Background: Concept maps are a valid assessment tool to explore student understanding of diverse topics. Many types of academic programs have integrated concept mapping into their courses, resulting in various activities and scoring methods to understand student perceptions.Purpose: Few prior reviews of concept mapping have addressed their use within engineering education. This systematic literature review examines articles that use concept mapping as an assessment tool in engineering education contexts and provides suggestions for future research.Scope/Method: We conducted a literature search using terms related to concept map and engineering education. Articles were screened by their title, abstract, section, and then full paper, resulting in 53 articles for the final review. Two researchers examined the topic, activity type, and scoring method of the maps.Results: Concept mapping topics fit into three categories, and the activity structures fit into four types. Of seven scoring methods, “Traditional” was the most used. Studies that compared multiple scoring methods showed that the “Holistic” and “Categorical” methods were better able to capture the content of the maps. All types of scoring demonstrated positive outcomes, suggesting that concept maps can demonstrate understanding of the topic and can assess learning.Conclusions: Concept maps have been applied in a number of ways. All types of concept mapping scores were shown to be useful and can lead to a better understanding of the students' learning outcomes. However, more research is needed to determine which scoring methods are recommended for specific applications.
1 January 2011 in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
Transportation problems are often sustainability problems and as such are complex, long-reaching, and difficult to address through incremental policies. Planning for these problems requires analyzing future conditions of the transportation system and the systems with which it interacts. Traditional futures studies using the forecasting method do not deal adequately with the uncertainty inherent in long-term studies of transportation problems. This paper reviews recent innovations in futures studies and their applications to planning studies for transportation system sustainability. The new methods, including scenario planning, backcasting (determining policy to meet future end point), and strategic sustainability assessment, involve both qualitative assessment and scientific models to create and analyze future states. In particular, the paper focuses on backcasting as an alternative to forecasting for scenario building and provides examples of how the method has been applied in the transportation sector. The review suggests that backcasting is a better option for analyzing transportation sustainability problems because it is an action-oriented approach focused on creating desirable future images and developing effective policies for achieving them.
Civil engineers are poised to impact sustainable development. Consequently, there is a need for curricular materials to scaffold students in developing sustainable design skills. Previously, a sustainability module, based on Kolb’s learning cycle, was integrated into a civil engineering capstone course in the United States. The purpose of this study was to analyze the extent to which students engaging in the module (intervention cohort) were able to improve their sustainable design skills, as compared to a group of capstone students not participating in the module (control cohort). A Sustainable Design Rubric was used to assess students’ sustainable design performance, as captured in capstone reports. In addition, students reflected on their confidence related to several sustainable design competencies via a survey. Based on an evaluation of capstone design reports, improvement in the intervention teams’ consideration of sustainable design criteria was somewhat limited, as they more extensively addressed only 2 of the 16 sustainable design criteria compared to control teams. Intervention students reported improved confidence in more sustainable design competencies than control students (10 of 12 for intervention students; 1 of 12 for control students). For future implementations, clearer and more extensive sustainable design expectations need to be set by instructors and project sponsors to increase the execution of sustainable design and close the gap between students’ perceptions of improved skills and teams’ actual application of sustainable design criteria.
1 October 2023 in Journal of Civil Engineering Education