The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) has played a fundamental role in our understanding of the world, and has applications across a broad range of disciplines. The introduction of PCR into forensic science marked the beginning of a new era of DNA profiling. This era has pushed PCR to its limits and allowed genetic data to be generated from trace DNA. Trace samples contain very small amounts of degraded DNA associated with inhibitory compounds and ions. Despite significant development in the PCR process since it was first introduced, the challenges of profiling inhibited and degraded samples remain. This review examines the evolution of the PCR from its inception in the 1980s, through to its current application in forensic science. The driving factors behind PCR evolution for DNA profiling are discussed along with a critical comparison of cycling conditions used in commercial PCR kits. Newer PCR methods that are currently used in forensic practice and beyond are examined, and possible future directions of PCR for DNA profiling are evaluated.
The use of PCR is widespread in biological fields. Some fields, such as forensic biology, push PCR to its limits as DNA profiling may be required in short timeframes, may be produced from minute amounts of starting material, and may be required to perform in the presence of inhibitory compounds. Due to the extreme high-throughput of samples using PCR in forensic science, any small improvement in the ability of PCR to address these challenges can have dramatic effects for the community. At least part of the improvement in PCR performance could potentially come by altering PCR cycling conditions. These alterations could be general, in that they are applied to all samples, or they could be tailored to individual samples for maximum targeted effect. Further to this, there may be the ability to respond in real time to the conditions of PCR for a sample and make cycling parameters change on the fly. Such a goal would require both a means to track the conditions of the PCR in real time, and the knowledge of how cycling parameters should be altered, given the current conditions. In Part 1 of our work, we carry out the theoretical groundwork for the ambitious goal of creating a smart PCR system that can respond appropriately to features within individual samples in real time. We approach this task using an open qPCR instrument to provide real-time feedback and machine learning to identify what a successful PCR ‘looks like’ at different stages of the process. We describe the fundamental steps to set up a real-time feedback system, devise a method of controlling PCR cycling conditions from cycle to cycle, and to develop a system of defining PCR goals, scoring the performance of the system towards achieving those goals. We then present three proof-of-concept studies that prove the feasibility of this overall method. In a later Part 2 of our work, we demonstrate the performance of the theory outlined in this paper on a large-scale PCR cycling condition alteration experiment. The aim is to utilise machine learning so that throughout the process of PCR automatic adjustments can be made to best alter cycling conditions towards a user-defined goal. The realisation of smart PCR systems will have large-scale ramifications for biological fields that utilise PCR.
28 April 2024 in Australian Journal of Forensic Sciences
The introduction of PCR into forensic science and the rapid increases in the sensitivity, specificity and discrimination power of DNA profiling that followed have been fundamental in shaping the field of forensic biology. Despite these developments, the challenges associated with the DNA profiling of trace, inhibited and degraded samples remain. Thus, any improvement to the performance of sub-optimal samples in DNA profiling would be of great value to the forensic community. The potential exists to optimise the PCR performance of samples by altering the cycling conditions used. If the effects of changing cycling conditions upon the quality of a DNA profile can be well understood, then the PCR process can be manipulated to achieve a specific goal. This work is a proof-of-concept study for the development of a smart PCR system, the theoretical foundations of which are outlined in part 1 of this publication. The first steps needed to demonstrate the performance of our smart PCR goal involved the manual alteration of cycling conditions and assessment of the DNA profiles produced. In this study, the timing and temperature of the denaturation and annealing stages of the PCR were manually altered to achieve the goal of reducing PCR runtime while maintaining an acceptable quality and quantity of DNA product. A real-time feedback system was also trialled using an STR PCR and qPCR reaction mix, and the DNA profiles generated were compared to profiles produced using the standard STR PCR kits. The aim of this work was to leverage machine learning to enable real-time adjustments during a PCR, allowing optimisation of cycling conditions towards predefined user goals. A set of parameters was found that yielded similar results to the standard endpoint PCR methodology but was completed 30 min faster. The development of an intelligent system would have significant implications for the various biological disciplines that are reliant on PCR technology.
23 July 2025 in Forensic Science International: Genetics
An initial step in the development of a smart PCR machine, capable of amending the cycling parameters when amplifying STR alleles, is to monitor PCR progression in real-time. Performing qPCR allows for the real-time monitoring and recording of amplification of control loci: comprised of a small and large amplicon, a positive control, and a section of the Y chromosome. This qPCR data enables the recording of degradation and inhibition, as the fluorescence during qPCR theoretically should follow an exponential increase. Hypothetically, combining qPCR with STR amplification would allow real-time quantification of fluorescence such that the parameters of the PCR could be modified to optimise STR amplification: fluorescence below expectation would indicate a need to amend the PCR parameters to improve the DNA amplification. In this study, two different commercially available qPCR kits were combined separately with one of four different STR kits, and the resulting STR profile quality was recorded. Controls were performed by amplifying the same quantity of DNA template for each of the four STR kits, with all standard single and combined amplifications performed five times, resulting in 60 amplifications in total. No significant decrease in profile quality or likelihood ratios were recorded for any of the combinations. There were no adverse effects on the STR amplification when performed on a real-time PCR machine, despite two different enzymes and the presence of additional primers requiring differing temperatures to bind. These data are needed as the first step towards a smart PCR machine that can adjust cycling parameters in real-time.