The adhesion of joining engineering plastics to the surface of aluminum components depends on the characteristics of the interface. Using first-principles density functional theory (DFT), the adsorption, surface reconstruction, and local bond stiffness of six polymer-constituent adatoms (H, C, N, O, Si, and S) are investigated at the top, bridge, hcp, and fcc sites of pristine and vacancy-defective Al(111) surfaces. All adatoms favor the threefold hollow sites, and the average adatom-aluminum bond length changes with the atomic radius, while C, N, and Si lead to the strongest first-layer reconstruction. The electronegative atoms N and O bind most strongly (about-7.9 eV), and a single surface vacancy effectively traps the adatoms C, N, and O with small covalent radii below the surface plane, marking the incipient stages of oxide, nitride, and carbide formation. Furthermore, the vertical bond stiffness is found to be inversely correlated with the binding strength. The top site with low coordination yields the stiffest but weakest bond and the highest vibrational frequency (up to 1679 cm-1 for H), while the stable hollow sites present softer bonds. Electron localization function and crystal orbital Hamilton population analyses corelate this inverse relationship to bond directionality which governs the bond stiffness, and to the total covalent overlap which governs the binding strength.