Ecovillages aim to foster community around sustainable practices and encourage low-impact lifestyles. This article explores the strategies employed by two ecovillages to scale up their practices through physical expansion and the consequence for the maintenance of said practices. The ecovillages under study are Hurdal in Norway and Findhorn in Scotland. The study employed a multi-method approach: document study, participant observation, and interviews with ecovillage residents. The ecovillages applied different strategies to gain access to economic resources for expansion. Hurdal ecovillage sold its land to a private developer while Findhorn chose a different path: raising funds within the community, accessing public funds, and adopting low-cost building designs. The study finds that collaborating with investors and developers results in expensive housing that excludes low-income individuals and attracts well-off house buyers with mainstream values. Both ecovillages dropped introductory courses that aimed to equip new members with the necessary skills for shared practices and establish a common ground. These two consequences led to a weakening of competences for shared practices as private property took precedence. Prioritizing affordable infrastructure and accessing local (community and public) financial resources opens up paths for expansion that can maintain the necessary skills and meaning for community living.
20 September 2024 in Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy
This chapter presents the results of needs-based workshops carried out in Vågan municipality in the Lofoten Islands in Northern Norway in 2018. Drawing on Max-Neef’s Human Scale Development participatory methodology, 14 representatives of the local society, including students, blue- and white-collar workers and pensioners, participated in a one-day workshop discussing satisfiers (values, social practices, institutions, personal and collective actions and attributes, environments, etc.) that either hampered or contributed to need fulfilment in the municipality. Participants also identified the interventions, at the personal, community and governance levels, that would improve need fulfilment and environmental sustainability. Analysis of workshop data revealed that sustainable transport practices, including ride- and car-sharing using collective transport and cycling, were considered synergetic as they helped fulfil several human needs whilst hampering none. Further, the study highlighted the interdependence of satisfiers associated with sustainable transport and other need-promoting satisfiers. For example, encouraging ride-sharing appeared both linked to the development of a dedicated mobile phone application and to the creation of non-commercial meeting places. The chapter concludes by reflecting on the implications of a human need perspective for the transition towards sustainable consumption practices.
Background: There is a gap between well-developed wellbeing theories and quantitative indicator systems used in research and policy. Beyond GDP and wellbeing economy work has produced hundreds of indicators and composite indices, yet reviews highlight fragmentation, lack of theoretical grounding and weak links to scientific frameworks. Methods: We analysed recent reviews of sustainable wellbeing models and their applications in systems modelling. Our review revealed that most wellbeing models used in systems modelling lack a strong theoretical foundation. In this paper, we present a new quantitative model for Sustainable and Inclusive Wellbeing (SIW) as a contribution towards filling this gap. To demonstrate the model’s features, we build a database of 20 sustainable development indicators and estimate SIW for 186 countries. Findings: The new model for SIW consists of four tiers. It integrates wellbeing indicators (Tier 4), Basic Human Needs theory (Tier 3), psychological and physiological wellbeing (Tier 2) to estimate SIW (Tier 1). The model features a newly developed Life Skills Index and uses s-shaped Saturation curves to link need satisfiers to need satisfaction. Interpretation: The model is demonstrated using a global indicator dataset. The results show that the SIW model calibrates well against self-reported Life Satisfaction at country level. The SIW-model is designed to be used in systems modelling that simulate key social, economic and environmental preconditions for wellbeing. This will require a revised set of context-dependent and policy relevant indicators as Tier 4 of the model. Funding: No funding was received for this study.