Significance: Forests worldwide have undergone rapid changes; however, understanding the causes of the changes has been a challenge. Climate on the regional scale has been overwhelmingly presumed to drive these changes, with little attention paid to the possible effects of competition. We compiled a long-term forest dataset from western Canada to study the relative importance of climate change and competition on tree growth, mortality, and recruitment. We showed that competition was the primary factor causing the long-term changes. Regional climate had a weaker yet significant effect on tree mortality, but no effect on tree growth and recruitment. This finding suggests that forest studies focused solely on the effects of climate may overlook the effect of other processes critical to forest dynamics.
Significance: The number of species in local ecological assemblages is constrained by competition and other local interactions between populations. However, ecologists have not agreed on the degree to which the unique history and geography of continental regions also influence local species richness. Here, based on forest plots distributed throughout the world, we show that the species richness of forest trees varies among continental regions independently of local climate. In particular, forest plots in Europe and North America contain fewer species than expected from the statistical relationship of diversity to present-day local climate. Thus, the number of species co-occurring locally reflects, to a significant extent, region characteristics, including geographic and geologic history, that influence evolutionary diversification and regional extinction.