Expanding the WBE footprint to include low-resource settings where small, informal, and ad-hoc wastewater systems and high burdens of disease are co-located requires resource-efficient and adaptable methods. To that end, we deployed passive samplers made of granular activated carbon (GAC) into raw influent at a small wastewater treatment plant continuously over 90 days. Detections of SARS-CoV-2 RNA, respiratory syncytial virus RNA, and human adenovirus DNA on GAC passive samplers were coincident with regional clinical trends during a low-incidence period. GAC also recovered bacterial DNA, including mapA, a gene associated with Campylobacter jejuni. A set of antibiotic resistance genes – tetW, blaTEM, blaCTX – were also quantified from GAC passive samplers and did not show increased relative abundance over exposure durations up to 168 hours. Sequencing of 16S rRNA amplicons indicated the GAC samplers recovered bacterial families abundant in both wastewater and feces. Over 38 deployments up to 168 hours long, the average uptake rate decayed exponentially with exposure duration for 16S rRNA (R2 = 0.972), pepper mild mottle virus (R2 = 0.882), and human adenovirus (R2 = 0.585). GAC passive samplers may afford a resource-efficient approach to producing quantitative data for a wide variety of infectious agents relevant to WBE.
We surveyed 310 household-based Arsenic Iron Removal Plants (AIRPs) in the 11 most water-challenged areas of Bangladesh to gather evidence on year-round water availability, functionality, and institutional support for finance, training, operations, and maintenance. A conceptual framework was developed to identify the factors related to the functionality of AIRPs. Multivariable logistic regression revealed that the physical properties of AIRP-treated water, user tariffs, willingness to pay, professional cleaning services, and capacity-building support were significantly associated with AIRP functionality (p < 0.05). AIRP systems that have been in place for over eight years have a 10-fold higher failure rate than those installed in the recent past. AIRPs connected to wells with adequate water yield are more than 6.4 times as likely to remain functional as those connected to wells with insufficient yield. AIRPs with treated water used for multiple purposes (cooking and drinking) are 6.2 times more likely to remain functional than those used exclusively for drinking. An AIRP system with someone responsible for day-to-day upkeep is 4.4 times more likely to function than one without such responsibility. This study offers insights for enhancing existing AIRP intervention programs in water-stressed rural areas of Bangladesh.
Decentralized wastewater treatment systems afford a unique opportunity to implement a One Water paradigm through water reuse and resource recovery. Simultaneously, poorly managed on-site wastewater treatment systems (OWTSs) pose significant threats to human health, although their role in environmental antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is understudied. We deployed culture-based methods adapted from the World Health Organization’s Tricycle Protocol to assess the potential role of OWTSs in discharging third generation cephalosporin-resistant E. coli (3GCR-Ec) and extended-spectrum beta lactamase-producing E. coli (ESBL-Ec). We detected 3GCR-Ec in 74% of ATU effluents (geometric mean of 440 CFU/100 mL) and ESBL-Ec in 19%. E. coli isolates in these effluents were resistant to an average of 4.11 antibiotic compounds. ESBL-Ec were detected in up to 19% of surface water samples from rivers known to be impacted by OWTS discharges. Human sewage marker abundance was significantly higher in samples containing 3GCR-Ec (p = 0.0026) and ESBL-Ec (p = 0.0121) and the proportion of samples positive for 3GCR-Ec was strong correlated with river discharge percentile (r > 0.67, p < 0.0292). Our findings emphasize the unique human-environment interface of decentralized wastewater treatments systems must be carefully considered in both One Health and One Water paradigms to safely and sustainably meet our needs.
Given the lack of publications establishing the comparability of dPCR measurements for water quality assessment, we performed a robust comparison of Qiacuity and Absolute Q dPCR platforms for detecting and quantifying HF183/BacR287, Entero1a, and EC23S857 using a certified reference material (SRM 2917) and water-sample derived DNA (n = 10). For experiments with SRM 2917, both platforms demonstrated very strong qualitative and quantitative agreement (intraclass correlation coefficients, ICC > 0.96) with comparable precision down to 1.5 – 1.8 log10 GC/reaction (coefficient of variation < 30%) and comparable 95% LODs for each assay (range 4.5 – 10 GC/reaction). During experiments with water samples, both platforms demonstrated strong repeatability among dPCR replicates both within and between platforms (Pearson correlation coefficient > 0.95) and strong quantitative agreement (ICC > 0.84). However, Qiacuity detected HF183/BacR287 more frequently than Absolute Q when results were considered at the dPCR technical replicate (p = 0.0005) or filter replicate level (p = 0.0020) and target abundance was less than 100 GC/100 mL. Nonetheless, in the context of the large uncertainties inherent to interpreting and applying molecular data for water quality management, we conclude that for the assays considered, Qiacuity and Absolute Q would not lead to meaningfully different water quality measurements.