than specified limits of 11.3mg/L, 0.1mg/L and 25mg/L respectively. This requires more holistic efforts to control the bad practices in farming in adjacent farm/arable lands and improvements in stewardship schemes for catchment sensitive farming in Ingbirchworth areas.
Keywords: Catchment sensitive farming;Nitrate vulnerable zones;Water quality;Stewardship farming schemes;Impact; Success Water is a common resource for all living creatures and is required to be preserved for use by all, in its pure/ natural form [1]. Unfortunately, the natural clean state of water in the rivers/ streams could not be preserved pollution free, mainly due to anthropogenic activities of humankind, land use changes, industrial revolution, heavy modified water bodies, geomorphological changes and climatic variations. All these have impacted the water quality with adverse effects on biodiversity and ecology. The increase in population and technology/ industry advancement have resulted into more use of fresh water from the environment. European Union Water Framework Directive (2000 & amended in 2012) wants every member state to implement best possible measures to prevent polluting the water streams physically or chemically by managing the complete river catchment as a wholistic approach [2]. This seems to be a gigantic task with less success possibilities but if implemented successfully, can stop doing the modifications and pollutants entry to water bodies throughout the catchment length by all stakeholder/ public partnership. UK has more than 8000 water streams in around 100 catchments to manage as per River Basin Management Plans prepared/ revised every 6 years by Environment Agency. These are managed to get ‘Good Status’ as per EU standards by 2021& 2027 (extended) due to non-attainment of goals set for 2015 [3]. The target to limit Nutrients and sediments into the rivers from farmlands remains a grey area in almost all EU countries and UK [4,5]. We are required to implement the best management practices to control all these pollutants entering to streams throughout the length of the river catchments which comprise the implementation of catchment sensitive farming being major source of pollutants, rehabilitation of barren land by forestation, control on land use changes, sediment transport to rivers from tillage/ cropless fields, control on farming and animal waste, preventing free entry of oil/ chemicals from roads as surface run off, control on industrial wastes/ sewerage treatment disposals and preservation of natural course of flow of streams with no/ less modifications. The anthropogenic pollution of water bodies by mixing of physical, chemical, biological and industrial waste in these streams is a result of increased population and human interventions especially after industrial revolution [6]. Kallis [7], Kaika [8], Adshead [9] & Grimeaud [10] have explained WFD issuance in 2000 as a historic milestone which combined all previous directives for maintenance of clean and healthy water for drinking/ irrigation/ bathing by preventing mixing/ disposal of waste, chemicals, organic materials, excessive use of nutrients/ manures, industrial waste and heavy modifications to water bodies for benefit of all living organism in all habitats including human beings, plants, birds, animals, microorganism and aqua life [7-10]. The WFD has been evolving over time into a detailed document by integration of various water related directives and policies issued time to time as shown in Figure 1; [11] and ask member states to maintain water reservoir for all purposes free from dangerous pollutants and treatment of wastewater before entering it to water streams through proper treatment plants. The treatment of polluted water is a costly affair and incurring major cost/ difficulty to water agencies in UK to achieve desired standards as implemented by EU WFD especially due to nitrate vulnerable farming in the catchment areas [12].
Figure 1: Integration of WFD [11]. The farmlands, cultivated areas and grassy fields are considered as a biggest source of entry of nutrients like Nitrate, Sulphate and Phosphates and Suspended Solids (SS) into water streams and reservoirs due to extensive use of organic manures and chemical fertilizers by farmers. The best solution to overcome the presence of nutrients and Suspended Solids (SS) is to implement a sustainable and sensible land use strategy for controlled agriculture/ farming in the catchment. The agriculture contributes £8 Billion in UK GDP by employing more than 0.3M people to do arable farming on three quarters of UK land [13]. However, controlling the farming industry to desired results is very difficult as any restrictions on use of fertilizers/ manures and implementation of catchment sensitive farming measures result into direct reduction of production yield and economic loss to farmers. However, UK government has implemented the rules for catchment sensitive farming with several subsidies to ease out the economic burden on farmers and they were required to implement the rules by 2019 with restricted use of land falling in the catchment vicinity of water reservoirs. The success of catchment sensitive policy is still questionable as much is required to be done by farmers in collaboration with DEFRA (Department for food, environment and rural affairs) and EA (Environment agency UK). This study has been carried out to assess the post implementation scenario/ water quality after incorporation of catchment sensitive farming in Ingbirchworth and Scout areas in South Yorkshire. In this study, water samples were collected from Ingbirchworth drinking water supply reservoir and Scout Dyke compensatory reservoirs maintained by Yorkshire Water Agency in the catchment of River Don. These reservoirs are fed by different water streams mainly draining water from surrounding arable/ farmlands of around 11.2km2 comprising mainly on grassland and some of the cultivated crop lands. This area is being managed by catchment sensitive farming under policies of DEFRA, Nitrate Vulnerable Zones legislation and Catchment Sensitive Farming advice since 2002. Pictorial coverage/ maps of reservoir are given in Figure 2.
Figure 2: Maps and Pictures Ingbirchworth reservoirs taken during site visit. The ever-increasing human interference in nature and especially for last 5 decades after industrial revolution, have caused more intake of nutrients and SS into water streams than ever before [14,15]. Edwards and Withers (2008) have studied that the water reservoirs are facing anthropogenic concentration of nutrients and SS due to increased use of fertilisers, manure, slurry, polluted surface drainage, wastewater, modified land use for agriculture, farms, urbanization, deforestation and industry [16]. Up to 70 % of Nitrogen and 30 to 50 % of phosphorous are coming from agricultural/ farms land into the reservoirs/ water streams in UK [17]. Runoff from arable/ farmlands is producing influx of up to 75% of SS [18], 25% of phosphorus and 60% of nitrate inputs to rivers [19]. Ockenden et al (2012) in their study found that it is difficult to control the influx of pollutants from Agri lands due to diffused use of fertilizers and presence of residual chemicals/ slurry in soil even in controlled catchment management [20]. There is a need of controlling the pollution sources from the fields by controlling application of fertilizers/ manures, over grazing, tillage, cross slope cultivation, edge of fields/ buffer zones, wetlands, maintenance of surface runoff and ditches/ drains in the catchment areas [21,22]. The pollutants can be point source or diffuse pollution in the form of Nutrients/ waste from agriculture/ farmlands, chemicals/ waste from industry/ roads/ surface drainage, sewerage treatment plants disposal, waste/ leakages from sewerage systems of rural/ urban population, microplastic, pharmaceuticals or modified structures [23]. These pollutants are responsible for bad water quality which largely affect the aqua life in the form of decreased biodiversity, genetic variations of species in water, algae/ bacteria/ coliform growth, dead zones due to decreased dissolved oxygen and sediments concentration. A per OFWAT (2011), England and Wales extract more than 55 billion litres/day from ecological water cycle which is equal to Winder Lake water. Water companies supply 15 billion litres/ day as treated water for domestic use, and they have charged customers £30 billion for treatment/ disposal of this water. To minimize this amount and to reduce the impact on ecosystem by extraction of this much of water, Billions of pounds have been spent on catchment management to get good quality raw water and return it back to environment with less treatment effort [24]. The pollutants are dissolved/ diluted by attenuation in river streams in open channel flow but extraction of huge amount of water affects this attenuation/ dilution capability of water. Therefore, best catchment management practices are required to maintain the water cycle with minimum disturbance. Fresh water is extracted from environment and used for different purposes. During use, water gets polluted by human and after treatment by Wastewater Treatment Plants (WWTP) and then it is released back in water streams. The treated water is not 100% free from pollutants/ chemicals and badly disturbs the water cycle in quality/ quantity both. As per press release of Environment Agency EA (2019) on efficacy of WWTP in UK, the standards achieved by the water companies in their WWTP since 2011, has deteriorated due to increase in sewage mixing occurrences in 2018. Only Northumbrian Water, one out of 9 water companies in UK, has achieved passing standards [25]. The partially treated water from these treatment plants is a source of pollution like pharmaceutical/ cosmetics residuals/ chemicals [26,27], microfibers/ microplastics [28,29] faecal coliform bacteria and other pathogens [30]. As per WWF (2019), one of the major causes of failing of UK rivers in getting good ecological status is pollution from WWTP as it impacts around 40% of UK rivers. It is imperative to modernize the WWTP to work as per the standards laid down by EU WFD and those specified by Environment Agency UK, otherwise UK may not be able to meet the 2021 & 2027 WFD targets [30]. UK customers are paying around £1.25 Billion annually as their water/ sewerage bills to water companies for the treatment of fresh/ wastewater, since 1989. Therefore, water companies are required to invest more on their plants and catchment management as a good preventative measure to maintain quality of water in rivers [31].
Some catchment management schemes and their efficacy in reducing water pollution throughout river catchment The best management practice to maintain a River Catchment is to control pollution entering the rivers from agriculture and farmlands. The bulk source of sediments, nitrate and phosphate to rivers is due to soil erosion/ use of fertilizers/ slurry in agriculture/ grazing fields which cause growth of algae and decrease in dissolved oxygen in water streams. Following paragraphs give details of some catchment schemes and their efficacy in getting desired results: SCaMP 1,2 and 3 by United Utilities since 2005 to 2020 are the catchment management examples in which around 60,000 hectares of land has been managed with catchment sensitive farming, forestation, peatland drains blockage, re-vegetation and fencing etc. There have been improvements/ steady results in water quality as regards the colour, dissolved oxygen, dissolved organic carbon, less soil erosion/ sediment transport, rehabilitation of natural habitats to some extent with temporal/ spatial variations because of these schemes though lesser than the desired results. However, more area is required to be managed to get better results in the catchment with participation/ finances of farmers, NGOs and government organization [32]. Collins [33] in their study of implementation of 12 onsite nutrients/ sediment control measures on farmlands in UK found that a localized impact on reduction in the levels of nitrate by 2.5%, phosphate by 11.9% and Sediments by 5.6% was observed with annual cost of £52/ hectare. It will cost around £450 million for whole agriculture land in UK annually to decrease the levels by these small levels. The 100% efficacy of these catchment practices involve more than 700 measures which are required to be fully controlled for the desired results of WFD with enormous investment and willingness participation of farmers [33]. DPIWE (2003), Department for primary industries, water and environment Tasmania carried out study on water quality of Montagu River after decades of its catchment management and found out very less improvement in quality of water as all indicators about nutrients, sediments, coliform bacteria and other physical/ chemical impurities remained more than the specified limits in almost all the reaches of the river thus showing hardly any success of catchment management to improve the water quality. The failure was caused mainly by non-implementation of the required practices, no control on use of fertilizers on farmlands, no proper disposal of sewerage/ industrial waste, lack of public participation and lack of finances [34]. McDowell [35] carried out the study for assessment of water quality in Pomahaka River catchment in New Zealand after decades of management for levels of nitrates, phosphate, suspended solids and E-coli bacteria. Very little improvement was observed in the length of the river with a lot of spatial/ temporal variations. Overall, the given indicators could not get better improvements due to application of fertilizers/ slurry on wet soils, unvegetated fields in non-crops season, ploughing of wet soils, direct ingress of animal faecal from Sheep and dairy farms and mixing of overflow sewerage from urban/ rural population [35]. Kay [36] studied Ingbirchworth reservoir catchment area to determine efficacy of catchment management which was declared Nitrate Vulnerable Zone (NVZ) under EA in 2002 and associate catchment ECSFDI in 2006 (England catchment sensitive farming Delivery Initiative ECSFDI). It comprises 3 reservoirs mainly surrounded by grazing lands of livestock with very less arable land. EA has managed the monitoring of this area by taking fortnightly samples at 11 points. They used the long-term data of EA and took 50 samples to determine the improvements in water quality. A partial success of catchment management in nitrate and phosphate levels in last 3 decades was observed that too only in a few streams having variations of levels lesser/ more than the specified limits in different peak times showing temporal/ spatial variations. The conclusion was drawn that localized management can give a better result for a local area only, however much more is required to be done by public participation and stricter implementation mechanism by government agencies to achieve results in the whole catchment. The results achieved for reduction of nitrates, phosphates and suspended solids over long-term observations of 3 years were found highly susceptible to temporal and spatial variations though partial improvement has been achieved as shown by ranges, median values and lower/ higher limits with first and fourth quartile box graphs as given in Figure 3; [36].
Figure 3: Presence of Nitrate and Phosphate in Ingbirchworth/ Scout Dyke 2006-2009 [36]. There is a need to interact with farmers to implement catchment sensitive practices like how, when and what quantity of fertilizers to be used, how to use slurry like injecting into the soil instead of spraying it on the soil, how to store the slurry, pesticides, insecticides and fertilizers etc away from water channels under the roof. How to do soil tillage and at what time. They should not plough the fields when soil is wet, should not spray in rainy weather, should maintain a buffer zone in between the water channel and crops edge, should grow a cover crop to stop sediments entry from naked soil and they should have mixed breeds/ types of animals as livestock [24,37- 39]. DEFRA is interacting with farmers by frequent site visits of its employees to give guidelines and to do audit of implementation of DEFRA guidance/ rules. However, there is a direct requirement of public...