The 2017 American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association hypertension guideline
1 recommends thiazide and thiazidelike diuretics as one of the first-line treatment classes. Hydrochlorothiazide is the most commonly prescribed member of the class, but the guideline states that chlorthalidone is preferred on the basis of longer half-life and proven trial reduction of cardiovascular disease. However, to our knowledge there are no large, completed randomized clinical trials comparing these medications, although one is in progress.
2 Indirect network meta-analyses showed superior effectiveness with chlorthalidone,
3,4 but a large observational study showed approximately equal effectiveness.
5 Short-term, small randomized clinical trials
6,7 showed only nominal differences in safety issues such as hypokalemia, but the observational study
5 showed a worse safety profile for chlorthalidone with higher rates of hypokalemia and hyponatremia.