Early suckler?: One trait that is unique to mammals is milk suckling. Suckling requires the presence of stability and motion in the throat, both of which require a complex hyoid apparatus. Zhou et al. describe a mammaliform docodontan fossil from the Jurassic that was preserved with a nearly intact hyoid (see the Perspective by Hoffmann and Krause). The structure is complex and saddle shaped, like that seen in modern mammals, suggesting that a muscularized throat was present before the development of mammals. Science , this issue p. 276 ; see also p. 222

The docodont Haldanodon exspectatus, a mammaliaform from the Late Jurassic of Portugal, is a crucial taxon for studying higher-level relationships of mammaliaforms and their morphological evolution. Based on high-resolution computed tomography scanning of three specimens of Haldanodon, we developed a new reconstruction of the basicranium including the petrosal and the inner ear. Our study confirms that Haldanodon and other basal mammaliaforms, such as Morganucodon and Sinoconodon, are similar in the main characteristics of their external anatomy of the petrosal. However, Haldanodon shows several derived features that support a phylogenetic position of docodonts more derived than Morganucodon and Sinoconodon: (1) elongated and curved cochlear canal (nearly 180°), (2) single lateral flange foramen of petrosal, (3) absence of anterior paroccipital process, and (4) squamosal constriction. The bony labyrinth reveals a secondary crus commune, which is regarded to be a plesiomorphic feature of the mammaliaform groundplan. The cochlear canal shows an apical inflation connected to a distinct sulcus and a separate notch in the internal acoustic meatus, supporting the existence of a lagenar nerve and macula as in monotremes. Haldanodon is unique among Mesozoic mammaliaforms in having a hypertrophied paroccipital region that is excavated into large tympanic pneumatic recesses, which are connected with the extensive porous and probably also pneumatic internal structures of the surrounding bones. The curved cochlear canal and the pneumatized middle ear region support the hypothesis that Haldanodon had more effective low-frequency hearing as an adaptation to a fossorial mode of life.