The aim of this article was to create key indicators for measuring the implementation potential of the green economy transition at a local level in a northernmost, natural biomass-rich environment. The case area to test the set of indicators was the village of Saija in Lapland. The work presented in this article is based on a communicative cooperative research and development project. The selection process for the appropriate indicators is based on a conceptual framework for developing local sustainability indicators and the thematic framework follows the key dimensions of the green economy (ecosystem resilience, resource efficiency and social equity). When selecting the local-level indicators, a strong emphasis was placed on the special characteristics of the local area and the availability and validity of the data. Layman villagers and data policy relevance (in this case green economy) were also taken into consideration. The key indicators developed as a result included: the increment of growing forest stock in relation to the drain on growing forest stock, the village population, the bioenergy consumption share, the utilization share of side streams, the bioenergy production potential, capital outflow, demographic dependency ratio, the ratio between employed and working age residents and the number of forest owners in relation to area households. The key indicators are targeted for use in supporting local decision-making and monitoring and assessing development activities and their effectiveness in the process of the green economy transition. The indicators measure the most critical factors for green economy transition in a local area and identify the most optimal development opportunities when moving towards green growth. In the measurement of the transition potential of the green economy, it was found that the case area’s imported fossil energy consumption could be substituted with self-sufficient bioenergy production utilizing the area’s own raw materials. There is extensive potential for the utilization of manure (an agricultural side stream) and forest resources (forestry side streams) at the local level, especially since forests account for 98% of Lapland’s land area. In support of the change from fossil-based energy consumption towards bioenergy production, plans for a biogas plant were examined for self-sufficient bioenergy production and this appeared to be the initial key process in the path of the green economy transformation in the case village of Saija.
Anaerobic digestion (AD) combines waste management with the production of renewable energy and recycled fertiliser products. Despite international targets to increase the recycling of nutrients for bio-based fertilisers (BBFs), there is a lack of studies assessing the environmental and economic impacts of the life cycle of digestate coming out of AD, and of associating the functional unit (FU) with the digestate, facilitating the comparability between mineral fertilisers. This study evaluated the environmental life cycle costs and climate impacts per FU of both biogas (MWh) and digestate (kg of soluble nitrogen) from feedstock procurement to the use on a farm (cradle-to-grave) which allowed comparison to purchased energy and mineral fertiliser. Three different farm-scale anaerobic digestion scenarios were studied utilizing slurry and different co-feedstocks. Results showed that biogas and digestate produced at farm had lower climate impacts and costs than the corresponding purchased products in all three scenarios. Valuing digestate as co-product decreased life cycle emissions of biogas by 24-29 %. Correspondingly, the carbon footprint of the digestate increased by 6-8% but was compensated by carbon sequestration potential when applied in soil. The NPV was positive for biogas and digestate product in all scenarios and highest for scenario utilising food industry side streams as co-feedstock. Monetising climate impacts increased the NPV of biogas and digestate because replaceable energy and mineral fertiliser had higher climate impacts. Product level analyses revealed different product-specific hot spots for biogas and digestate for targeted improvements in sustainability.
11 December 2025 in International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology
Purpose: Cattle production has substantial environmental impacts, especially from feed crop production and enteric fermentation. The climate change impacts of cattle-based products are already widely studied, yet other environmental impacts such as eutrophication and land use also require attention to avoid potential trade-offs. For a wider inclusion of sustainability dimensions and to direct the sustainability measures in Finnish dairy production more accurately, the effect of actions on environmental impacts but also on risks for social impacts is needed to be assessed. Methods: Dairy production scenarios were assessed using a Life Cycle Assessment for their effect on environmental impacts and risks for social impacts. Scenarios included two levels of concentrates, 45% and 35%, with typical grass-silage based mixed rations with rapeseed meal as controls. The scenarios focused on replacing imported inputs such as rapeseed meal with domestically produced leguminous crops: (1) half of the grass silage substituted with red clover (CL), (2) rapeseed meal substituted with faba beans (FB) and (3) a combination of the two (CL + FB). The inclusion of leguminous crops in dairy cow diets was also evaluated in terms of the pre-crop effects. Results: Regarding environmental impacts, the lowest emissions per cow were achieved with a 35% concentrate CL + FB ration. When the environmental impacts were assessed per kilogram of fat- and protein-corrected milk (FPCM), the 45% concentrate level had better environmental performance due to its higher productivity. For eutrophication potential 13–24% lower emissions were achieved in all scenarios compared to controls, largely due to nutrient-efficiency in clover and faba bean cultivation. At the product level, 45% concentrate levels showed lower eutrophication when corresponding mixed rations were compared, and CL and CL + FB consistently outperformed other scenarios. The land demand assessment showed slight differences; the lowest impacts were achieved with FB due to pre-crop effects. In terms of risks for social impacts, both FB and CL + FB exhibited lower risk levels compared to the control and CL. A more detailed examination of the social impact categories revealed four with the most significant differences in risk values: ‘Fair Salary’, ‘Industrial Water Depletion’, ‘Public Sector Corruption’, ‘Sanitation Coverage’. Conclusions: Overall, mixed rations with domestic legumes indicated improvement of the sustainability of dairy production as both the environmental impacts and risks for social impacts were reduced with their introduction. However, the milk yield played a key role. When introducing legumes in dairy cows’ diets, it is important to maintain a good level of productivity by optimizing mixed rations to avoid increased burdens at product level.