18 December 2010 in Journal of Ornithology
28 October 2013 in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
Summary: Survival is often estimated from capture–recapture data using Cormack–Jolly–Seber (CJS) models, where mortality and emigration cannot be distinguished, and the estimated apparent survival probability is the product of the probabilities of true survival and of study area fidelity. Consequently, apparent survival is lower than true survival unless study area fidelity equals one. Underestimation of true survival from capture–recapture data is a main limitation of the method. We develop a spatial version of theCJSmodel that allows estimation of true survival. Besides the information aboutwhethera specific individual was encountered at a given occasion, it is often recordedwherethe encounter occurred. Thus, information is available about the fraction of dispersal that occurs within the study area, and we use it to model dispersal and estimate true survival. Our model is formulated hierarchically and consists of survival, dispersal and observation submodels, assuming that encounters are possible anywhere within a study area. In a simulation study, our new spatialCJSmodel produced accurate estimates of true survival and dispersal behaviour for various sizes and shapes of the study area, even if emigration is substantial. However, when the information about dispersal is scarce due to low survival, low recapture probabilities and high emigration, the estimators are positively biased. Moreover, survival estimates are sensitive to the assumed dispersal kernel. We applied the spatialCJSmodel to a data set of adult red‐backed shrikes (Lanius collurio). Apparent survival of males (c. 0·5) estimated with theCJSmodel was larger than in females (c. 0·4), but the application of the spatialCJSmodel revealed that both sexes had similar survival probabilities (c. 0·6). The mean breeding dispersal distance in females wasc. 700 m, while males dispersed onlyc. 250 m between years. SpatialCJSmodels enable study of dispersal and survival independent of study design constraints such as imperfect detection and size of the study area provided that some of the dispersing individuals remain in the study area. We discuss possible extensions of our model: alternative dispersal models and the inclusion of covariates and of a habitat suitability map.
23 June 2005 in Journal of Animal Ecology
Summary: The environmental conditions that migratory birds experience during their stay at different locations throughout the year can have significant impact on the variation of annual survival rates. Because migrants often crowd during non‐breeding, environmental conditions can affect survival rates of individuals originating from different breeding populations, thus also provoking spatial synchronisation of annual survival rates. The identification of critical environmental factors affecting survival is therefore crucial for understanding large‐scale population dynamics of migrants. We studied temporal and spatial variation of survival rates of migratory white storkCiconia ciconiafrom eastern Germany and Poland and examine factors associated with this variation. We used resighting and dead‐recovery data from more than 30 000 individuals sampled over 19 years to estimate survival. Survival rates of juvenile and adult white storks originating from the two countries varied in parallel over time. Thus, variation in survival was caused by environmental variation to which individuals of both age classes from both countries were similarly sensitive. Variation in the primary production (as reflected by the normalized difference vegetation index) at one staging area in the eastern Sahel that is visited from October to November contributed up to 88% to the temporal variation in survival. Annual survival was reduced when primary production in the Sahel was low. As the population growth rate of white storks is very sensitive to changes in survival, variation in primary production in the Sahelian staging area contributed significantly to population changes and is likely to be an important reason for population synchrony. This study demonstrates that dynamics of migratory bird populations inhabiting large breeding areas can result from environmental variation encountered at a staging area that is visited for only a short period of time.
1 October 2000 in Journal of Ornithology