Damage detection algorithms employing the conventional acceleration measurements and the associated modal features may underperform due to the limited number of sensors used in the monitoring and the smoothing effect of spline functions used to increase the spatial resolution. The effectiveness of such algorithms could be increased if a more accurate estimate of mode shapes were provided. This study presents a hybrid structural health monitoring method for vibration-based damage detection of bridge-type structures. The proposed method is based on the fusion of data from conventional accelerometers and computer vision-based measurements. The most commonly used mode shape-based damage measures, namely, the mode shape curvature method, the modal strain energy method, and the modal flexibility method, are used for damage detection. The accuracy of these parameters used together with the conventional sparse sensor setups and the proposed hybrid approach is investigated in numerical case studies, with damage scenarios simulated on a simply-supported bridge. The simulations involve measuring the acceleration response of the bridge to ambient vibrations and train crossings and then processing the data to determine the modal frequencies and mode shapes. The efficiency and accuracy of the proposed hybrid health monitoring methodology are demonstrated in case studies involving scenarios in which conventional acceleration measurements fail to detect and locate damage. The robustness of the proposed method against various levels of noise is shown as well. In the studies considered, damage as small as 10% decrease in flexural stiffness of the bridge and localized in less than 1% of the span-length of the bridge is reliably detected even with very high levels of measurement noise. Finally, a modified modal flexibility damage parameter is derived and used to alleviate the shortcomings of the modal flexibility damage parameter.
26 June 2022 in Structure and Infrastructure Engineering
This article presents a numerical study that aims to explore the dynamic behavior of railway bridges under vibrations induced by heavy-haul traffic. For this purpose, a finite element code that can conduct moving load and moving mass analysis of single span bridges was developed. The software was validated by comparing the numerical response to the analytical solution for various speeds. The numerical analysis of the benchmark bridge under the benchmark train showed the interplay between the natural frequency of the bridge, the mass of the train and the loading frequency. A comprehensive parametric study to investigate the impact of different parameters on the dynamic behavior of railway bridges is also provided. The bridge span length, normalized train length, normalized mass of the train, bridge deck stiffness, and train speed are the variables considered in the parametric study. The results of the extensive numerical analyses improve the understanding of railway bridge behavior under heavy-haul trains, and highlight the impact of the inertial effect of the trains on bridges, especially for varying span length and deck stiffness. It is also demonstrated that, when the train-to-bridge mass ratio exceeds 40%, the inertial effects of the train mass needs to be included in the analysis in order to obtain a reliable estimate of the bridge behavior under different train speeds.
This article presents a novel methodology to extract the bridge frequencies from the vibrations recorded on train-mounted sensors. Continuous wavelet transform is used to distinguish the bridge frequencies from the other peaks that are visible in the Fourier amplitude spectrum of the accelerations recorded on train bogies. The efficacy of the proposed method is demonstrated through numerical case studies. For this, a detailed three-dimensional finite element model that can capture the vibration characteristics of the bridge, track, and train is created, and each component of the model is separately validated. The train model used is a three-dimensional multi-degree-of-freedom system that can simulate the pitching and rolling behavior. The train was then virtually driven over the bridge at different speeds and under varying track irregularities to evaluate the robustness of the proposed method in extracting bridge frequencies from train-mounted sensors under different conditions. The proposed methodology is shown to be capable of identifying bridge modal frequencies even for aggressive track irregularity profiles and relatively high speeds of trains.
This article presents a study that aims to identify the boundary conditions of a railway bridge using system identification and artificial neural networks. Vibrations generated by three different train types recorded during a 24-h long measurement campaign is used to identify the modal frequencies and mode shapes of a single-span 50 m long railway bridge. Frequency Domain Decomposition and Stochastic Subspace Identification with Covariance methods were used to identify the modal properties from the recorded vibrations and the effect of the used Operational Modal Analysis on the identified modal properties was evaluated. An initial finite-element (FE) model based on the design drawings was not able to replicate the observed dynamic behavior of the bridge. Using a sensitivity analysis, the key parameters of the finite-element model that impact the vibration frequencies of the bridge was determined. 300 finite-element models were created by changing the values of these key parameters within their effective range and were used to identify the relationship between these parameters and the vibration frequencies using Artificial neural networks (ANNs). Leveraging this relationship, the values of the FE model parameters that minimizes the error between the measured and computed frequencies was determined. As a result, the mean error between the computed and the identified vibration frequencies was reduced from 27.3% for the initial model to 3.0% for the updated model. The study indicates that boundary conditions are among the most influential parameter on the dynamic behavior of bridges and can deviate significantly from the simplistic models generally used in the FE models.
Bridges serve as vital engineering structures crafted to facilitate secure and effective transportation networks. Throughout their life-cycle, they withstand various factors, including diverse environmental conditions, natural hazards, and substantial loads. Recent bridge failures underscore the significant risks posed to the structural integrity of bridges. Damage detection techniques, being core components of structural health monitoring, play a crucial role in objectively assessing bridge conditions. This article introduces a novel framework for identifying damage in bridges utilizing continuous wavelet analysis of accelerations recorded using two sensors mounted on a vehicle traversing the bridge. The proposed method leverages changes in the static response of the bridge, which has proven to be more sensitive to damage than its dynamic counterpart. By doing so, the method eliminates the reliance on modal parameters for damage identification, addressing a significant challenge in the field. The proposed framework also addresses key challenges encountered by drive-by monitoring methods. It mitigates the adverse effects of road roughness by utilizing residual accelerations and efficiently detects and locates damage even in the absence of corresponding data from an undamaged bridge. Numerical investigations demonstrate the robustness of the proposed method against various parameters, including damage location and extent, vehicle speeds, road roughness levels, different boundary conditions, and multi-damage scenarios.