Effective population size affects the efficacy of selection, rate of evolution by drift and neutral diversity levels. When species are subdivided into multiple populations connected by gene flow, evolutionary processes can depend on global or local effective population sizes. Theory predicts that high levels of diversity might be maintained by gene flow, even very low levels of gene flow, consistent with species long-term effective population size, but tests of this idea are mostly lacking. Here, we show that Lycaeides butterfly populations maintain low contemporary (variance) effective population sizes (e.g. ~200 individuals) and thus evolve rapidly by genetic drift. However, populations harboured high levels of genetic diversity consistent with an effective population size several orders of magnitude larger. We hypothesized that the differences in the magnitude and variability of contemporary versus long-term effective population sizes were caused by gene flow of sufficient magnitude to maintain diversity but only subtly affect evolution on generational timescales. Consistent with this hypothesis, we detected low but nontrivial gene flow among populations. Furthermore, using short-term population-genomic time-series data, we documented patterns consistent with predictions from this hypothesis, including a weak but detectable excess of evolutionary change in the direction of the mean (migrant gene pool) allele frequencies across populations and consistency in the direction of allele frequency change over time. The documented decoupling of diversity levels and short-term change by drift in Lycaeides has implications for our understanding of contemporary evolution and the maintenance of genetic variation in the wild.
Genes that affect adaptive traits have been identified, but our knowledge of the genetic basis of adaptation in a more general sense (across multiple traits) remains limited. We combined population-genomic analyses of evolve-and-resequence experiments, genome-wide association mapping of performance traits, and analyses of gene expression to fill this knowledge gap and shed light on the genomics of adaptation to a marginal host (lentil) by the seed beetle Callosobruchus maculatus. Using population-genomic approaches, we detected modest parallelism in allele frequency change across replicate lines during adaptation to lentil. Mapping populations derived from each lentil-adapted line revealed a polygenic basis for two host-specific performance traits (weight and development time), which had low to modest heritabilities. We found less evidence of parallelism in genotype-phenotype associations across these lines than in allele frequency changes during the experiments. Differential gene expression caused by differences in recent evolutionary history exceeded that caused by immediate rearing host. Together, the three genomic datasets suggest that genes affecting traits other than weight and development time are likely to be the main causes of parallel evolution and that detoxification genes (especially cytochrome P450s and beta-glucosidase) could be especially important for colonization of lentil by C. maculatus.
The degree or extent of gene reuse during repeated adaptation offers key insights into the genomic constraints on evolution. Although many studies have identified signs of genomic repeatability, a thorough synthesis of methods for detecting gene reuse and estimating its extent is missing. In this review, we first propose a simple framework for studies aimed at identifying gene reuse during repeated adaptation using genomic data. Next, we examine existing approaches to (i) detect gene set overlap, perform significance testing, and perform multivariate dimensionality reduction, (ii) distinguish between gene and allele reuse while emphasising methods for detecting allele reuse, (iii) explore models to identify the mechanisms behind repeated adaptation, and (iv) address issues and potential solutions to differentiate true gene reuse from methodological artifacts. Our review highlights standardised methods developed using genomic data to identify gene reuse. We also note that, although few studies quantify allele reuse, conducting such analyses is essential because it adds a more detailed layer to predicting evolutionary paths. Finally, several strategies can be used to cross‐validate signals of gene reuse. These should be applied to confirm true positives, as biological and methodological artifacts can bias predictions. By synthesizing current methods and outlining a robust analytical framework, we provide a roadmap for enhancing the accuracy and reliability of gene reuse detection in adaptive evolution.