Since 2015, power in Poland has been exercised by the right-wing populist coalition, led by the socially conservative Law and Justice (PiS) party. The deconfliction mark of these governments became the “unholy alliance” with Christianity, which was a movement that used populist manipulation based on exacerbating social dichotomy, campaigning against the LGBT community, nationalism, xenophobia, attitudes of rejection, anti-pluralism and anti-establishment. In this context, the aim of this article is to theoretically analyse the ideological and religious frames between right-wing populism and Christianity in Poland. The considerations begin with the presentation of the theoretical background, that is, the relationship that exists between the populist “thin-core ideology” and Christianity within the framework of ideological appropriation of religion by populists. Furthermore, the author will make an attempt to decipher mutual influences and seek answers to the question: How did PiS “hijack” the Catholic Church in Poland? The next step will present a comparative identification of convergent and divergent frameworks between right-wing populists and the Catholic Church in Poland. Finally, the article will outline indications for the socio-pastoral prevention of populism and a summary of the main results.
30 November 2024 in Journal of Religious Education
Biblical didactics is an important element of confessional religious education. In traditional settings, it is primarily associated with working with the text, alone or in groups, in plenary discussion or pantomime. Nowadays, however, young people are increasingly acquiring their knowledge—including about the Bible—on the Internet, using new technologies such as conversational Artificial Intelligence (AI), of which ChatGPT (Generative Pre-trained Transformers) is perhaps the best-known example. In this context, the following article seeks to answer the question of whether, and if so to what extent, ChatGPT can be a helpful tool for teaching the Bible in the classroom. To answer this question, the authors present a theoretical framework that encompasses both foundational insights into conversational AI and ChatGPT, as well as their implications for religious education and biblical teaching in Germany. In the next step, based on J. Theis’ five-step model of Bible didactics [(1) initial perception; (2) analysis of the text; (3) in-depth reflection; (4) critical interpretation; (5) creative assimilation], ways of using ChatGPT in biblical teaching in the classroom are presented and their potential limitations are discussed. The article concludes with six final theses that summarise the investigation findings and offer some suggestions for the future.
20 September 2023 in Religionspädagogische Beiträge
Da der Religionsunterricht die Schüler*innen auf eine verantwortungsvolle Teilnahme an einer zunehmend technologisierten Gesellschaft vorbereiten soll, gewinnt auch die Frage, ob und inwieweit Künstliche Intelligenz (KI) in diesem Fach eingesetzt werden kann, immer mehr an Relevanz. Vor diesem Hintergrund verfolgt der vorliegende Artikel ein dreifaches Ziel. Zunächst werden die Begrifflichkeit und Funktionsweise der KI erläutert, um in einem zweiten Schritt die exemplarischen Anwendungsmöglichkeiten und -grenzen von KI zur Realisierung der drei grundlegenden Aufgaben des Religionsunterrichts aufzuzeigen, d. h. im Rahmen der Vermittlung von strukturiertem und lebensbedeutsamem Grundwissen über den Glauben der Kirche; des Vertrautmachens mit Formen gelebten Glaubens und der Förderung religiöser Dialog- und Urteilsfähigkeit. Abschließend werden vier zentrale Brennpunkte skizziert, die sich weitgehend aus der durchgeführten Analyse ergeben und – bezogen auf religiöse Lehr- und Lernprozesse – die Frage nach Verlusten durch den Einsatz von KI erörtern: das Unterlaufen der Subjektwerdung der Schüler*innen, die Verstärkung von Vorurteilen oder Diskriminierung durch fragwürdige Qualität und Entstehungsprozesse von KI-Trainingsdaten sowie Datenschutz- und Sicherheitsfragen, die eingeschränkte Portabilität sowie die hohen Kosten von KI.
This article critically analyses the use of generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI)—specifically, the DALL·E system within the ChatGPT-4o environment—for creating visualisations of biblical scenes for teaching purposes. As part of a case study examining the Baptism of Jesus in the Jordan (Mt 3:13–17; cf. Mark 1:9–11; Luke 3:21–22; John 1:31, 34) and the Last Supper (Mt 26:17–30; cf. Mark 14:12–16; Luke 22:7–13), four AI-generated images are analysed. Two were created using general, non-specific prompts, while the other two were based on more precise queries containing references to Catholic symbolism and the images’ intended educational use. A comparison of these variants reveals a lack of theological depth and symbolic oversimplification in AI-generated images, as well as a tendency to reproduce Western cultural stereotypes. Despite their aesthetic appeal and quick availability, these images do not reflect the complexity of the biblical or spiritual contexts of the scenes depicted. This study aims to evaluate the theological, symbolic, and pedagogical value of AI-generated images and to provide practical recommendations for their responsible use in Bible didactics. In conclusion, the authors argue that GenAI can support biblical teaching when used consciously, critically, and reflectively.
10 February 2022 in Journal of Religious Education
The Right-wing populism in Poland faces multiple challenges with respect to Religious Education. This is a complex issue, given it is not only about school education supporting pro-democratic positions in the modern generation of students, but also the fact that today’s populists have participated in long-term and complex educational processes of a similar nature. In this sense, the aim of this article is to seek an answer to the question of how Religious Education in Poland—with all of its theoretical and cognitive background rooted in the Christian vision of God and human and the world—can contribute to the elimination of the alliance of the right-wing populist perspectives from the dominant religion of the nation. The article will explain how practical educational opportunities will help students to understand the political strategy of populists, decipher their presentations and approaches, and so shape a positive attitude towards democracy as a desired ideological system within government and social life.
This article examines the perception of artificial intelligence (AI) in religious education, comparing the views of Catholic religion teachers in Germany and Poland. The analysis focuses mainly on generative AI, particularly large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT or Claude, which have recently transformed educational and communicative practices. As one of the most rapidly advancing technologies, generative AI evokes both hope and apprehension in the context of faith transmission, spiritual development and religious education. Quantitative research was conducted to identify current similarities and differences in the perception of AI in these two countries, and to determine the factors influencing the readiness of RE teachers ( n = 236) to incorporate AI into their teaching approaches. The results reveal ambivalence: while teachers recognize AI's potential to personalize teaching and engage students, they also highlight risks such as the oversimplification of religious content, ethical threats and the potential weakening of the spiritual dimension of religious education. Cultural and systemic differences influence the degree of AI acceptance, with digital competence and professional experience proving to be key determinants of openness. The authors make recommendations regarding teacher training and support, emphasizing the importance of consciously and critically integrating AI into religious education theory and practice.