As across the world, in Turkey, several studies have been carried out by local government to use sustainable and 100% zero-emission public transport following increased public awareness. Increasing greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) due to transportation systems in the world make it necessary to establish “zero-emission sustainable transportation systems” in Turkey. In this study, an economic analysis based on actual field data is presented for Istanbul Electricity, Tramway and Tunnel General Management (IETT) to seek the suitability of an electric bus concept for Istanbul conditions. For this purpose, a dynamic model based on the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) from well to wheel has been proposed for the three groups of transportation, namely diesel, CNG (compressed natural gas) and electric buses. The data source used in the proposed approach is created by performing actual field performance tests for diesel, CNG and electric buses under real Istanbul road, time, and trip conditions. Afterwards, the Net Present Value (NPV), Internal Rate of Return (IRR), and Payback Period (PB) methods considering TCO values and updated unit prices are carried out for the investment versus profitability analyses to compare the different public bus concepts. The results show that the electric bus concept with a charging station depot achieving sustainable and zero-emission goals will be the driving force to advance the electric bus concept for Istanbul Public Transport.
5 May 2022 in Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering
The trend toward electric buses worldwide is increasing day by day. Along with it, sectoral infrastructure elements are developing rapidly. Electric buses offer advantages in terms of operating costs and environmental emission values. Despite this, the most important disadvantage is that the purchasing costs have not yet reached the expected level compared to other internal combustion engine buses. Many country and especially city-based targets have been determined for electric solutions in rubber-tyred public transportation systems in the world. Only in Shenzhen city of China, 100% transition to electric bus solution has been achieved in public transportation. In this study, a different perspective has been put forward for the acceleration of the transition to the use of electric buses and the increase in the prevalence of public transportation enterprises. The concept of retrofit. This is conversions of the conventional powered (diesel and CNG) buses into electric buses, which are currently used. For the concept in paper, the actual project costs for one of the world’s most important public transportation companies have been revealed. According to the analysis results obtained, for Payback Period (PB) method are based on a fleet of 100 vehicles in total, the return time of the investment required for the results based on this approach which retrofit from CNG to Electric, is calculated as 8.74 years. For the Payback Period (PB) approach, it has been concluded that for the 5 years, which is envisaged to be taken as a reference, retrofit concept (from CNG to Electric) should be based on 100000 € per vehicle based on the current operating conditions. This retrofit approach based on the concept of sustainable public transportation is expected to become widespread with the results obtained.
30 June 2023 in Ct&f - Ciencia, Tecnología Y Futuro
As cities grow and become more populous, the demand for public transportation increases due to a need for authorities to expand their transportation capacity. However, the increased use of vehicles can cause environmental impacts such as air pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, and noise. To address these issues, governments and other stakeholders seek alternative transportation systems or technologies. This paper intends to assess the financial viability of using fuel cell hybrid-electric buses as an alternative transportation system for the Istanbul Metrobus System. The analysis is based on the Payback Period Method, which evaluates the costs and benefits of a project over its lifetime. The study compares the total operating costs of using fuel cell hybrid-electric buses to diesel and battery-electric buses. The study determined that fuel cell hybrid-electric buses can lead to a reduction in total operating costs of 81.1% compared to diesel buses and 56.3% compared to battery-electric buses. This analysis suggests that fuel cell hybrid-electric buses offer added value after approximately 9 years. The outcome of this study is significant as it can help stakeholders take informed decisions about the financial viability of alternative transportation systems. Furthermore, the financial model or approach used in this study can be useful for understanding how public transportation systems can be funded in the future.
11 January 2023 in El-Cezeri Fen ve Mühendislik Dergisi
Küresel ölçekte elektrikli otomobil satışları 2021 yılında pandemi koşulları ve tedarik zincirinde yaşanan zorluklara rağmen rekor seviyeye ulaşarak, toplam elektrikli otomobil kullanımını 16,5 Milyonun üzerine çıkmasına ve söz konusu artışın yaklaşık 70% oranında bataryalı elektrikli araçlardan meydana gelmesine imkân sunmuştur. Birçok ülke tarafından bildirilen ve yakın geleceğe yönelik içten yanmalı motorlu araçların kısıtlamasına/yasaklanması dair açıklamalar; bu kapsamda sağlanan teşvikler, elektrikli araç pazarına olan yönelimi arttırmaktadır. Türkiye’de ise 2021 yılı verilerine göre elektrikli otomobil satışları, toplam satışlarının 5,03% karşılık gelmektedir. Artan elektrikli otomobil kullanımının, otomotiv endüstrisi için temel gereksinimlerden olan ve önemli bir ticari potansiyeli barındıran satış sonrası hizmet kulvarındaki bakım & onarım süreçlerine dair değişiklikleri beraberinde getirmesi beklenmektedir. Yapılan birçok araştırmada şehir içi kullanıma uygun elektrikli otomobillerin bakım & onarım maliyetlerinin, içten yanmalı motorlu otomobillere göre 20-35 % oranında daha ekonomik olduğu belirtilmektedir. Söz konusu bu avantaj özellikle filolar nezdinde daha da belirgin hale gelmekte; filolar için söz konusu maliyetlerin araç türüne ve kullanım amacına bağlı olarak araç bazında toplam sahip olma maliyetinin 7-12%' sine karşılık geldiği ifade edilmektedir. Bu çalışmada elektrikli araçlara özel periyodik bakım & onarım yaklaşımlarına yer verilecektir. Türkiye özelinde çok yeni olan işbu konuya dair bakış açısının geliştirilmesi hedeflenmektedir. Mevcut durumda standartlardan uzak ve birçok belirsizlikler yaşandığı değerlendirilen elektrikli araçlara özel bakım & onarım faaliyetleri için bireysel / kurumsal (kamu) kullanıcılarına hitaben, içten yanmalı motorlu araçlardan farklı olarak, araçların güç sistem bileşenlerini esas alan temel bakım & onarım süreç ve prosedürlerine değinilerek; konuya dair farkındalık sağlanılması hedeflenmektedir.
18 January 2024 in International Journal of Low-Carbon Technologies
The utilization of electric buses presents a viable solution to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and the concomitant decrease in fossil fuel consumption. Furthermore, their low-noise operation has the additional benefit of reducing noise pollution, which is a particular issue in large urban areas. This constitutes a significant advantage for public transport systems. Additionally, they provide cost savings in operations and maintenance, which represent a substantial proportion of expenditure for public transport operators. However, the initial purchase cost of electric buses is higher than that of conventional buses (diesel and CNG). This discrepancy can be attributed primarily to the absence of economies of scale in the manufacturing of electric bus subsystems and the substantial expenses associated with non-standardized, disparate technologies, most notably the high-voltage traction battery. The considerable disparity in the upfront cost of electric buses (in comparison to their internal combustion counterparts of equivalent specifications) has prompted a novel strategy among local authorities responsible for the provision of public transportation services: Retrofit! This paper presents, for the first time, a comparison between all-electric buses constructed from the ground up and retrofitted diesel-electric buses in actual public transportation operations. The results obtained will facilitate an evaluation of the retrofit approach within the context of sustainable transport policies, with the ultimate objective of raising awareness among relevant audiences and decision-making mechanisms.
As cities confront the dual challenges of global warming and urban environmental degradation, adopting sustainable mobility strategies has become essential for future resilience and sustainability. The use of electric vehicles, which have minimal emissions and are constructed in an energy-efficient manner, represents a viable solution to this issue. Conversely, the secure and effective implementation of electric vehicles in car parks presents a multitude of technical and infrastructural challenges. Despite the anticipated substantial rise in the use of electric vehicles in the near future, there are proposals for them to be subject to a range of restrictions due to fire safety concerns. It has been established that charging processes represent the primary cause of fires in electric vehicles. The utilisation of charging stations in enclosed and particularly subterranean garages situated within edifices that serve a multiplicity of purposes, including commercial, residential and retail, is on the rise. As a result, it poses a greater risk in a potential fire scenario than a charging station located in the open air. The pressure on charging times, especially for electric vehicles, requires the use of chargers with a higher power rating, which may increase the risk. It is noted that although electric vehicle fires and combustion engine vehicle fires have similar characteristics, there are differences in the fire behavior of electric vehicles. This paper aims to provide a strategic guide to achieving urban sustainability goals by looking at innovative approaches to the deployment of electric vehicles in car parks and solutions to potential risks. The use of car parks is crucial to strengthening the role of electric vehicles in future urban mobility systems. It aims to facilitate the harmonisation of electric vehicles and charging stations, contributing to a more sustainable future by reducing the environmental impact of cities.