30 October 2018 in Annals of Biomedical Engineering
14 March 2019 in Annals of Biomedical Engineering
10 June 2021 in Journal of Neurotrauma
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is a significant public health burden, and the development of advanced countermeasures to mitigate and prevent these injuries during automotive, sports, and military impact events requires an understanding of the intracranial mechanisms related to TBI. In this study, the efficacy of tissue-level injury metrics for predicting TBI was evaluated using finite element reconstructions from a comprehensive, multi-species TBI database. The database consisted of human volunteer tests, laboratory-reconstructed head impacts from sports, in vivo non-human primate (NHP) tests, and in vivo pig tests. Eight tissue-level metrics related to brain tissue strain, axonal strain, and strain-rate were evaluated using survival analysis for predicting mild and severe TBI risk. The correlation between TBI risk and most of the assessed metrics were statistically significant, but when injury data was analyzed by species, the best metric was often inconclusive and limited by the small datasets. When the human and animal datasets were combined, the injury analysis was able to delineate maximum axonal strain as the best predictor of injury for all species and TBI severities, with maximum principal strain as a suitable alternative metric. The current study is the first to provide evidence to support the assumption that brain strain response between human, pig, and NHP result in similar injury outcomes through a multi-species analysis. This assumption is the biomechanical foundation for translating animal brain injury findings to humans. The findings in the study provide fundamental guidelines for developing injury criteria that would contribute towards the innovation of more effective safety countermeasures.
1 November 2014 in Experimental Neurology
1 July 2020 in Journal of Neurotrauma
Traumatic brain injuries (TBI) are a substantial societal burden. The development of better technologies and systems to prevent and/or mitigate the severity of brain injury requires an improved understanding of the mechanisms of brain injury, and more specifically, how head impact exposure relates to brain deformation. Biomechanical investigations have used computational models to identify these relations, but more experimental brain deformation data is needed to validate these models and support their conclusions. The objective of this study was to generate a dataset describing in situ human brain motion under rotational loading at impact conditions considered injurious. Six head-neck human post-mortem specimens, unembalmed and never frozen, were instrumented with 24 sonomicrometry crystals embedded throughout the parenchyma that can directly measure dynamic brain motion. Dynamic brain displacement, relative to the skull, was measured for each specimen with four loading severities in the three directions of controlled rotation, for a total of twelve tests per specimen. All testing was completed 42-72 hours post-mortem for each specimen. The final dataset contains approximately 5,000 individual point displacement time-histories that can be used to validate computational brain models. Brain motion was direction-dependent, with axial rotation resulting in the largest magnitude of displacement. Displacements were largest in the mid-cerebrum, and the inferior regions of the brain - the cerebellum and brainstem - experienced relatively lower peak displacements. Brain motion was also found to be positively correlated to peak angular velocity, and negatively correlated with angular velocity duration, a finding that has implications related to brain injury risk assessment methods. This dataset of dynamic human brain motion will form the foundation for the continued development and refinement of computational models of the human brain for predicting traumatic brain injury.
20 December 2019 in Journal of Neurotrauma
Scaling methods are used to relate animal exposure data to humans by determining equivalent biomechanical impact conditions that result in similar tissue-level mechanics for different species. However, existing scaling methods for traumatic brain injury (TBI) do not account for the anatomical and morphological complexity of the brains for different species and have not been validated based on accurate anatomy and realistic material properties. In this study, the relationship between the TBI condition and brain tissue deformation was investigated using human, baboon, and macaque brain finite element (FE) models, which featured macro- and mesoscale anatomical details. The aim was to evaluate existing scaling methods in predicting similar biomechanical responses in the different species using both idealized and real-world TBI pulses. A second aim was to develop a new method to improve how animal data are scaled to humans. As previously found in humans, the animal's brain response to the rotational head motion was well characterized by single-degree-of-freedom (sDOF) mechanical systems with resonance at certain natural frequency, and this concept was leveraged to develop a new TBI scaling method based the natural frequency of the sDOF models representing each species. Previously described biomechanical scaling methods based on mass or inertia ratios were poor predictors of equivalent strain. The novel frequency-based scaling method was an improved approach to scaling the equivalent loading conditions. The findings of this study enable better interpretation of mechanical-trauma responses obtained from animal data to the human, thus effectively advancing the development of human injury criteria and contributing toward the mitigation of TBI.