With the great progress of product development technology, product forms have been greatly enriched by cognitive differences; users and designers have formed a “cognitive friction” phenomenon in the product evaluation process, which results in designers being unable to grasp user emotions accurately and risks of product development failure. This paper aims to balance the cognitive differences between cognitive subjects (users and designers) and evaluates the product image form. First, image entropy is used to evaluate and extract the weight of the product target image. Second, fuzzy Theil entropy is used to evaluate the cognitive friction between cognitive subjects, and its existence and size are visually presented. Then, a cognitive friction balance model is built by combining game theory, the comprehensive evaluation weight between cognitive subjects is obtained, and the product image form is ranked and optimized. Finally, all the research steps are described in the form of a household hair dryer. The results show that fuzzy Theil entropy and game theory have significant advantages in the evaluation and balance of cognitive friction in product design. Thus, the cognitive friction evaluation and balance model constructed from the fuzzy Theil entropy and game theory do not only enable different cognitive subjects to achieve cognitive symmetry, but also screen out product forms that meet the cognitive needs of users. This finding provides the theoretical basis and practical significance for the establishment of a closed-loop model in cognitive friction balance and the reduction of cognitive differences between cognitive subjects in the entire process of product design. It also introduces new ways of thinking and methods for cognitive science research.
16 March 2022 in Multimedia Tools and Applications
The product form serves as a crucial information carrier for expressing design concepts and encompasses significant valuable references. During the product iteration process, changes in design subjects, such as designers and decision-makers, result in substantial variability and uncertainty in the direction of product form evolution. To address these issues, an evolutionary design method for product forms based on the gray Markov model and an evolutionary algorithm is proposed in this study. Firstly, quadratic curvature entropy is utilized to quantify historical form features of product evolution. Subsequently, the original data on product form feature evolution are fitted and predicted using the gray Markov model, thereby obtaining the predicted value of the latest generation of product form features, which is determined to be 0.14586. Finally, this study uses this predicted value to construct a fitness function in the framework of an evolutionary algorithm, which in turn identifies next-generation product forms that can stimulate designers’ creative thinking. The method’s application is illustrated using the side outer contour of the Audi A4 automobile as an example. The research findings demonstrate that combining the gray Markov model with an evolutionary algorithm can effectively simulate designers’ understanding of previous generations’ design concepts and achieve stable inheritance of these design concepts during product iteration. This approach mitigates the risk of abrupt changes in design concepts caused by designers and decision-makers due to personal cognitive biases, thereby enhancing product development efficiency.
Current design decision-making methods ignore the fuzzy relationship between Kansei images, and the use of constant weights reduces the accuracy of cognitive evaluation results. To solve these problems, this paper proposes a grey decision-making method for product form driven by the fuzzy relationship between Kansei images. First, according to the initial weight of the Kansei images, variable weight theory is used to determine the Kansei image variable weights of the samples, and the variable weight comprehensive evaluation results for each sample are obtained. Then, based on the correlation and angle of the Kansei images, a cobweb diagram is drawn to represent the fuzzy relationship between the Kansei images of each sample. Combined with the cobweb grey target decision-making model (CGTDM) for multiple Kansei images, decision coefficients are calculated. The decision coefficients are compared and ranked to determine the relatively optimal design reference sample. Finally, the constructed model is compared with the CGTDM for multiple Kansei images and TOPSIS. The results show that the difference coefficient of the proposed method is the largest, and it can reflect the decision-making thinking of the designers and improve the discrimination among the decision-making results to a certain extent.
Refined decision-making of the design intent is a key factor affecting the iterative design of complex equipment products. While current research on design intent decision-making generally emphasizes methodological innovation, it often neglects the individualized and fuzzy expressive characteristics of cognitive agents, as well as the actual status of the research object. This oversight leads to uncertainty in both design intent and design outcomes. To address these issues, in this paper, a refined decision-making method for the multimodal fuzzy design intent of complex products based on noncooperative–cooperative game serialization is proposed. First, through scenario analysis, the fuzzy design intent evaluation process of different cognitive agents is transformed into a cooperative game model based on a fuzzy network, achieving a preliminary assessment of design intent. On this basis, a noncooperative game-based refined matching and decision-making model for design intent across different dimensions is constructed, thereby completing the final design intent decision-making for a specific product model. Finally, the proposed method is applied to the design intent decision-making process of a CKA6180 CNC machine tool, yielding the conclusion that the two design intents of “good protective performance” and “grand appearance” should be prioritized, thereby verifying the practicality and effectiveness of the method. The analysis of the results reveals the following: ① The application of scenario analysis theory enables a more comprehensive and precise characterization of the design intents of different cognitive agents; ② The construction of a model combining a fuzzy network with a cooperative game facilitates a more complete representation and evaluation of multimodal fuzzy design intent data; ③ The integration of a refined design concept with a noncooperative game model leads to more definitive design intent decision outcomes, thereby reducing the “disturbance” of experience dependence in the early design phase and consequently enhancing subsequent design satisfaction.