This study examined the impact of the Nigerian Agricultural Insurance Corporation (NAIC) on subsistence Farmers in Kogi State, Nigeria. Primary data were collected from 160 respondents, comprising 80 insured (beneficiaries) and 80 uninsured (non-beneficiaries) farmers, selected through purposive and snowball sampling techniques. Descriptive and inferential statistical analyses were employed to assess socio-economic characteristics, technical efficiency (TE), and output determinants. Most respondents in the study area were self-employed. In addition, 48% of the beneficiaries and 31% of the non-beneficiaries had 6–10 years of farming experience. Most beneficiaries and non-beneficiaries inherited land for farming. Most beneficiaries were ADP members, while only 40% of non-beneficiaries were ADP members. Most beneficiaries and non-beneficiaries had access to technical assistance. Approximately 69% of non-beneficiaries had access to input supply, compared with beneficiaries. Household agricultural income was between 10,000 and 30,000, and most beneficiaries’ and non-beneficiaries’ savings were 5000 or less. The results revealed that beneficiaries had higher household income, agricultural income, and savings than non-beneficiaries, with greater participation in cooperatives and access to agricultural services. The mean Technical Efficiency (TE ) score of beneficiaries was 0.87, significantly higher than the 0.54 recorded for non-beneficiaries, indicating greater efficiency but with potential for improvement. Regression analysis identified the number of livestock, feed, and loans as significant determinants of output for both groups, while farming experience positively influenced technical efficiency. Age and remittances were significant factors for beneficiaries, whereas educational level and cooperative membership significantly influenced non-beneficiaries’ efficiency. Beneficiaries also recorded statistically significant advantages in terms of total revenue, total cost, and output levels. The findings highlighted the significant contribution of agricultural insurance to enhancing productivity, risk management, and financial resilience among small-scale farmers. The study recommends increasing awareness of agricultural insurance through targeted education, simplifying enrollment processes, improving claim responsiveness, and designing farmer-centered insurance policies. Additionally, government interventions, such as expanding access to agricultural credit, subsidies, and input support, are essential to promote greater participation in agricultural insurance schemes and to stimulate sustainable agricultural investment in Kogi State.