Robust and accurate Gulf Stream separation remains an unsolved problem in general circulation modeling whose resolution will positively impact the ocean and climate modeling communities. Oceanographic literature does not face a shortage of plausible hypotheses that attempt to explain the dynamics of the Gulf Stream separation, yet a single theory that the community agrees on is missing. In this paper, the authors investigate the impact of the deep western boundary current (DWBC), coastline curvature, and continental shelf steepening on the Gulf Stream separation within regional configurations of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology General Circulation Model. Artificial modifications to the regional bathymetry are introduced to investigate the sensitivity of the separation to each of these factors. Metrics for subsurface separation detection confirm the direct link between flow separation and the surface expression of the Gulf Stream in the Mid-Atlantic Bight. It is shown that the Gulf Stream separation and mean surface position are most sensitive to the continental slope steepening, consistent with a theory proposed by Melvin Stern in 1998. In contrast, the Gulf Stream separation exhibits minimal sensitivity to the presence of the DWBC and coastline curvature. The implications of these results to the development of a “separation recipe” for ocean modeling are discussed. This study concludes adequate topographic resolution is a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for proper Gulf Stream separation.
10 April 2024 in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
The development of any atmosphere or ocean model warrants a suite of test cases (TCs) to verify its spatial and temporal discretizations, order of accuracy, stability, reproducibility, portability, scalability, etc. In this paper, we present a suite of shallow water TCs designed to verify the barotropic solver of atmosphere and ocean models. These include the non‐dispersive coastal Kelvin wave; the dispersive inertia‐gravity wave; the dispersive planetary and topographic Rossby waves; the barotropic tide; and a non‐linear manufactured solution. These TCs check the implementation of the linear pressure gradient term; the linear constant or variable‐coefficient Coriolis and bathymetry terms; and the non‐linear advection terms. Simulation results are presented for a variety of time‐stepping methods as well as two spatial discretizations: a mimetic finite volume method based on the TRiSK scheme, and a high‐order discontinuous Galerkin spectral element method. The experimental procedure for conducting these numerical experiments is detailed. It underscores several key considerations that vary depending on the chosen spatial discretization method. Finally, convergence studies of every TC are conducted with refinement in both space and time, only in space, and only in time. The convergence slopes match the expected theoretical predictions.
11 December 2024 in Journal of Open Source Software
The development of any atmosphere or ocean model warrants a suite of test cases to verify its spatial and temporal discretizations, order of accuracy, stability, reproducability, portability, scalability, etc. In this paper, we present a suite of shallow water test cases designed to verify the barotropic solver of atmosphere and ocean models. These include the non-dispersive coastal Kelvin wave; the dispersive inertia-gravity wave; the dispersive planetary and topographic Rossby waves; the barotropic tide; and a non-linear manufactured solution. These test cases check the implementation of the linear pressure gradient term; the linear constant or variable-coefficient Coriolis and bathymetry terms; and the non-linear advection terms. Simulation results are presented for a variety of time-stepping methods as well as two spatial discretizations: a mimetic finite volume method based on the TRiSK scheme, and a high-order discontinuous Galerkin spectral element method. We explain the strategies that need to be adopted for specifying initial and non-periodic boundary conditions on hexagonal meshes. Convergence studies of every test case are conducted with refinement in both space and time, only in space, and only in time. The convergence slopes match the expected theoretical predictions.
In this paper we introduce a new software framework for the offline calculation of tracer transport in the ocean. The Fast Equilibration of Ocean Tracers Software (FEOTS) is an end-to-end set of tools to efficiently calculate tracer distributions on a global or regional sub-domain using transport operators diagnosed from a comprehensive ocean model. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first application of a Transport Matrix Model to an eddying ocean state. We demonstrate the capabilities of FEOTS in an application focused on the Argentine Basin, where intense eddy activity and the Zapiola Anticyclone lead to strong mixing of water masses. The demonstration clearly shows the benefits of the approach, while at the same time highlighting the limitations of the Impulse Response Functions approach in capturing tracer transports by a non-linear advection scheme. Our future work will focus on improving the computational efficiency of the code to reduce time-to-solution, and on using different basis functions to better represent non-linear advection operators.
We address the question of separating the ocean’s deterministic response to time-dependent forcing from its intrinsic chaotic variability. Because the forcing is neither stationary nor periodic and spatial homogeneity is precluded by both the forcing pattern and boundary conditions, statistical analysis must rely on ensemble averaging. Here, we define this as the arithmetic mean over realizations with equally probable initial conditions. Ideally, one could compute the ensemble mean directly without performing numerous realizations, but this requires knowledge or closure of the second-order statistics — the classical turbulent-closure problem, here recast for a non-equilibrium, geophysical setting. Building on the ideas of nonlinear midlatitude ocean adjustment (Dewar 2003), we examine this problem using idealized quasigeostrophic (QG) double-gyre ensembles subjected to episodic temporal variations in wind forcing. Our objective here is not to develop a subgrid parameterization of unresolved eddies, but rather to construct and test prognostic equations for the ensemble mean itself, using the simplest possible closure assumptions. We find that the performance of ensemble mean closures is highly dependent on the spatiotemporal structure of the forcing. Under slowly varying forcing, approximate closures reproduce the mean evolution reasonably well; under rapidly varying, near-zero-mean forcing, the simplest ensemble-mean closures fail, even at the level of basin-averaged total energy and enstrophy. In both regimes, the ensemble-mean response is not simply the accumulated imprint of the applied forcing, but instead appears as a continuing, non-equilibrated dialogue between the mean and eddy fields.