Our article argues that non-human animals deserve to be treated as something more than property to be abused, exploited, or expended. Such an examination lies at the heart of green criminology and law—an intersection of which we consider more thoroughly. Drawing upon our respective and collective works, we endeavor to engage in a discussion that highlights the significance of green criminology for law and suggests how law can provide opportunities to further green criminological inquiry. How the law is acutely relevant for constituting the animal goes hand in glove with how humanness and animality are embedded deeply in the construction of law and society. We contend that, when paired together, green criminology and law have the potential to reconstitute the animal as something more than mere property within law, shed light on the anthropocentric logics at play within the criminal justice system, and promote positive changes to animal cruelty legislation. Scholarship could benefit greatly from moving into new lines of inquiry that emphasize “more-than-human legalities”. Such inquiry has the power to promote the advocacy-oriented scholarship of animal rights and species justice.
30 October 2020 in International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology
Drawing upon historical developments and legal interpretations of “crimes against nature” as it relates to bestiality, this paper endeavors to promote further discussions surrounding the conception of “natural” and/or extant law, by which an understanding of historical and modern objections to crimes against nature opens them up to the critique of thin-universalism—that is, that despite disparate socio-moral fundaments, laws of prohibition coalesce around evangelical totalities. We contend that a paradigm shift in respect of naturalness is necessitated—naturalness should be packaged and represented, in part, by the empirical. Thus, conceptions of vulnerability and sentience rooted in social scientific understandings and in hospitable forms of rights protections ought to provide a new understanding of governance of the natural. In turn, this naturalness ought to be reflected in law so long as the boundaries we propose are not unduly transgressed. If unnatural acts like bestiality have their prohibitions in the legal tethering points of Judeo-Christian and, later Victorian roots, the new natural law ought to be apprised of rights-based constitutionalism and informed by green criminological and animal rights logics. Law, apprised of these ethics, would evolve to expand protections for animals, human and non-human alike. Laws based on the new naturalness could protect species and environments as evidence demands.
Our chapter argues for the disciplines of criminology and law to collaborate on correctional research. As we suggest, both fields, while providing unique vantage points and insights on how prisons operate, care, and control over those incarcerated, can be brought together to foster progressive, creative, and innovate correctional research endeavors. The intersection of criminology and law is explored thoroughly by drawing upon our collective work examining Canadian federal corrections as it connects to Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD). We highlight the significance of criminology for law while also suggesting how law can provide prospects to advance criminological inquiry. When paired together, we contend that criminology and law have the potential to reconsider how Canadian law fails to address the needs and lived experiences of those incarcerated. Our efforts to scrutinize important Canadian case law reaffirm the need for criminology to take seriously case law-as-case study, while also questioning institutional deficits, further suffering, harm (legal, physical, and otherwise) and punishment for those incarcerated. Correctional scholarship could benefit greatly from moving into new lines of inquiry that emphasize overlapping and synergistic collaborations between criminology and law. Such inquiry has the power to advance new considerations for legal reform, sentencing patterns, and correctional preventative measures both within federal corrections and beyond.