The implementation of Building Information Modeling (BIM) technology is advancing within the construction industry. However, there are several risks and challenges associated with the implementation process. Nowadays, there is a lack of research on management strategies to minimize or eradicate these risk factors. The objective of this work is to assess and select the most appropriate theoretical framework to examine the interrelations between risk factors and management strategies based on the publications available in Scopus and Google Scholar. Information has been processed using NVivo 12 Pro software via thematic and content analysis to extract risk factors and suitable theories/theoretical lens. The analysis reveals that the DeLone and McLean information systems (IS) success model is appropriate to examine risk factors within technical aspects from a single-dimensional perspective, while the Socio-technical system theory is preferred for considering socio-technical aspects from a multidimensional perspective. Thus, the new approach merges two concepts, namely, BIM-based construction networks and Leavitt socio-technical model, to analyze the situation in a more holistic manner. This article explores the theoretical concepts of risks in the BIM implementation and various methodological approaches from previous BIM and other information technology (IT)-related studies. The findings provide evidence from a single-dimensional perspective extending to areas with limited research such as the amalgamated aspects. Therefore, they establish a robust and adaptable theoretical framework with global relevance contributing to the generation of new knowledge. Further research is recommended to assess the financial and contractual theories for verification in BIM studies.
Building Information Modelling (BIM) represents a technological and organisational innovation transforming the architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) industry by embedding data-rich collaboration into project delivery. However, the diffusion of this innovation is constrained by unresolved legal–contractual complexities, where conventional frameworks often fail to manage BIM-specific risks, such as unclear responsibilities, intellectual property, and dispute resolution. This study advances knowledge by conceptualising a novel legal–contractual analytical dimension that systematically links risk factors to tailored management strategies, enabling BIM innovation to be more effectively embedded into organisational and contractual processes. A mixed-methods design was adopted. An integrative review of Scopus- and Google Scholar-indexed studies, supported by thematic analysis in NVivo, generated a comprehensive legal–contractual Risk Breakdown Structure (RBS) that organises fragmented knowledge of legal–contractual risks. Qualitative content analysis, combined with survey and expert interview data, enabled triangulated validation and the development of the BIM-RBS Matrix and BIM-RBS–MS Nexus. These tools operationalise risk knowledge by quantifying risk severity (SPSS Version 29.0.1.0 (171)) and systematically aligning management strategies with specific risk categories. The results highlight actionable innovations, such as enhanced cybersecurity protocols (e.g., QR-based traceability) to strengthen cyber/data security and collaborative risk–reward mechanisms to address contractual design ambiguities. The study makes three primary contributions: (1) conceptualising a structured legal–contractual knowledge spectrum for BIM innovation, (2) advancing mixed-methods integration for legal–contractual risk knowledge creation and validation, and (3) providing actionable frameworks that support industry, policymakers, and researchers in embedding BIM innovation more reliably. This study frames legal–contractual risk knowledge as a critical enabler of innovation that extends theoretical understanding and offers globally relevant pathways for the knowledge-based transformation of the AEC sector.
The construction industry is moving towards the era of industry 4.0; 5.0 with Building Information Modelling (BIM) as the tool gaining significant traction owing to its inherent advantages such as enhancing construction design, process and data management. However, the integration of BIM presents risks that are often overlooked in project implementation. This study aims to develop a novel amalgamated dimensional factor (Techno-organisational Aspect) that is set out to identify and align appropriate management strategies to these risks. Firstly, it encompasses an in-depth analysis of BIM and risk management, through an integrative review approach. The study utilises an exploratory-based review centred around journal articles and conference papers sourced from Scopus and Google Scholar. Then processed using NVivo 12 Pro software to categorise risks through thematic analysis, resulting in a comprehensive Risk Breakdown Structure (RBS). Then qualitative content analysis was employed to identify and develop management strategies. Further data collection via online survey was crucial for closing the research gap identified. The analysis by mixed method research enabled to determine the risk severity via the quantitative approach using SPSS, while the qualitative approach linked management strategies to the risk factors. The findings accentuate the crucial linkages of key strategies such as version control system that controls BIM data repository transactions to mitigate challenges controlling transactions in multi-model collaborative environment. The study extends into underexplored amalgamated domains (techno-organisational spectrum). Therefore, a significant contribution to bridging the existing research gap in understanding the intricate relationship between BIM implementation risks and effective management strategies.
The construction industry is moving towards the era of industry 4.0; 5.0 with Building Information Modelling (BIM) as the tool gaining significant traction owing to its inherent advantages such as enhancing construction design, process and data management. However, the integration of BIM presents risks that are often overlooked in project implementation. This study aims to develop a novel amalgamated dimensional factor (Techno-organizational Aspect) that is set out to identify and align appropriate management strategies to these risks. Firstly, it encompasses an in-depth analysis of BIM and risk management, through an integrative review approach. The study utilizes an exploratory-based review centered around journal articles and conference papers sourced from Scopus and Google Scholar. Then processed using NVivo 12 Pro software to categorise risks through thematic analysis, resulting in a comprehensive Risk Breakdown Structure (RBS). Then qualitative content analysis was employed to identify and develop management strategies. Further data collection via online survey was crucial for closing the research gap identified. The analysis by mixed method research enabled to determine the risk severity via the quantitative approach using SPSS (version 29), while the qualitative approach linked management strategies to the risk factors. The findings accentuate the crucial linkages of key strategies such as version control system that controls BIM data repository transactions to mitigate challenges controlling transactions in multi-model collaborative environment. The study extends into underexplored amalgamated domains (techno-organisational spectrum). Therefore, a significant contribution to bridging the existing research gap in understanding the intricate relationship between BIM implementation risks and effective management strategies.
Building Information Modelling (BIM) represents a technological and organisational innovation transforming the architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) industry by embedding data-rich collaboration into project delivery. However, the diffusion of this innovation is constrained by unresolved legal-contractual complexities, where conventional frameworks fail to manage BIM-specific risks such as unclear responsibilities, intellectual property, and dispute resolution. This study advances knowledge and practice by conceptualising a novel legal-contractual amalgamated dimensional factor that links identified risks with tailored management strategies, thereby enabling BIM innovation to be embedded more effectively into organisational processes. A mixed-methods design was adopted. An integrative review of Scopus- and Google Scholar-indexed studies, supported by thematic analysis in NVivo, generated a comprehensive Risk Breakdown Structure (RBS) that organises fragmented knowledge of legal-contractual risks. Qualitative content analysis, combined with survey and expert interview data, enabled triangulated validation and the development of the BIM-RBS Matrix and BIM-RBS–MS Nexus. These tools operationalise risk knowledge by ranking severity (SPSS) and aligning management strategies with specific risk categories. The results highlight actionable innovations such as QR-code protocols to strengthen cyber/data security and shared risk–reward mechanisms to address contractual design ambiguities. The study contributions are: (1) conceptualising a structured legal-contractual knowledge spectrum for BIM innovation, (2) advancing methodological integration for risk knowledge creation and validation, and (3) providing actionable frameworks that support industry, policymakers, and researchers in embedding BIM innovation more reliably. Framing legal-contractual risk knowledge as critical enabler of innovation extends theoretical understanding, offering globally relevant pathways for knowledge-based transformation of the AEC sector.