Osnabrück University of Applied Sciences, Faculty of Management, Culture, and Technology, Institute for Dual Study Programmes, 49809 Lingen/Ems, Germany
Prof. Dr. Guido Grunwald
Osnabrück University of Applied Sciences, Faculty of Management, Culture, and Technology, Institute for Dual Study Programmes, 49809 Lingen/Ems, Germany
Purpose: The purpose of this study is to identify challenges and derive options for stakeholder engagement of project partnerships for sustainable innovations in higher education institutions (HEIs).Design/methodology/approach: Guided by Donabedian’s structure-process-outcome (SPO) model, our conceptual exploration focuses on understanding stakeholder experience and identifying stakeholder engagement options in different project phases. This research includes empirical data on sustainability expectations towards HEIs collected from 239 business students from the USA and Germany. The Kano method and factor analysis were used for data analysis.Findings: This research suggests that balancing differences in stakeholder types and priorities, identifying and fulfilling key stakeholder expectations and addressing their resource limitations play a crucial role in the partnership’s structure stage. Adjustments for timing and forms of engagement, based on the stakeholder types and their expectations, are necessary during the process stage. Attaining stakeholder consensus on goal achievement and fostering trust and long-term commitment for sustainability are vital tasks in the outcome stage.Practical implications: HEIs are advised to identify and assess stakeholders according to their anticipated inputs and contributions to the expected project outputs. They should consider adopting minimal thresholds of involvement and actively engaging key stakeholders, students, by demonstrating direct sustainability impacts.Originality/value: This conceptual study adds value by enhancing the understanding of sustainable project partnerships in HEIs through the adoption of concepts from open innovation, service management and relationship management research. It illuminates the significance of stakeholder engagement and experience, including the management of expectations, thereby supporting HEIs in effectively implementing sustainability initiatives.
Purpose: This paper aims to analyze the requirements for stakeholder integration in sustainability project partnerships in times of sustainability crisis. Referring to the COVID-19 pandemic as a sustainability crisis that has sensitized consumers and other stakeholders to corporate responsibility for social and sustainability issues, a conceptual framework for stakeholder integration is developed from which implications for designing the potential, process and result quality are derived.Design/methodology/approach: In this conceptual paper, design options for stakeholder integration are derived from open innovation and service management research. Specific crisis-related determinants of stakeholder integration are derived from current corporate social responsibility (CSR) and crisis research taking into account the opportunities and challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic. Design options and crisis-related determinants are then combined to a conceptual framework for stakeholder integration in sustainability project partnerships in times of crisis. Based on this framework, research propositions are derived that provide insights into the design of the potential, process and result quality of stakeholder integration.Findings: This paper shows that the COVID-19 pandemic can be viewed as a sustainability crisis, which places special entrepreneurial demands on stakeholder integration in sustainability project partnerships. The pandemic offers potential for integrating a large number of stakeholders and has emphasized the need for integrating a broad range of stakeholders. Higher skepticism of stakeholders toward companies' CSR engagement in the pandemic has raised stakeholder demands for early integration. Higher skepticism and CSR involvement have rendered active forms of integration even more relevant, which, however, should still be adapted to the respective stakeholder prerequisites. The pandemic has increased the need for constant and comprehensive exchange of data on project results between stakeholders and the project leading organization. Measurement of target achievement can be promoted by establishing stakeholder commitment with regard to the target measures on the collective and relationship levels of the partnership. Finally, the pandemic has reinforced the need for more dialogical forms of communicating sustainability project results.Originality/value: Solving problems and exploiting opportunities in times of crisis require a high degree of entrepreneurship and creative leadership in order to gain new ideas and overcome resource deficits. Sustainability project partnerships in which various stakeholders contribute resources and knowledge to collaborate on idea development and finding solutions to sustainability issues are suitable for this. However, previous approaches to stakeholder integration in open innovation and service management research largely neglect the crisis context and only a few are related to sustainability. In CSR and crisis research, stakeholder-related approaches to coping with crises tend to be underrepresented, and the comprehensive concept of stakeholder integration has so far hardly been considered as an approach to crisis management. By taking into account the COVID-19 pandemic as a sustainability crisis, this paper provides new impulses for the integration of stakeholders in sustainability project partnerships in times of crisis. Recommendations for the design of the potential, process and result quality are derived, which provide insights for project leaders and stakeholders alike. In addition, implications for public policymakers are derived, who are assigned an increasingly active role in the pandemic and who can contribute to the success of sustainability project partnerships by setting suitable framework conditions. The developed concept can be expanded to include further company-related determinants and offers a starting point for empirical analysis in the still underexplored research fields of sustainability-oriented relationship marketing and sustainability crises.
The value–action gap (VAG) refers to the disparity between individuals’ expressed beliefs and their actual behaviors in sustainability contexts. While previous research has focused on past or present evaluations of sustainable consumer behavior, this study aims to investigate the VAG among business students regarding their future-oriented sustainability expectations from Higher Education Institutions. Specifically, this study examines (1) the VAG in these students’ expectations, (2) the role of their interest in or involvement with sustainability in shaping the VAG, and (3) potential differences in the VAG based on students’ expectations of basic, performance, and excitement sustainability requirements. Data for the study were collected through an online survey of 239 business students in the USA and Germany. The Theory of Attractive Quality framework and the Kano analysis were used to identify students’ sustainability expectations, categorizing requirements based on non-linear and qualitative assessments. Our findings reveal larger VAGs in the German context across all sustainability attributes examined. Increased student involvement correlates with a smaller VAG, irrespective of the country. The VAG varies across different types of expectations, with the smallest observed for basic needs. Monitoring students’ sustainability expectations, analyzing their interest in and engagement with sustainability issues, and establishing realistic expectations are crucial for reducing the VAG. It is advisable to prioritize sustainability attributes that facilitate direct student participation, such as integrating sustainability concepts into student research. Future research on the VAG should explore variations in students’ personal, ethical, religious, social, demographic, and political orientations through segmentation.
Drawing from the Theory of Planned Behaviour and a review of empirical research on enablers and barriers for student sustainable behaviour, we explore business students' future‐oriented sustainability expectations and intentions to engage in sustainability behaviour at their Higher Education Institutions (HEIs). Using a process of configurational theorising with fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) and data from 239 business students in two countries—the USA and Germany—we identify multiple equifinal configurations that are associated with high and low sustainability behavioural intentions. Our findings show that students' active engagement in HEIs' sustainability transformation depends on diverse configurations of student characteristics and contextual factors, and various configurations can lead to either high or low sustainability intentions, varying across country contexts. By leveraging these findings to derive strategies that foster sustainability transformation at HEIs, we offer new theoretical and empirical insights to scholars and practical implications.