Recent research has proved that most widely used two-equation turbulence closure models are unconditionally unstable in regions of nearly potential flow having finite strain, as commonly found beneath non-breaking surface waves. In this work, we extend such analysis to consider the popular realizable k–ε turbulence model. It is proved that this model, unlike all others thus far analyzed, is only conditionally unstable in such regions due to the addition of viscosity in the ε dissipation term. A method for formally stabilizing the model in the problematic regions is likewise developed. The results of the analysis, using both standard and stabilized turbulence closures, are confirmed via numerical simulations of progressive surface wave trains using a computational fluid dynamics model. Important qualitative differences are likewise demonstrated in simulations involving spilling breaking waves. (In the above, k is the turbulent kinetic energy density, and ε is the turbulence dissipation rate.)
Computational fluid dynamics is increasingly used to investigate the inherently complicated phenomenon of wave breaking. To date, however, no single model has proved capable of accurately simulating the breaking process across the entirety of the surf zone for both spilling and plunging breakers. The present study newly considers the Reynolds stress– $\omega$ turbulence closure model for this purpose, where $\omega$ is the specific dissipation rate. Novel stability analysis proves that, unlike two-equation closures (at least in their standard forms), the stress– $\omega$ model is neutrally stable in the idealized potential flow region beneath surface waves. It thus naturally avoids unphysical exponential growth of turbulence prior to breaking, which has plagued numerous prior studies. The analysis is confirmed through simulation of a progressive surface wave train. The stress– $\omega$ model is then applied to simulate a turbulent wave boundary layer, demonstrating superior accuracy relative to a two-equation model, especially during flow deceleration. Finally, the stress– $\omega$ model is employed to simulate spilling and plunging breaking waves, with seemingly unprecedented accuracy. Specifically, the present work marks the first time that a single turbulence closure model collectively: (1) avoids turbulence over-production prior to breaking, (2) accurately predicts the breaking point, (3) provides reasonable evolution of turbulent normal stresses, while also (4) yielding accurate evolution of undertow velocity structure and magnitude across the surf zone, for both spilling and plunging cases. Differences in the predicted Reynolds shear stresses (hence flow resistance) are identified as key to the improved inner surf zone performance, relative to a state-of-the-art two-equation model.
This work provides a novel approach that combines computational fluid dynamics (CFD) with computational solid mechanics (CSM) to dynamically simulate the fully coupled hydroelastic interaction between nonlinear ocean waves and a submerged horizontal plate breakwater (SHPB). Based on a systematic series of simulations, it is shown that the wave damping performance of an SHPB can be evidently improved by an appropriate extent of deformation, which can be achieved through the design of its bending stiffness by varying elasticity and/or aspect ratio. The wave attenuation effect is found to be maximized when an SHPB has a deformation amplitude close to the incident wave amplitude. By accounting for the hydroelastic effect through the fully coupled CFD+CSM approach, this work presents a new computational technique that supports the design of deformable offshore and coastal structures.
2 January 2024 in Environmental Science & Technology
Incipient wave breaking on a vertical circular pile is simulated with a Reynolds stress– $\omega$ turbulence model. Comparison of results simulated with a stabilized two-equation turbulence model, as well as no turbulence model, demonstrates that the breaking point and the peak force on a vertical cylinder due to incipient breaking should not be affected by the turbulence closure model, provided that it is stable and the simulations are converged. Notably, the present results show that the build-up to peak force induced by incipient wave breaking can be accurately predicted without any turbulence closure model. However, for the prediction of the secondary load cycle (SLC), proper turbulence modelling is required, as this process involves both turbulence production and lee-side flow separation. The Reynolds stress– $\omega$ model is demonstrated to predict the SLC more accurately than a stabilized two-equation $k$ – $\omega$ turbulence model, as the flow separation points and vorticity field are better predicted. Some existing studies indicate that the generation of the SLC does not necessarily result from flow separation, but is rather due to the suction force. The present work finds that the occurrence and point of flow separation significantly affect the magnitude of the suction force, which hence affects the SLC prediction significantly. For waves breaking on a vertical pile, proper turbulence modelling is therefore essential for accurate SLC predictions. (In the above, $k$ is the turbulent kinetic energy density and $\omega$ is the specific dissipation rate.)