Migrants diagnosed with schizophrenia are overrepresented in forensic-psychiatric clinics. A comprehensive characterization of this offender subgroup remains to be conducted. The present exploratory study aims at closing this research gap. In a sample of 370 inpatients with schizophrenia spectrum disorders who were detained in a Swiss forensic-psychiatric clinic, 653 different variables were analyzed to identify possible differences between native Europeans and non-European migrants. The exploratory data analysis was conducted by means of supervised machine learning. In order to minimize the multiple testing problem, the detected group differences were cross-validated by applying six different machine learning algorithms on the data set. Subsequently, the variables identified as most influential were used for machine learning algorithm building and evaluation. The combination of two childhood-related factors and three therapy-related factors allowed to differentiate native Europeans and non-European migrants with an accuracy of 74.5% and a predictive power of AUC = 0.75 (area under the curve). The AUC could not be enhanced by any of the investigated criminal history factors or psychiatric history factors. Overall, it was found that the migrant subgroup was quite similar to the rest of offender patients with schizophrenia, which may help to reduce the stigmatization of migrants in forensic-psychiatric clinics. Some of the predictor variables identified may serve as starting points for studies aimed at developing crime prevention approaches in the community setting and risk management strategies tailored to subgroups of offenders with schizophrenia.
9 January 2017 in Forensische Psychiatrie, Psychologie, Kriminologie
Um Informationen zu den Bedingungen von Psychotherapie im Maßregelvollzug zu gewinnen, wurde eine Online-Umfrage initiiert. Die Auswertung ergab, dass in den Einrichtungen mehrheitlich psychotherapeutisch gearbeitet wird (vor allem verhaltenstherapeutisch, manualisiert), zum großen Teil durch Psychologen[1], meist im Gruppensetting. Allerdings kommt es in relevantem Maß zu Ausfällen. Der Vorwurf, der Maßregelvollzug sei eine allein kustodiale Unterbringung, scheint in weiten Teilen des Maßregelvollzugs heute nicht (mehr) zu gelten. The Federal Constitutional Court has emphasized the necessity of psychotherapy for offenders. Little is known about the actual situation of this field of work. Thus, an online survey was initiated. The survey was conducted through an online portal. The heads of forensic psychiatric facilities have been asked to participate by completing a questionnaire. The elicitation provided data from 27 institutions. A large part of patients receive psychotherapeutic treatment. Psychotherapy is predominantly shaped by psychologists. The majority of institutions apply approaches derived from behavioral therapy. To a large extent, manualized and modular procedures are being used; most of them in group settings. One problem stems from personnel deficiencies, leading to psychotherapy not taking place on a regular basis or not being performed in accordance to the guidelines of treatment programs. The prior allegation – impositions of forensic measures being characterized by custodial detention – is no longer valid for a high number of forensic psychiatric services. 1 Aufgrund der Begrenzung der Zeichenzahl wurde auf die zusätzliche Anführung der jeweils weiblichen Formen verzichtet.