Business Excellence Models (BEMs) are used by organisations to assess and improve their work practices and performance. The authors’ research identified that there are currently 94 national Quality/Business Excellence (BE) Awards used in 83 countries. While the use of BEMs is widespread, it was identified that many organisations wanted guidance in terms of which improvement initiatives to implement to assist them on their BE journey. This paper discusses how the BEM can be used as an overarching framework for managing and/or aligning multiple improvement initiatives within the organisation. A new model is developed showing some of the main improvement initiatives that can be adopted towards achieving BE, which are arranged according to the common enabling criteria of BEMs and levels of BE maturity. This proposed model can be used as a pathway/roadmap to BE. In developing this model, a literature review, a document review and several semi-structured interviews were conducted. Sixteen quality and BE experts were interviewed in New Zealand, Singapore, and Malaysia.
Participatory design (PD) has become a popular approach used in a range of applications to generate a range of different outcomes. The defining strength of this approach is that it has potential to generate appropriate solutions while also empowering the involved community. This strength has resulted in PD being used as a method for developing humanitarian technology in developing countries. However, this diversity has made it difficult to evaluate the effectiveness of each project, leading to criticisms that PD lacks empirically demonstrable benefits over traditional approaches. This article presents a new outcome-focused framework to assist in the evaluation of PD projects. The Insights, Solutions and Empowerment Framework draws from extant literature, and first-hand case studies in rural Cambodia, and attempts to provide a holistic view of the value PD offers, and important cross-cutting values to reflect on.
3 January 2013 in International Journal of Production Research
In this paper, we empirically test the theoretical model underlying the Toyota Way (TW), based on data obtained from Toyota’s logistics, sales and marketing functions across 27 countries. TW is the result of Toyota attempting to codify its culture to the global community. Using structural equation modelling techniques we show that the TW-associated measures challenge, kaizen, genchi genbutsu, respect and teamwork do adequately operationally define the TW; the first three measures corresponding to the construct ‘process improvement’ and the final two measures corresponding to the construct ‘people development’. Empirically, people development is found to have no direct effect on how the TW is deployed across a business unit. However, people development is found to be indirectly related to TW deployment through the mediating effect of process improvement. Our study provides quantitative evidence that while the intangible aspects of the TW (modelled as people development) may not directly relate to the results, they are an integral component of a complete implementation of the TW and related ‘Lean’ systems. By logical extension, this provides support for adoption of a holistic and long-term strategy, integrating soft and hard elements, by those organisations attempting to implement and sustain Toyota-style systems.
24 April 2007 in International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management
Purpose: The paper aims to describe a recently completed research project on the use of statistical quality control (SQC) methods in the context of food and drinks manufacturing. It discusses issues surrounding the successful uptake of such methods, including organisational motivation, possible application, costs and benefits, critical success factors and the central importance of prerequisite statistical thinking (ST).Design/methodology/approach: A three stage, mixed methods approach was adopted, incorporating surveys augmented by case studies and key informant interviews with industry managers and providers of relevant industry training. All data were combined to produce the final model.Findings: The paper finds that SQC methods are of relevance in the industry, providing the process is appropriate and management have a basic awareness of the fundamentals of ST. Certain organisational and external factors were found to progressively reduce the effectiveness with which such methods are introduced and sustained. The paper ends with discussion of an original model, developed from the research, which illustrates the “filters” that tend to reduce the effectiveness with which methods are used in the industry, with a discussion of how each can be overcome.Research limitations/implications: The research in this paper is focused on the European food manufacturing and legislative context, and predominantly UK. Low survey response rates numbers necessitated a nonparametric approach to survey analysis.Practical implications: The paper shows that the filters model is of generic applicability and interest to current and future managers, and to other researchers in this area.Originality/value: The paper addresses the “how to” of SQC, and examines an industry where there is not yet widespread literature on the benefits of SQC methods. It presents an original model of the barriers to effective use of statistical methods within a process knowledge and improvement cycle.
Lean six sigma (LSS) is a quality improvement phenomenon that has captured the attention of the industry. Aiming at a capability level of 3.4 defects per million opportunities (Six Sigma) and efficient (lean) processes, LSS has been shown to improve business efficiency and customer satisfaction by blending the best methods from Lean and Six Sigma (SS). Many businesses have attempted to implement LSS, but not everyone has succeeded in improving the business processes to achieve expected outcomes. Hence, understanding the cause and effect relationships of the enablers of LSS, while deriving deeper insights from the functioning of the LSS strategy will be of great value for effective execution of LSS. However, there is little research on the causal mechanisms that explain how expected outcomes are caused through LSS enablers, highlighting the need for comprehensive research on this topic. LSS literature is overwhelmed by the diverse range of Critical Success Factors (CSFs) prescribed by a plethora of conceptual papers, and very few attempts have been made to harness these CSFs to a coherent theory on LSS. We fill this gap through a novel method using artificial intelligence, more specifically Natural Language Processing (NLP), with particular emphasis on cross-domain knowledge utilization to develop a parsimonious set of constructs that explain the LSS phenomenon. This model is then reconciled against published models on SS to develop a final testable model that explains how LSS elements cause quality performance, customer satisfaction, and business performance.
15 February 2018 in Total Quality Management & Business Excellence
Productivity growth is an on-going challenge facing New Zealand’s (NZ) manufacturing sector. To help boost productivity, the Government attempted to implement lean through a targeted investment programme. We evaluate the effectiveness and success of this strategy, with reference to a sample of small to medium-sized manufacturers. Using the Sustainable Lean Iceberg Model [Hines, P. (2010). How to create and sustain a lean culture. Development and Learning in Organizations: An International Journal, 24(6), doi:10.1108/dlo.2010.08124fad.0072010] as a theoretical basis, we developed a case study protocol based around key constructs for sustainability of lean, and tested this using a sample of 20 manufacturers that had been part of the Government lean programme. Data were collected at two points in time; at least two, and at least eight years after the initial lean implementation. In the second round, we found that lean was being sustained in only one of the organisations as per our prediction following the first round. Two were attempting to sustain, and two were attempting to ‘re-implement’ lean. Four had abandoned lean altogether, and several had gone out of business entirely. Our study reinforces the vital importance of ‘strategy and alignment’, ‘leadership’ and ‘behaviour and engagement’. The tendency to focus on ‘quick win’ implementations of tools and techniques does not create the necessary cultural shift to permit sustainable lean.