The mechanisms that influence human longevity are complex and operate on cellular, tissue, and organismal levels. To better understand the tissue-level mechanisms, we compared the organization of cell proliferation, differentiation, and cytoprotective protein expression in the squamous epithelium of the esophagus between mammals with varying lifespans. Humans are the only species with a quiescent basal stem cell layer that is distinctly physically separated from parabasal transit-amplifying cells. In addition to these stark differences in the organization of proliferation, human squamous epithelial stem cells express DNA repair-related markers, such as MECP2 and XPC, which are absent or low in mouse basal cells. Furthermore, we investigated whether the transition from basal to suprabasal is different between species. In humans, the parabasal cells seem to originate from cells detaching from the basement membrane, and these can already begin to proliferate while delaminating. In most other species, delaminating cells have been rare or their proliferation rate is different from that of their human counterparts, indicating an alternative mode of how stem cells maintain the tissue. In humans, the combination of an elevated cytoprotective signature and novel tissue organization may enhance resistance to aging and prevent cancer. Our results point to enhanced cellular cytoprotection and a tissue architecture which separates stemness and proliferation. These are both potential factors contributing to the increased fitness of human squamous epithelia to support longevity by suppressing tumorigenesis. However, the organization of canine oral mucosa shows some similarities to that of human tissue and may provide a useful model to understand the relationship between tissue architecture, gene expression regulation, tumor suppression, and longevity.