Purpose To compare the effects of hearing aids and their technology levels (premium and basic) on attention, memory, brain response, and self‐perceived benefit amongst individuals who were naïve to sound amplification. Material and methods A pragmatic, single‐blinded, and randomised pilot clinical trial in three‐parallel arms according to hearing aids technology: (a) premium; (b) basic; and (c) no amplification hearing devices. Participants were ≥60 years old with mild‐to‐moderate sensorineural symmetric hearing loss and naïve to sound amplification. We tested attention and memory skills, as well as brain response and self‐perceived benefit before and after 12 weeks of using the hearing devices. The primary outcome was any improvement in the tests we performed. Results The participants who missed the follow‐up (n = 2) were excluded from our final analysis. We ended up with 22 patients (A = 8, B = 6, and C = 8) who were 80.4 (±6.1) years old, predominantly female (63.63%), and poorly educated (3.8 ± 1.6 years). After the intervention, we observed differences in attention and memory scores (reverse counting, P < .01, 95% CI 2.2; 11.63; digit sequence repetition, P = .03, 95% CI −1.9; −0.05; delayed recall, P = .03, 95% CI −1.2; −0.05; recognition, P < .01, 95% CI −2.6; −0.45; and visual memory, P < .01, 95% CI −0.9; −0.15), but only reverse counting (A vs C, P < .01,95% CI 5.9; 20.55) and recognition (B vs C, P < .01, 95% CI −6.1; −0.88) were observed in pairwise comparisons. The difference in N1 wave latency (/g/ sound, P = .01,95% CI 2.1; 18.59) could not be confirmed in pairwise comparison. The self‐perceived benefit questionnaire revealed no difference between groups A and B; the groups A and C differed in benefit (P < .01, 95% CI −2.2; −0.76), satisfaction (P = .02,95% CI ‐2.0;‐0.21), residual participation restrictions (P = .01, 95% CI −2.9; −0.38), and quality of life (P = .03, 95% CI −1.4; −0.08); the groups B and C differed in benefit (P < .001, 95% CI −2.3; −0.96), and satisfaction (P = .01,95% CI −2.1; −0.29). Conclusion In this study, premium and basic hearing aids impacted attention, memory, brain response, and self‐perceived benefit similarly amongst individuals who were naïve to sound amplification after 12 weeks of using the hearing devices.