In 2006, 2010, and 2011 attempts were made by health policy advocates to ignite policy debate about the introduction of supervised injecting facilities (SIFs) in Melbourne, Australia. Although there have been a number of attempts to introduce SIFs in Australia, only one facility has been introduced in Sydney, and it has only recently achieved full operating status beyond an extended nine-year trial period. This article retraces the policy narratives in documentary materials (parliamentary debates, policy documents, public advocacy and empirical research) to reflect on the causes for policy impermeability in this contested arena. Interest in supervised injecting rooms, whilst always an exemplar of harm reduction, actually emerged in New South Wales in the mid-1990s from government concern over endemic police corruption. Subsequent policy narratives in Victorian SIF advocacy tended to focus heavily on the health and welfare of drug users, with a notable absence of concern about SIFs as a response to police corruption. It is suggested that future policy initiatives in this arena be mindful of the role and influence of policy narratives that focus on policing, if future SIF advocacy is to be successful.
Although preventive health in Australia has been acknowledged as central to national health and wellbeing, efforts to reform the delivery of preventive health have to date produced limited results. The financing of preventive health at a national level is based on outcome- or performance-based funding mechanisms; however, delivery of interventions and activities at a state level have not been subjected to outcome-based funding processes. A new financing tool being applied in the area of social services (social impact bonds) has emerged as a possible model for application in the prevention arena. This paper explores key issues in the consideration of this funding model in the prevention arena. When preventive health is conceptualised as a merit good, the role of government is clarified and outcome measures fully articulated, social impact bonds may be a viable funding option to supplement core public health activities. What is known about the topic?: The complexities of outcome monitoring in preventive health are well understood. Likewise, the problem of linking funding to outcomes from preventive health practice has also been debated at length in health policy. However, not much is known about the application of social impact bonds into the preventive health arena. What does this paper add?: This paper discusses the limitations and opportunities facing the application of the social impact bond financing model in the preventive health arena. This has not been undertaken previously. What are the implications for practitioners?: Social impact bonds have received significant recent attention from federal and state government treasury departments as potential financing tools for government. Health policy practitioners are watching this space very closely to see the outcomes of a New South Wales trial. Health promotion practitioners and primary care practitioners who deliver preventive services will need to keep abreast of this issue as it will have significant impact on their practice if states and territories introduce outcome-based funding processes.
31 August 2005 in International Journal of Drug Policy
When The Age renamed the corner of Russell and Bourke streets the ‘Golden Elbow’ it brought the city into close proximity with an altogether different city. Neither Chang Mai, Hong Kong nor Melbourne, the Golden Elbow was defined by what it could be. Neither one thing (Melbourne) nor another (somewhere else), the Golden Elbow is a space of the city-becoming-other. Through narrative work and news media maps of no-go zones, machines mobilise fear and thus value, from the desire flowing through this abject zone. Capitalism sucks value from these encounters through the production of fear as affect. The city-becoming-other is both enormously productive, and destructive of bodies caught up in the mix. This article explores the flow of desire and the abject of a city becoming other through a street drug marketplace. The encounter with the abject brings use closer to the beauty and fear of ontological mixity.