Many empirical studies have discussed market liquidity, which is regarded as a measure of a booming financial market. Further, various indicators for objectively evaluating market liquidity have also been proposed and their merits have been discussed. In recent years, the impact of high-frequency traders (HFTs) on financial markets has been a focal concern, but no studies have systematically discussed their relationship with major market liquidity indicators, including volume, tightness, resiliency, and depth. In this study, we used agent-based simulations to compare the major liquidity indicators in an artificial market where an HFT participated was compared to one where no HFT participated. The results showed that all liquidity indicators in the market where an HFT participated improved more than those in the market where no HFT participated. Furthermore, as a result of investigating the correlations between the major liquidity indicators in our simulations and the extant empirical literature, we found that market liquidity can be measured not only by the major liquidity indicators but also by execution rate. Therefore, it is suggested that it could be appropriate to employ execution rate as a novel liquidity indicator in future studies.
We built an artificial market model and investigated the impact of large erroneous orders on price formations. Comparing the case of consented large erroneous orders in the short term with that of continuous small erroneous orders in the long term, if amounts of orders are the same, we found that the orders induced almost the same price fall range. We also analyzed effects of price variation limits for erroneous orders and found that price variation limits that employ a limitation term shorter than the time erroneous orders exist effectively prevent large price fluctuations. We also investigated effects of up-tick rules adopting the trigger method that the Japan Financial Services Agency adopted on November 2013.
11 June 2015 in Electronics and Communications in Japan
SUMMARY: We built an artificial market model and compared the effects of price variation limits, short sell regulations, and uptick rules. When there were no regulations, the price fell below the fundamental value when economic bubble collapses occurred. When there were regulations, this overshoot did not occur and the market was more effective. However, the short sell regulations and uptick rules caused the trading prices to be higher than the base value. To summarize these points, the price variation limits have the potential to make the market more effective. We also surveyed an adequate limitation price range and an adequate limitation time span for the price variation limit and found conditions for the parameters for the price variation limit that prevent such overshoots.
13 April 2017 in Evolutionary and Institutional Economics Review