Sam Barraclough

Mr. Sam Barraclough

Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester, UK
orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
24 May 2022 in Sports
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SBSam Barraclough
Sam Barraclough
Kevin TillKevin Till
Kevin Till
AKAdam Kerr
Adam Kerr
SEStacey Emmonds
Stacey Emmonds
Talent identification (TID) and talent development (TD) continue to receive significant investment from team sports organisations, highlighting their importance in attempting to identify potential elite athletes. Accompanying this continual pursuit to unearth future talent is an ever-increasing body of research aiming to provide solutions and strategies to optimise TID and TD processes. Therefore, the aim of this review is to provide a summary and critical synthesis of the methodological approaches applied to TID in team sports and present considerations for future TID research. Specifically, this review highlights three key areas for consideration: (1) the timespan of the research design; (2) the use of monodisciplinary or multidisciplinary variables; and (3) the fidelity of the methodological approaches to the assessment of talent. The review highlights the benefits of longitudinal, multidisciplinary, and ecologically valid research designs for TID within team sports.

12 August 2024 in International Journal of Sports Science & Coaching
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SBSam Barraclough
Sam Barraclough
KTKevin Till
Kevin Till
AKAdam Kerr
Adam Kerr
SEStacey Emmonds
Stacey Emmonds
Talent identification of young soccer players is a significant consideration for elite youth soccer organisations, with decisions on players often being made based on the subjective expert opinion of scouts and coaches. Previous research has suggested that scouts and coaches purportedly consider a multitude of factors before arriving at their decisions. However, to date, limited research exists regarding how coaches evaluate player potential within such organisations and how the consideration of further data may influence such evaluations of a player's future potential. Therefore, the aim of this study was to present ratings of perceived potential in an elite youth soccer academy and explore the relationships between a player's perceived potential, athleticism, and perceived level of current match performance. Using 181 player observations, findings demonstrated that ratings of players’ perceived potential decreased within older age groups and were the lowest in the senior academy age group (U18). Furthermore, a mixed effects ordinal regression model suggested that coaches’ perceptions of a player's future potential demonstrated strong relationships with current match performance and athleticism. Increases in a player's mean match rating significantly increased the odds of them being perceived to have higher potential and increases in athleticism also demonstrated a positive relationship with increased perceptions of potential. The findings have implications for youth soccer organisations, providing insight into the distribution of ratings of potential within an elite youth soccer academy, and demonstrating that further data (match performance and athleticism) is related to, and may influence, coaches’ perceptions of player potential.

30 October 2023 in International Journal of Sports Science & Coaching
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SBSam Barraclough
Sam Barraclough
DPDavid Piggott
David Piggott
KTKevin Till
Kevin Till
AKAdam Kerr
Adam Kerr
SEStacey Emmonds
Stacey Emmonds
Important decisions surrounding talent identification (TID), talent development (TD) and (de)selection within elite youth soccer are often grounded in the subjective opinions of coaches. These opinions often stem from coaches’ observations of player performance, which have been shown to be susceptible to several biases. Additionally, previous research has failed to establish specific criteria on which such opinions are based, aside from a coach's own intuition and practical experience. This study aimed to create a communal language and aligned criteria for the specific purpose of evaluating players’ performances. Semi-structured interviews were undertaken with nine experienced coaches (13.6 ± 10.8 years) from a professional UK soccer academy to identify coaches’ perceptions of key position-specific soccer actions, performed during differing moments of the game, for evaluating individual match performance. Thematic analysis of the interview data permitted the extraction of several themes , posited to encompass the position-specific soccer actions highlighted by the coaches. Themes for outfield positions included attacking skills; defending skills; movements to receive, create or exploit space; receiving and releasing skills; support play; end product; press, recover to the ball, man or space; and tactical understanding. Goalkeeper themes included tactical understanding, positioning relative to the ball, danger, teammates and opponents, play forward, support play, choice of action and range of distribution. This study highlights an applied approach of creating a shared mental model for appraising player performances, which can facilitate discussion and knowledge exchange between coaches and practitioners, with the intention of improving decision-making around TID, TD and (de)selection decisions.

9 June 2025 in PLOS ONE
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MAMatthew Andrew
Matthew Andrew
SBSam Barraclough
Sam Barraclough
JDJames H. Dugdale
James H. Dugdale
MRMatthew J. Reeves
Matthew J. Reeves
ATAndrew O. Triggs
Andrew O. Triggs
AKAdam L. Kelly
Adam L. Kelly
Relative age effects in soccer are typified by an overrepresentation of players born earlier in the selection year. Examinations of relative age effects remain limited in female players and developing soccer nations. The aim of the present study was to examine the influence of sex, age, nation, playing position, and playing status in international level soccer players under Confederation of North, Central American and Caribbean Association Football (Concacaf). The sample consisted of a total of 1,959 active soccer players from 24 soccer nations that competed in recent Concacaf Championships. Results indicated an evident relative age effect in male [p < 0.05] but not female [p = 0.81] players. Male players were over‐represented by players born in the first quartile for the U17 [p < 0.01] level, however, this over‐representation did not transfer to the U20 or senior levels. No relative age effects were observed at any level for female players. A large proportion of nations demonstrated relative age effects in male, but not female samples. Relative age effects were shown for players participating at age group level, but not those ‘playing-up’. Results from this study highlight the continued disparity in relative age effects prevalence between male and female players raises further questions regarding the value of selecting relatively older players to metrics of success, transition, and selection for senior international soccer. This information can be used to advance talent identification and development in Concacaf nations.

12 September 2025 in PLOS ONE
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MAMatthew Andrew
Matthew Andrew
SBSam Barraclough
Sam Barraclough
ATAndrew O. Triggs
Andrew O. Triggs
JDJames H. Dugdale
James H. Dugdale
AKAdam Kelly
Adam Kelly
MRMatthew Jonathan Reeves
Matthew Jonathan Reeves
Talent identification (TI) in soccer is a complex and multifactorial process within the context of collegiate sport in the United States, where coaches must assess performance-ready athletes often under strict regulatory and resource constraints. Despite the critical role college coaches play in bridging youth to professional soccer, little is known about their evaluative priorities during recruitment. This study examined how soccer coaches from female and male NCAA Division I and II programs perceived the importance of various player attributes and scouting methods in the TI process. A total of 178 college soccer coaches completed a survey assessing perceptions across seven attribute categories (technical, physical, psychological, game intelligence, social, other, and coach-specific) and common scouting methods. Bootstrapped trimmed means, effect sizes, and inter-rater agreement (rwg) were used to analyse the coaches’ ratings of importance across attributes and to assess for differences in coach perceptions within the female and male programs. Results showed coaches across female and male programs rated technical proficiency, coachability, decision-making, and work rate as critically important. College-specific soccer knowledge was the most highly valued coach attribute, while live match observation was the most preferred scouting method. Sex-based differences were generally minimal, although emerged in perceptions of physical and social attributes, with coaches of female players placing greater emphasis on communication and agility. Results highlighted a shared prioritisation of technical and psychological qualities in college TI, with contextual differences influenced by sex and program structure. These insights support the development of more aligned and evidence-informed TI strategies in collegiate soccer environments.

12 April 2025 in Journal of Sports Sciences
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SBSam Barraclough
Sam Barraclough
Kevin TillKevin Till
Kevin Till
AKAdam Kerr
Adam Kerr
SEStacey Emmonds
Stacey Emmonds
Multidisciplinary profiling provides coaches with key information to augment their (de)selection decisions. These profiles often encompass objective and subjective data in the form of signs (isolated assessments), samples (contextualised assessments) and subjective expert opinion (SEO). Whilst multiple sources of information are considered by coaches during their decision-making, research exploring the extent to which objective and subjective multidisciplinary information can classify (de)selection is limited. Multidisciplinary data (physical profiling, match statistics, coach match ratings) were collected on 58 Under-16 (n = 20) and Under-18 (n = 38) youth male soccer players from a single academy in the United Kingdom. Group-level differences between selected (n = 39) and deselected (n = 24) players were explored, and binary logistic regression models were created to classify (de)selection. Analysis revealed a significant difference between selected and deselected players for match ratings (p < 0.0001), 505 left foot (p < 0.01), frequency of passes, percentage of successful aerial duels, and percentage of accurate crosses (p < 0.05). A classification model containing signs, samples and SEO data demonstrated the best model fit (AIC = 72.63), the highest discriminatory power (AUC = 0.79) and classified players with the greatest accuracy (78%) for (de)selection purposes. The use of signs, samples and SEO can support (de)selection decisions but fails to fully represent the complexity of the (de)selection process.