Estimating river discharge requires simultaneous measurement of velocity and flow depth. While surface velocities are relatively easy to measure using noncontact techniques, depth measurement usually requires physically intrusive instrumentation. This limits our capability to remotely monitor discharge in natural rivers subject to bed level variations. This work tests the potential to estimate the surface velocity, the water depth, the depth average velocity, and then discharge of a river using only a sequence of images of the dynamic water surface. The method is based on a comparison between the spatiotemporal Fourier spectra of the pixel intensities of these images and the theoretical dispersion relations of turbulence‐generated surface fluctuations and gravity‐capillary waves. The method is validated through the analysis of water surface videos obtained with fixed cameras from two river sections equipped with conventional discharge gauging. The applicability of the approach is demonstrated and the measurement uncertainties are quantified. The method is affected by two main sources of uncertainty: one derives from the estimation of the velocity index and the other from the obtainable resolution of the Fourier analysis. This resolution strongly controls the observation of depth and/or velocity variations in space and in time. The technique has advantages over current approaches: it has clear physical foundations; the equipment is low cost and is highly mobile; it does not need artificial tracers or physical equipment to measure depth; and it can directly provide estimates of the key flow parameters just from time series of images of the water surface.
22 January 2024 in River Research and Applications
Rivers with alluvial bars store more wood than those without, supplied through channel shifting. However, wood dynamics (arrival or new deposits, departure or entrainment, and stable or immobile pieces) can vary substantially over time in response to critical hydrological drivers that are largely unknown. To evaluate them, we studied the dynamics of large wood pieces and logjams along a 12‐km reach of the lower Allier River using six series of aerial images of variable resolution acquired between 2009 and 2020, during which maximum river discharge fluctuated around the dominant flood discharge (Q1.5) that is potentially the bankfull discharge along this well‐preserved not incised reach. Individual wood departure was best correlated with water levels exceeding dominant flood discharge. The duration of the highest magnitude flood was best correlated with wood depositions, with shorter floods resulting in a higher number of deposits. Finally, most of the wood remained stable when river discharge did not exceed 60% of Q1.5 over a long period of time. Changes in inter‐annual wood budget (reach‐scale) depend on the duration over which discharge exceeded 60% of Q1.5. Hydrological conditions driving jam build‐up and removal were similar to those controlling individual wood piece dynamics. The results suggest that specific hydrological conditions influence the dynamics of large wood and log jams in the Allier River. Understanding the dynamics of large wood and its impact on river morphology is fundamental for successful river management and habitat restoration initiatives.
Recognition of the important physical and ecological roles played by large wood in channels and on floodplains has grown substantially during recent decades. Although large wood continues to be routinely removed from many river corridors worldwide, the practice of wood reintroduction has spread across the United States, the United Kingdom and western Europe, Australia, and New Zealand. The state‐of‐science regarding working with wood in rivers was discussed during a workshop held in Colorado, USA, in September 2022 with 40 participants who are scientists and practitioners from across the USA, UK, Europe, and Japan. The objectives of this paper are to present the findings from the workshop; summarize two case studies of wood in river restoration in the western United States; and provide suggestions for advancing the practice of wood in river management. We summarize the workshop results based on participant judgements and recommendations with respect to: (i) limitations and key barriers to using wood, which reflect perceptions and practicalities; (ii) gaps in the use of large wood in river management; (iii) scenarios in which wood is generally used effectively; and (iv) scenarios in which wood is generally not used effectively. The case studies illustrate the importance of the local geomorphic context, the configuration complexity of the wood, and the potential for modification of river corridor morphology to enhance desired benefits. Moving forward, we stress the importance of collaboration across disciplines and across communities of research scientists, practitioners, regulators, and potential stakeholders; accounting for stakeholder perceptions of the use of large wood; and increasing non‐scientist access to the latest state‐of‐science knowledge.
1 January 2024 in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
Large wood plays a significant role in fluvial ecosystems, influencing river geomorphology and ecology. However, it poses both benefits to river systems and risks, making it essential to understand its dynamics for effective management. A better understanding the wood breakdown process is required to evaluate the flood risk of wood in rivers. This paper aims to evaluate early‐stage fragmentation of wood in rivers after being recruited through bank erosion, taking into account its mobility and residence time. Two methods for characterising and monitoring wood fragmentation are suggested and compared: 1) photo‐interpretation based on ground and drone photo and 2) terrestrial LiDAR. We used Quantitative Structure Modelling (QSM) of point clouds to accurately simulate the full branching structure of trees. Close relationships exist between photo‐interpreted and LiDAR‐derived complexity metrics, but a scaled parameter (i.e., diameter) is needed to correlate branching complexity with volume. The debranching process occurs quickly, with a median reduction in branching complexity of over 80% within the initial 2 years. Further research with a larger sample size is necessary to investigate the impact of context – including transportation, submersion, accumulation, and isolation of wood pieces – on the fragmentation process. Field observations indicate that immobile wood pieces can experience a rapid reduction in their branching complexity, similar to the ones that are transported. Partial fine branching structure can be maintained on transported pieces. Both photo‐interpretation and terrestrial LiDAR offer complimentary approaches to monitoring wood fragmentation. Photo‐interpretation is easily implementable and may be used as a proxy for mechanical fragmentation, while terrestrial LiDAR may be used to monitor 3D wood fragmentation, volume and length evolution, following QSM modelling.
8 December 2022 in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms
Wood is an integral part of rivers that can have both positive and negative impacts on natural systems and infrastructures. Different techniques have been developed to quantify wood flux or discharge in rivers. Among them, the stream‐side video monitoring technique has proven effective for at‐a‐station wood monitoring with a high temporal and spatial resolution over an indefinite time period. However, the visual annotation of wood pieces in the videos is subject to uncertainties due to observer bias or ‘vision limitations’, and video sampling or ‘time limitations. Vision limitations mean that there are patches in the recorded image that may or may not be considered as wood pieces depending on the judgement of the observer. Time limitations mean that the video record may be sampled to estimate the wood flux rather than completing a census of the full record due to the time‐consuming nature of continuous visual annotation. To assess these uncertainties, six flood events and 13 video segments corresponding to more than 37 days and 64,000 pieces of wood were analysed on two different rivers (Ain and Allier Rivers in France). The results show that while there is a significant difference between observers for the detection of small wood pieces (< 1 m in length), no significant difference exists for the detection of large wood pieces (> 1 m in length). The application of a truncation length (i.e., considering only wood pieces with a size higher than a certain threshold) reduces the piece number uncertainty significantly without resulting in a meaningful change in the total volume of wood. For the time limitation, it is shown that sampling uncertainty depends on wood flux related to water discharge and flood stages (rising versus falling), so a dynamic sampling strategy that depends on flood stage is recommended.