Two-year field experiments were conducted at Tamil Nadu Rice Research Institute, Aduthurai, Tamil Nadu, India, to evaluate the effect of continuous flooding (CF) and alternate wetting and drying (AWD) irrigation strategies on rice grain yield and greenhouse gas emissions from double-cropping paddy rice. Field observation results showed that AWD irrigation was found to reduce the total seasonal methane (CH4) emission by 22.3% to 56.2% compared with CF while maintaining rice yield. By using the observed two-year field data, validation of the DNDC-Rice model was conducted for CF and AWD practices. The model overestimated rice grain yield by 24% and 29% in CF and AWD, respectively, averaged over the rice-growing seasons compared to observed values. The simulated seasonal CH4 emissions for CF were 6.4% lower and 4.2% higher than observed values and for AWD were 9.3% and 12.7% lower in the summer and monsoon season, respectively. The relative deviation of simulated seasonal nitrous oxide (N2O) emissions from observed emissions in CF were 27% and −35% and in AWD were 267% and 234% in the summer and monsoon season, respectively. Although the DNDC-Rice model reasonably estimated the total CH4 emission in CF and reproduced the mitigation effect of AWD treatment on CH4 emissions well, the model did not adequately predict the total N2O emission under water-saving irrigation. In terms of global warming potential (GWP), nevertheless there was a good agreement between the simulated and observed values for both CF and AWD irrigations due to smaller contributions of N2O to the GWP compared with that of CH4. This study showed that the DNDC-Rice model could be used for the estimation of CH4 emissions, the primary source of GWP from double-cropping paddy rice under different water management conditions in the tropical regions.
1 October 2013 in Soil Science and Plant Nutrition
We have estimated methane (CH4) emission from total rice (Oryza sativa L.) paddies in Japan by means of a process-based biogeochemistry model, DeNitrification-DeComposition(DNDC)-Rice, combined with a geographic information system (GIS) database of climate, soil and farming practices. In the GIS database, 2 million ha of rice paddies were divided into 17,408 units according to 136 climate areas, 16 soil types, four classes of drainage rate and two classes of groundwater level, to simulate CH4 flux from each of the units applying the DNDC-Rice model. As a result, the national-scale CH4 emission in 1990 was estimated to be 216 Gg carbon (C), 13% lower than a previous inventory estimated by the Tier 2 method. By our Tier 3 approach, a relatively higher CH4 flux was estimated from eastern regions than from western regions of Japan, presumably due to the differences in climate and water management. Sensitivity analysis and uncertainty assessment indicated that it is important to account for the heterogeneity in soil properties such as field water capacity, iron (Fe) concentration and drainage rate, in order to reduce the uncertainty in regional estimates.
The DNDC-Rice model effectively simulates yield and greenhouse gas emissions within a paddy system, while its performance under upland conditions remains unclear. Using data from a long-term cover crop experiment (fallow [FA] vs. rye [RY]) in a soybean field, this study validated the DNDC-Rice model’s performance in simulating soil dynamics, crop growth, and C-N cycling processes in upland systems through various indicators, including soil temperature, water-filled pore space (WFPS), soybean biomass and yield, CO2 and N2O fluxes, and soil organic carbon (SOC). Based on simulated results, the underestimation of cumulative N2O flux (25.6% in FA and 5.1% in RY) was attributed to both underestimated WFPS and the algorithm’s limitations in simulating N2O emission pulses. Overestimated soybean growth increased respiration, leading to the overestimation of CO2 flux. Although the model captured trends in SOC stock, the simulated annual values differed from observations (−9.9% to +10.1%), potentially due to sampling errors. These findings indicate that the DNDC-Rice model requires improvements in its N cycling algorithm and crop growth sub-models to improve predictions for upland systems. This study provides validation evidence for applying DNDC-Rice to upland systems and offers direction for improving model simulation in paddy-upland rotation systems, thereby enhancing its applicability in such contexts.
Biological N2 fixation (BNF) and ratoon rice growth are biological processes that mediate N and C cycling in rice paddy ecosystems, but their contributions to paddy soil fertility have rarely been evaluated in a quantitative and unified manner. In this study, we analyzed the contribution of BNF and ratoon rice growth to soil N fertility at six rice paddy sites in four prefectures of Japan, combining 2-year field monitoring and simulation using the DNDC-Rice biogeochemistry model. Across the sites and years, ratoon rice was found to accumulate up to 30 kg N ha−1 without fertilization and irrigation after main rice harvest. BNF was not measured but estimated to be 33–63 kg N ha−1 yr−1 at the six sites, by applying a newly built BNF model after calibration against a literature dataset. Based on the simulations using DNDC-Rice under typical local management strategies, we estimated the following contributions of BNF and ratoon rice to soil N fertility, with variations based on the climate, soil properties, and management, as follows: (a) BNF and ratoon rice contributed 4–33% and 3–23% of the N supply from soil during the main rice season, respectively. (b) While BNF contributed 3–29% of the main rice N uptake, that from ratoon rice was much lower (6% or less), presumably because the decomposition of ratoon rice residue induced N immobilization during the main rice season. (c) Although the major part of N gain by BNF was being lost via denitrification and N leaching, BNF was contributing up to 6.6% of the organic N pool at the 0–30 cm soil layer. Ratoon rice was working to save N loss by reducing N leaching, consequently contributing up to 3.3% of the soil N pool. These findings provide quantitative insights into what roles BNF and ratoon rice play in paddy soil fertility.