In this study, CoNiV-reinforced AMCs were fabricated by spark plasma sintering at 475°C and 500°C. The results show that, at 475°C, only a thin Al(Co, Ni, V) solid solution forms at the interface, whereas at 500°C, a continuous Al₃(Co, Ni, V) intermetallic layer with a thickness of 5–8 μm is formed. This intermetallic phase endows the composite with excellent strength–ductility synergy, resulting in increases of approximately 155% in ultimate tensile strength and 167% in elongation to fracture. In the 475°C sample, cracks preferentially initiate at interfacial defects and propagate along the interface between the Al matrix and CoNiV particles, exhibiting a distinct crack path. In contrast, in the 500°C sample, cracks tend to nucleate at the interface between the core-shell structure and the Al matrix, propagating along weakly bonded regions, which results in a more tortuous crack path. On this basis, a comparison between the MD-based core-shell model and the shell-free model reveals that the core-shell model is more prone to the formation of voids and micro-cracks during tensile deformation. However, intermetallic phases enhance the material's performance by impeding void growth and crack coalescence; they achieve this by increasing the tortuosity of crack paths, hindering dislocation motion, and promoting stress transfer across interfaces. These findings providing guidance for interfacial design and property optimization.