Suleyman Sertkaya

Dr. Suleyman Sertkaya

Lecturer in Islamic Studies
+1
orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

7Years (2020-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
5 November 2020 in Religions
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Suleyman SertkayaSuleyman Sertkaya
Suleyman Sertkaya
Zuleyha KeskinZuleyha Keskin
Zuleyha Keskin
Prophet Muhammad is a role model for millions of Muslims today. This makes sīrah, the life of the Prophet, a critical source to understand and contextualise. Muslims interpret the events of his life so that they can replicate them in every aspect of their lives. However, extremely polar interpretations of sīrah exist, leading to terrorists on the one side and peace-loving Muslims on the other side, with both using Prophet Muhammad as a reference. The major events most often referred to in sīrah are incidents that unfolded after migration to Medina, particularly the battles and conflicts with other communities. When classical and contemporary sīrah sources are studied, the prominence of the battles is easily seen. However, events besides the battles are just as critical, yet these events are often omitted or downplayed—events that could have easily led to a violent outcome, based on the societal norms at the time, but did not. The Meccan and Medinan periods of Prophet Muhammad’s life are significantly different, with the main difference being the power balance. In Mecca, Muslims had little power, which meant great hardships and mistreatment; meanwhile, in Medina, Muslims were in a position of power. While Prophet Muhammad has been criticised for taking advantage of this power and being violent, this article argues otherwise. Through the examples provided, it becomes evident that Prophet Muhammad preferred peace first and foremost at all times.

24 February 2022 in Religions
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Suleyman SertkayaSuleyman Sertkaya
Suleyman Sertkaya
Sīrah (the life and biography of Prophet Muhammad) has been the point of focus and writing since the Prophet passed away. Approaches to sīrah have evolved in the Muslim and non-Muslim worlds over the centuries. This has had a significant impact on how the Prophet and even Islam are viewed in the Muslim and non-Muslim worlds. While Muslim scholars have focused on details of the exact biography, what and why a particular incident occurred in his life, his leadership, reverence of his teachings and other aspects of his life as a role model as well as lessons that can be derived from his life to emulate in daily life, non-Muslim authors have approached sīrah quite differently. Some are extremely critical to the point of ridicule and slander, while others approach it in a more authentic and genuine manner. The sources to which they have access, namely Arabic sources, play a critical role in the way sīrah is approached. Similarly, interactions with Muslims, scientific developments and globalisation have had significant impacts on the way sīrah is perceived, particularly in modern times. This article provides a chronological and systematic review and analysis of the major sīrah works written by Muslims and non-Muslims since the 7th century. It traces the evolvement of sīrah literature in Muslim and non-Muslim scholarship by documenting the reasons and fundamental factors affecting various approaches to sīrah across the centuries.

1 February 2023 in Religions
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Suleyman SertkayaSuleyman Sertkaya
Suleyman Sertkaya
The Prophet of Islam, Muhammad, is depicted through extremely polar interpretations. Some perceive his life as a source for peace-making societies, whereas others portray him as a “warmonger” or “Prophet of the sword”, and use his examples to justify violence and terrorist attacks. The major incidents referred to in the latter context are the wars and conflicts that occurred after his migration to Medina. These conflicts are also prominent in sīrah narratives of his Medinan life from classical and modern periods. One can argue that there is a significant difference in the way Prophet Muhammad acted in Medina compared to the Meccan period. This is mostly attributed to the power balance, as the Muslims had little power in Mecca, which resulted in them enduring adversities, including verbal insults and physical torture while remaining peaceful and non-violent. In Medina, however, the Muslims obtained relatively more power and behaved differently. The main criticism of the Prophet at this juncture is that he took advantage of this power and became violent; this is the reason all the battles fall in his Medinan life. This article examines the root causes of his behaviour and shift in attitude. It clarifies the Prophet’s goal and agenda at this stage of his life. The article highlights his attitude towards peace and war by holistically analysing the battles and skirmishes that unfolded during the Medinan period. It examines the time spent on war and peace throughout his prophetic mission. In doing so, it enumerates statistical data, such as the number of battlefield casualties and those from expeditions. To attain accurate information in this regard, classical sīrah works and modern research on the battles are referred to as the main resources.

20 November 2023 in Religions
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Suleyman SertkayaSuleyman Sertkaya
Suleyman Sertkaya
Prophet Muhammad is a central figure in Islam. Systematic exploration of his life and biography as a central discourse for sīrah studies remains timeless and relevant. This has made his life a focal point for study among Muslim and Western scholars for centuries, resulting in the emergence of fresh approaches in modern times. This paper delves into the concept of “sīrah philosophy,” which is vigorously advocated by Fethullah Gülen, a prominent Muslim scholar, as a novel and essential perspective for sīrah studies in modern times. Gülen’s amalgamation of the Prophet’s life and contemporary challenges underscores the enduring significance of sīrah in guiding modern discourse. Sīrah philosophy, at its core, provides a framework rooted in the Prophet’s life to draw inspiration for addressing contemporary issues. The article unpacks the practical application of sīrah philosophy through the Hudaybiya incident, a pivotal moment in the Prophet’s life during his time in Medina. From conflict resolution and peacebuilding to interfaith dialogue, Gülen’s approach leverages sīrah to propose solutions for complex contemporary problems, offering a dynamic way to engage with present-day predicaments. In essence, this article emphasises how sīrah, as envisioned by Muslim scholars like Gülen, transcends historical and contextual boundaries, enriching present-day discourse. As sīrah studies evolve, this pioneering exploration of a modern trajectory fosters a deeper appreciation of the Prophet’s legacy, facilitating comprehensive understanding for diverse audiences. This article argues that this approach is groundbreaking and innovative, paving the way for new perspectives to read and interpret sīrah in a contemporary world for a modern audience.

1 January 2025
Verified
Book
Closed access
Suleyman SertkayaSuleyman Sertkaya
Suleyman Sertkaya

20 April 2026 in Australian Journal of Islamic Studies
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Suleyman SertkayaSuleyman Sertkaya
Suleyman Sertkaya
HCHakan Coruh
Hakan Coruh
Ali Bulaç (b. 1951), a prominent Turkish Islamist intellectual and sociologist, has played a significant role in shaping contemporary debates on Islam, modernity, and religious thought in Türkiye. His seven-volume Qurʾānic commentary, Kur’an Dersleri (Dirāsāt al-Qur’ān), represents the culmination of decades of intellectual engagement and offers a valuable window into modern Turkish tafsīr discourse. This article examines Bulaç’s hermeneutical approach by analysing the intellectual and biographical conditions that prompted him to write a tafsīr, the methodological principles that structure his exegetical practice, and the broader scholarly tradition within which he situates himself. Building on this foundation, the study focuses on two representative case studies that illuminate the character of his interpretive project: (1) his engagement with the ongoing debate between contextualist and traditional approaches to Qurʾānic interpretation, and (2) his approach to women’s veiling (ḥijab/headscarf) in the Qur’ān. Through these cases, the article demonstrates how Bulaç seeks to uphold classical hermeneutical principles while responding critically to the theological, socio-ethical and intellectual challenges of the modern world. His tafsīr exemplifies a distinctive attempt to bridge inherited exegetical methods with contemporary concerns, making the Qurʾān intellectually rigorous and contextually meaningful for modern Turkish readers. Regarding the two cases, the article argues that Bulaç rejects modernist/contextualist approaches to revelation, particularly criticising Fazlurrahman and Abdolkarim Soroush’s interpretations. While the Qurʾān uses history as a narrative tool, not as a limiting context, the purpose of the Qurʾān’s judgments is universal. Although he often critiques modernist and reformist perspectives, he occasionally aligns with them on certain points, such as Jesus’ ascension and return. Finally, Bulaç believes in the universality of the Qurʾānic teaching for women’s veiling (ḥijab/Ali Bulaç headscarf), and the obligation to wear the headscarf is still in force for Muslim women due to the Qurʾānic reason (‘illa) of “identity.”