What is environmental, social, and governance (ESG) data and how do we evaluate its quality and effectiveness? This form of evaluation is important, as it is a precondition for investors trying to integrate ESG in investment decisions. Previous literature describes intrinsic properties of ESG data (e.g. multifaceted-ness and context dependence) and highlights a trade-off between the validity and reliability of ESG data, which is often tied to the lack of theoretical foundations and scarcity of high-quality ESG data. Encouragingly, new data technologies have improved the accessibility, availability, and transparency of ESG data, but an agreed theoretical framework to evaluate ESG data quality is still lacking. This paper seeks to fill that theoretical gap by proposing a ‘user-oriented’ approach to evaluate ESG data. In this framework, we consider ESG data to be a ‘continuous concept with limitless boundaries’ and characterise it in terms of its width and depth. The bearing of width and depth on ESG data quality is ultimately a function of the investment decisions in which such data is used: the approach we endorse is therefore user-centric. This study then shows how ESG data, when it is of high quality, maps onto the investment decision-making processes.
17 June 2022 in Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
This study systematically reviews the evolutionary trajectory of corporate sustainability research spanning from 1973 to 2019. Through a scientometric analysis of 26,111 Web of Science articles, it demonstrates the continuous development of the conceptual foundations of corporate sustainability, leading to changes in research subjects over time. Despite recent efforts to integrate sustainability into mainstream business models, there remains a lack of consensus on theoretical and methodological frameworks. The study aims to enhance understanding of the conceptual foundations of corporate sustainability by classifying 47 years of research into four major periods: the Dawn of Diverse Ideas (1979–2005), the Rise of Conceptual Frameworks (2006–2011), the Era of Heterogeneity (2012–2015), and the Age of Stakeholder Engagement (2016–2019). The analysis examines the leading research subjects, theories, and perceptions of corporate sustainability in each period, providing a comprehensive review of the evolution of sustainability research. Moreover, the study introduces emerging concepts in the latest sustainability research and underscores the significance of academic research in addressing the current challenges practitioners face.
This study aims to advance the understanding of and address the valley of death that is significantly widening in the clean energy domain due to its financing challenges. We conduct a case study on three new investment vehicles in the US energy sector (First Look Fund by Activate, Prime Impact Fund by Prime Coalition, and Aligned Climate Capital), which set their missions to contribute to bridging the valley of death in clean energy. While three cases focus on different technological development phases, they raise a consistent point that investment opportunities (and risks) are not assigned to the appropriate investors. We argue that current financial intermediaries have failed to effectively channel funding sources to entrepreneurs, as we evidence network fragmentation and information asymmetries among investor groups and companies. Therefore, we propose three intermediary functions that can facilitate intelligent and effective information flow among investors throughout the entire energy technology development cycle. Our findings highlight the emergence of collaborative platforms as critical pillars to address financing issues among new energy ventures.