Fishmeal is the main source of dietary protein for most commercially farmed fish species. However, fishmeal prices have been raised even further because of competition with domestic animals, shortage in world fishmeal supply, and increased demand. Increased fishmeal prices have contributed to the quest for alternatives necessary to replace fishmeal as a global research priority. A literature search was conducted using these terms on Google Scholar and EBSCOhost; fishmeal replacement in fish feeds, fishmeal alternatives in fish feeds, animal protein sources in aquaculture, insects in fish feeds, terrestrial by-products, and fishery by-products. To calculate the variation between experiments, a random effect model was used. Results indicated that different fish species, sizes, and inclusion levels were used in the various studies and showed that the use of insects, terrestrial by-products, and fishery by-products has some limitations. Despite these drawbacks, the use of animal protein sources as a replacement for fishmeal in fish diets has had a positive impact on the feed conversion ratio, variable growth rate, final weight, and survival rate of different types of fish species of different size groups. Findings also showed that some animal by-products had not been assessed as a protein source in aquaculture or animal feeds, and future studies are recommended.
The rapid proliferation of water lettuce, Pistia stratiotes, poses significant ecological challenges. This study investigates the use of Pistia stratiotes as a substrate for producing black soldier fly larvae. The experiment used 40 g of black soldier fly larvae (BSFL) pupae for all five substrates (T0, T25, T50, T75, and T100). Each treatment had three replicates. The physicochemical parameters, such as the temperature and pH, ranged from 27.30 °C to 27.40 °C and from 7.03 to 7.60, respectively. The survival rates ranged from 90.13% to 94.73%. The biochemical parameters showed significant differences, including dry matter, organic matter, ash, crude protein, crude lipid, crude fiber, carbohydrate, and energy (p < 0.05). Regarding the larvae’s growth and substrate use, the BSFL production varied depending on the rearing substrate. The highest growth was observed in substrates without water lettuce leaf (WLL) (T0), followed by those in treatment at 25% (T25) and 50% (T50) inclusion of WLL and then the substrate made solely of WLL (T100). The substrates degradation rate in this study varied significantly, ranging from 46.40% to 67.38%. The physicochemical characteristics of the substrates are associated with the growth performance of the BSFL, and the inclusion of WLL influenced the nutritional composition of the larvae.
The Nile crocodile (Crocodylus niloticus) aquaculture industry, primarily for the production of skins, is amongst the largest aquaculture industry in sub-Saharan Africa and produces a range of meat waste products. The aim of this study was to evaluate the nutritional value of raw and cooked meal derived from different parts of Crocodylus niloticus carcasses as a potential source of protein in animal feed production, especially fish. Proximate composition of major nutrients such as moisture, crude protein, crude fat, crude fibre, ash and selected minerals were analysed in October-November 2018 for comparison with other meal sources. Results indicated that Crocodylus niloticus derived meal is of a comparable quality for use in aquaculture feeds, compared to by-product meal quality reported for meal derived from bovine bones and meat, feathers, blood and other poultry by-products. Crocodile meal is hypothesised to be a suitable fishmeal replacement in the production of aquaculture feeds.
Fish are generally known to change their nutritional requirements depending on their life stage and formulating feeds for different size groups to meet their dietary needs is essential. This study aimed to assess the potential of Crocodylus niloticus meat meal as an animal protein source replacing fishmeal in Oreochromis mossambicus diets. Ten fry (0.07 g fish−1) were randomly assigned to three formulated diets (0% (D1), 50% (D2), and 100% (D3)), and each diet had three replicates. The fry were fed 10% body weight per day (BWd−1) for 30 days. New diets (0% (D4), 50% (D5), and 100% (D6)) were introduced, and the feeding rate was reduced to 5% BWd−1 for 48 days. After that, the fish were fed 2% BWd−1 for 78 days, the same diets used for fingerlings. All size groups were fed two portions of their daily ration at 10:30 h and 15:30 h. Our results point to the suggestion that Crocodylus niloticus meat meal may replace fishmeal for Oreochromis mossambicus, as there were no significant differences in weight gain (G), specific growth rates (SGR), gross feed conversion ratios (GFCR), or protein efficiency ratios (PER) for fry fed different diets. Furthermore, there were similarities in Gs, SGRs, GFCRs, and PER in fingerlings and sub adult to adult fish fed D4 and D5. The cost analysis of ingredients used in diets with 50% and 100% Crocodylus niloticus meat meal indicated that it was profitable to use this meat meal in diets of O. mossambicus of all groups. The profit index of 0.3 for fry, 0.8 for fingerlings, and 1.9 for subadults to adults for 100% fishmeal diets were lower than 0.4 and 0.5 for fry, 0.9 and 1.1 for fingerlings, and 2.3 and 2.9 for sub adult to adult fish fed diets with 50% and 100% crocodile meat meal, respectively.
The velvet bean (Mucuna pruriens) is an important source of protein in animal feed. This study investigates the potential substitution of soybean (Glycine