The dewatering of flocculated high density slurry presents a significant challenge to most mining industries. The new technologies to treat high density slurry require a consistent and robust flocculation method in order to enter the market of tailings management. The flocculation of high density slurry, however, due to its complexity, is always a challenge to be undertaken appropriately and to evaluate the dewatering performance correctly. This paper probes the complexity by using a torque-controlled mixing technique to demonstrate the influence of feed properties, polymer type, polymer dosage, and mixing conditions on dewatering performance. The study shows that flocculant should be dosed at the optimal range to achieve the highest dewatering performance. A full dosage responsive curve including under dosage, optimal dosage, and overdosage is critical to evaluate the dewatering performance of high density slurries and flocculants. The mixing conditions such as mixing speed, mixing time, and geometry of the mixing impeller affect the flocculation efficacy. It was found that the dewatering performance of high density slurry is sensitive to solids content, water chemistry, and clay activity. High sodicity and high clay activity in the high density slurry decreases the dewatering performance. Therefore, it is critical to evaluate flocculants across multiple feeds and dosages with replication in order to select optimal dewatering performance. Using multiple key performance indicators (KPIs) to build technical and economic criteria is also critical for polymer evaluation.