To critically evaluate and summarize identified evidence for the use of ultrasound to measure peripheral skeletal muscle architecture during critical illness. Seven electronic databases (Medline, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, Cochrane Library, Physiotherapy Evidence Database, Scopus, Excerpta Medica Database, and Web of Science [including Science Citations and Conference Proceedings]) and personal libraries were searched for relevant articles. Cross-referencing further identified references. Quantitative study designs excluding abstracts, published in English, including adult critically ill patients in the ICU, evaluating peripheral skeletal muscle architecture during critical illness with ultrasound were included. Studies using ultrasonographic muscle data as outcome measures in interventional trials were excluded. Performed by one reviewer using a standardized data extraction form and cross-checked by a second reviewer. Quality appraisal was undertaken by two independent reviewers-studies were classified, graded, and appraised according to standardized algorithms and checklists. Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines were adhered to. Seven studies with independent patient cohorts totaling 300 participants were included. One study adopted a case-control design, and the remainder were case series. Ultrasound data demonstrated deficits in a variety of peripheral skeletal muscle architecture variables across a range of muscle groups associated with critical illness. Ultrasound offered more accurate data compared to limb circumference measurement and has excellent reported reliability, but underestimated data acquired via more invasive muscle biopsy. Ultrasound provides clinical utility for assessing the trajectory of change in peripheral skeletal muscle architecture during critical illness, supplementing more detailed characterization, albeit rarely used, from muscle biopsy analysis. Adoption of standardized operating protocols for measurement will facilitate future meta-analysis of data.
New Findings: What is the central question of this study?The aim of this study was to examine the relationship between neural respiratory drive (NRD) measured as the electromyogram of the diaphragm (EMGdi%max) and parasternal intercostal muscles (sEMGpara%max) during two different ventilatory loading strategies, namely acute hypercapnia and inspiratory threshold loading. We hypothesized that, although agonist in nature, there would be a preferential increase in NRD to the diaphragm over the parasternal intercostal muscles during the two different loading conditions, given their different mechanical advantages and relative contributions to ventilation. What is the main finding and its importance?The sEMGpara%max provides a non‐invasive alternative to EMGdi%max recorded using an invasive oesophageal electrode catheter for the quantification of NRD. The EMGdi%max was, however, consistently greater than sEMGpara%max during both loading protocols, demonstrating that these two measures of NRD are not interchangeable. Understanding the effects of respiratory load on neural respiratory drive and respiratory pattern are key to understanding the regulation of load compensation in respiratory disease. The aim of the study was to examine and compare the recruitment pattern of the diaphragm and parasternal intercostal muscles when the respiratory system was loaded using two methods. Twelve subjects performed incremental inspiratory threshold loading up to 50% of their maximal inspiratory pressure, and 10 subjects underwent incremental, steady‐state hypercapnia to a maximal inspired CO2 of 5%. The diaphragmatic electromyogram (EMGdi) was measured using a multipair oesophageal catheter, and the parasternal intercostal muscle EMG (sEMGpara) was recorded from bipolar surface electrodes positioned in the second intercostal space. The EMGdi and sEMGpara were analysed over the last minute of each increment of both protocols, normalized using the peak EMG recorded during maximal respiratory manoeuvres and expressed as EMG%max. The EMGdi%max and sEMGpara%max increased in parallel during the two loading methods, although EMGdi%max was consistently greater than sEMGpara%max in both conditions, inspiratory threshold loading [bias (SD) 9 (3)%, 95% limits of agreement 4–15%] and hypercapnia [bias (SD) 6 (3)%, 95% limits of agreement −0.05 to 12%]. Inspiratory threshold loading resulted in more pronounced increases in mean (SD) EMGdi%max [10 (7)–45 (28)%] and sEMGpara%max [5.3 (3.1)–40 (28)%] from baseline compared with EMGdi%max [7 (4)–21 (8)%] and sEMGpara%max [4.7 (2.3)–10 (4)%] during hypercapnia, despite comparable levels of ventilation. These data support the use of sEMGpara%max, as a non‐invasive alternative to EMGdi%max recorded with an invasive oesophageal electrode catheter, for the quantification of neural respiratory drive. This technique should make evaluation of respiratory muscle function easier to undertake and therefore more readily acceptable in patients with respiratory disease, in whom transduction of neural respiratory drive to pressure generation can be compromised.
Neural respiratory drive, quantified by the parasternal intercostal muscle electromyogram (EMGpara), provides a sensitive measure of respiratory system load-capacity balance. Reference values for EMGpara-based measures are lacking and the influence of individual anthropometric characteristics is not known. EMGpara is conventionally expressed as a percentage of that obtained during a maximal inspiratory effort (EMGpara%max), leading to difficulty in applying the technique in subjects unable to reliably perform such manoeuvres. To measure EMGpara in a large, unselected cohort of healthy adult subjects in order to evaluate relevant technical and anthropometric factors. Surface second intercostal space EMGpara was measured during resting breathing and maximal inspiratory efforts in 63 healthy adult subjects, median (IQR) age 31.0 (25.0–47.0) years, 28 males. Detailed anthropometry, spirometry and respiratory muscle strength were also recorded. Median (IQR EMGpara was 4.95 (3.35–6.93) µ V, EMGpara%max 4.95 (3.39–8.65)% and neural respiratory drive index (NRDI, the product of EMGpara%max and respiratory rate) was 73.62 (46.41–143.92) %.breath/min. EMGpara increased significantly to 6.28 (4.26–9.93) µ V ( p < 0.001) with a mouthpiece, noseclip and pneumotachograph in situ . Median (IQR) EMGpara was higher in female subjects (5.79 (4.42–7.98) µ V versus 3.56 (2.81–5.35) µ V, p = 0.003); after controlling for sex neither EMGpara, EMGpara%max or NRDI were significantly related to anthropometrics, age or respiratory muscle strength. In subjects undergoing repeat measurements within the same testing session ( n = 48) or on a separate occasion ( n = 19) similar repeatability was observed for both EMGpara and EMGpara%max. EMGpara is higher in female subjects than males, without influence of other anthropometric characteristics. Reference values are provided for EMGpara-derived measures. Expressing EMGpara as a percentage of maximum confers no advantage with respect to measurement repeatability, expanding the potential application of the technique. Raw EMGpara is a useful marker of respiratory system load-capacity balance.
Peak cough flow (PCF) measurements can be used as indicators of cough effectiveness. Portable peak flow meters and spirometers have been used to measure PCF, but little is known about their accuracy compared to pneumotachograph systems. The aim of this study was to compare the accuracy of four portable devices (Mini–Wright and Assess peak flow meters, SpiroUSB and Microlab spirometers) in measuring PCF with a calibrated laboratory based pneumotachograph system. Twenty healthy volunteers (mean (SD) age 45 (16) years) coughed through a pneumotachograph connected in series with each portable device in turn, and the differences in PCF readings were analysed. In addition, mechanically generated flow waves of constant peak flow were delivered through each device both independently and when connected in series with the pneumotachograph. Agreement between PCF readings obtained with the pneumotachograph and the portable devices was poor. Peak flow readings were on average lower by approximately 50 L min −1 when measured using the portable devices; 95% limits of agreement spanned approximately 150 L min −1 . The findings highlight the potential for inaccuracy when using portable devices for the measurement of PCF. Depending on the measurement instrument used, absolute values of PCF reported in the literature may not be directly comparable.
Follow-up studies of infants born prematurely are essential to understand the long-term consequences of preterm birth and the efficacy of interventions delivered in the neonatal period. Retention of participants for follow-up studies, however, is challenging, with attrition rates of up to 70%. Our aim was to examine retention rates in two follow-up studies of prematurely born children and identify participant or study characteristics that were associated with higher attrition, and to discuss retention strategies with regard to the literature. Data from children recruited at birth to one of two studies of prematurely born infants were assessed. The two studies were the United Kingdom Oscillation Study (UKOS, a randomised study comparing two modes of neonatal ventilation in infants born less than 29 weeks of gestational age (GA)), and an observational study examining the impact of viral lower respiratory tract infections in infancy in those born less than 36 weeks of GA (virus study). The UKOS participants, but not those in the virus study, had regularly been contacted throughout the follow-up period. UKOS subjects were followed up at 11 to 14 years of age and subjects in the virus study at 5–7 years of age. At follow up in both studies, pulmonary function and respiratory morbidity were assessed. Retention rates to follow-up in the two studies and baseline characteristics of those who were and were not retained were assessed. Retention was significantly higher in UKOS than the virus study (61% versus 35%, p < 0.0001). Subjects lost to UKOS follow up had greater deprivation scores (p < 0.001), a greater likelihood of intrauterine tobacco exposure (p = 0.001) and were more likely to be of non-white ethnicity (p < 0.001). In the virus study, those lost to follow-up had higher birth weights (p = 0.036) and were less likely to be oxygen dependent at hospital discharge (p = 0.003) or be part of a multiple birth (p = 0.048). Higher retention was demonstrated when there was regular contact in the follow-up period. Both social factors and initial illness severity affected the retention into follow-up studies of prematurely born infants, though these factors were not consistent across the two studies.