The current paper is positioned at the intersection of computer simulation, governance research, and research on infrastructure systems, such as transportation or energy. It proposes a simulation framework, "Simulation of the governance of complex systems" (SimCo), to study the governability of complex socio-technical systems experimentally by means of agent-based modelling (ABM). SimCo is rooted in a sociological macromicro-macro model of a socio-technical system, taking into account the interplay of agents' choices (micro) and situational constraints (macro). The paper presents the conceptualization of SimCo, its elements and subsystems as well as their interactions. SimCo depicts the daily routines of users performing their tasks (e.g. going to work) by choosing among different technologies (e.g. modes of transportation), occasionally deciding to replace a worn-out technology. All components entail different dimensions that can be adjusted, thus allowing operators to purposefully intervene, for instance in the case of risk management (e.g. preventing congestion) or system transformation (e.g. towards sustainable mobility). Experiments with a basic scenario of an urban road transport system demonstrate the effects of different modes of governance (so control, strong control and a combination of both), revealing that so control may be the best strategy to govern a complex socio-technical system.
This paper presents an agent-based model (ABM) for residential end-users, which is part of a larger, interdisciplinary co-simulation framework that helps to investigate the performance of future power distribution grids (i.e., smart grid scenarios). Different modes of governance (strong, soft and self-organization) as well as end-users’ heterogeneous behavior represent key influential factors. Feedback was implemented as a measure to foster grid-beneficial behavior, which encompasses a range of monetary and non-monetary incentives (e.g., via social comparison). The model of frame selection (MFS) serves as theoretical background for modelling end-users’ decision-making. Additionally, we conducted an online survey to ground the end-user sub-model on empirical data. Despite these empirical and theoretical foundations, the model presented should be viewed as a conceptual framework, which requires further data collection. Using an example scenario, representing a lowly populated residential area (167 households) with a high share of photovoltaic systems (30%), different modes of governance were compared with regard to their suitability for improving system stability (measured in cumulated load). Both soft and strong control were able to decrease overall fluctuations as well as the mean cumulated load (by approx. 10%, based on weekly observation). However, we argue that soft control could be sufficient and more societally desirable.
Das Simulationsframework „SimCo“ erlaubt es, die Steuerung komplexer, netzwerkförmiger, soziotechnischer (Infrastruktur-)Systeme zu untersuchen – beispielsweise die des Verkehrs- oder Energiesystems. SimCo basiert auf den Prinzipien der agentenbasierten Modellierung und Simulation. Dynamiken auf der Systemebene werden durch die Interaktion einer Vielzahl strategisch handelnder, heterogener Agenten erzeugt. Mit Hilfe von Simulationsexperimenten lassen sich unterschiedliche Szenarien (mit politisch definierten Zielvorstellungen) hinsichtlich ihrer Wirksamkeit sowie möglicher nicht-intendierter Nebenfolgen testen, denn der Steuerungserfolg hängt letztlich von den Reaktionen der Agenten auf der Mikro-Ebene ab. Ein abstraktes, urbanes Verkehrssystem dient als Anwendungsfall und lässt eine Mischung aus weichen und harten Steuerungsmaßnahmen vielversprechend erscheinen.