Keith Matthews

Dr. Keith Matthews

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

6Years (2021-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 April 2025 in Discover Sustainability
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
Miriam GlendellMiriam Glendell
Miriam Glendell
MHMatt Hare
Matt Hare
KWKerry Waylen
Kerry Waylen
KAKerr Adams
Kerr Adams
JBJean Boucher
Jean Boucher
JPJ. Gareth Polhill
J. Gareth Polhill
The evolving ‘permacrisis’ of compounding environmental and social challenges calls for transformative approaches to understanding and intervening in socio-ecological systems. Approaches to support systems thinking and understanding can be vital to achieving this goal. However, applying such systems thinking is often challenging, and we need to better reflect on the pros and cons of different approaches for building systems understanding and informing changes. In this paper, we first identify key attributes of systems thinking approaches from literature. We then use these as a framework for comparing and evaluating seven different systems thinking approaches, selected on the basis of our experience in applying them in support of the management and governance of various types of land systems. The seven approaches are: agent-based modelling, Bayesian belief networks, causal loop modelling, spatial multicriteria analysis, societal metabolic analyses, social network mapping and quantitative story telling. This framework has allowed us to appraise and reflect on our own experiences to identify the respective strengths and weaknesses of these different methodologies. We note that some of the ability to inform change depends as much on the context within which specific tools are used as the particular features of the tools themselves. Based on our appraisal, we conclude by suggesting six key recommendations that should be followed by others seeking to commission and use systems approaches, in order to enable them to support transformative change. We hope this may be useful to those working with systems approaches, since there is an urgent need for analytic efforts that can inform and enable transformative change. We also reiterate the call for sustained funding for long-term, standards-based evaluation of systems thinking approaches with respect to whether their use can demonstrate instrumental impacts leading to the kind of transformation the IPCC has called for, i.e. fundamental system change that goes beyond capacity development impacts such as network-building.

16 July 2024 in European Journal of Soil Science
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
FMFraser Macfarlane
Fraser Macfarlane
CRCiaran Robb
Ciaran Robb
MCMalcolm Coull
Malcolm Coull
MMMargaret McKeen
Margaret McKeen
DWDoug Wardell-Johnson
Doug Wardell-Johnson
MAMatt Aitkenhead
Matt Aitkenhead
Peat makes up approximately a quarter of Scotland's soil by area. Healthy, undisturbed, peatland habitats are critical to providing resilient biodiversity and habitat support, water management, and carbon sequestration. A high and stable water table is a prerequisite to maintain carbon sink function; any drainage turns this major terrestrial carbon store into a source that feeds back further to global climate change. Drainage and erosion features are crucial indicators of peatland condition and are key for estimating national greenhouse gas emissions. Previous work on mapping peat depth and condition in Scotland has provided maps with reasonable accuracy at 100‐m resolution, allowing land managers and policymakers to both plan and manage these soils and to work towards identifying priority peat sites for restoration. However, the spatial variability of the surface condition is much finer than this scale, limiting the ability to inventory greenhouse gas emissions or develop site‐specific restoration and management plans. This work involves an updated set of mapping using high‐resolution (25 cm) aerial imagery, which provides the ability to identify and segment individual drainage channels and erosion features. Combining this imagery with a classical deep learning‐based segmentation model enables high spatial resolution, national scale mapping to be carried out allowing for a deeper understanding of Scotland's peatland resource and which will enable various future analyses using these data.

9 September 2021 in Sustainability
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
KMKeith Matthews
Keith Matthews
ARAnsel Renner
Ansel Renner
KBKirsty L. Blackstock
Kirsty L. Blackstock
KWKerry Waylen
Kerry Waylen
DMDave G. Miller
Dave G. Miller
MGMario Giampietro
Mario Giampietro
The paper presents insights from carrying out a pan-EU sustainability assessment using Farm Accountancy Data Network (FADN) data (the old wine) with societal metabolism accounting (SMA) processes (the new bottles). The SMA was deployed as part of a transdisciplinary study with EU policy stakeholders of how EU policy may need to change to deliver sustainability commitments, particularly to the UN Sustainable Development Goals. The paper outlines the concepts underlying SMA and its specific implementation using the FADN data. A key focus was on the interactions between crop and livestock systems and how this determines imported feedstuffs requirements, with environmental and other footprints beyond the EU. Examples of agricultural production systems performance are presented in terms of financial/efficiency, resource use (particularly the water footprint) and quantifies potential pressures on the environment. Benefits and limitations of the FADN dataset and the SMA outputs are discussed, highlighting the challenges of linking quantified pressures with environmental impacts. The paper concludes that the complexity of agriculture’s interactions with economy and society means there is great need for conceptual frameworks, such as SMA, that can take multiple, non-equivalent, perspectives and that can be deployed with policy stakeholders despite generating uncomfortable knowledge.

29 June 2024 in Biological Conservation
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
DFDebbie Fielding
Debbie Fielding
SNScott Newey
Scott Newey
RPRobin J. Pakeman
Robin J. Pakeman
DMDave Miller
Dave Miller
ZGZisis Gagkas
Zisis Gagkas
SSStuart W. Smith
Stuart W. Smith

25 February 2026 in Nature Conservation
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JRJosselin Rouillard
Josselin Rouillard
JMJohanna Meier
Johanna Meier
KBKirsty L. Blackstock
Kirsty L. Blackstock
KMKeith Matthews
Keith Matthews
Sebastian BirkSebastian Birk
Sebastian Birk
The Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) is a key lever to support the transition towards sustainable agricultural production in Europe. However, successive reforms have been incremental and modest with regard to environmental objectives. This contribution presents an assessment of the choices made by Member States in their CAP Strategic Plans (CSPs), directing the EUR 307 billion in funding to support agriculture and rural areas for the period 2023–2027. The focus is on the different funding instruments supporting the restoration of freshwater ecosystems, in particular addressing the impact of drainage, restoring wetland and floodplain connectivity, and increasing landscape-scale water retention. A detailed mapping of farm practices supported by CAP funding – i.e. conditionality, eco-schemes, rural development (Environment and Climate measures), and investments – is presented. Results show that interventions to reduce the impact of drainage, restore wetland and floodplain connectivity, and increase landscape-scale water retention remain limited in scope. Illustrative examples of good practice are highlighted, along with recommendations for improved implementation of the CAP in the current programming period and the next round of reform. CAP 2023–2027 offers opportunities for wetland and freshwater ecosystem restoration. Member State choices show limited ambition and do not fully exploit the potential of the CAP to support restoration efforts. Good practices where the CAP supports wetland and freshwater ecosystem restoration are identified. Better metrics and performance-based incentives are needed to improve outcomes.

11 January 2025 in Journal of Environmental Management
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
HNHebe Nicholson
Hebe Nicholson
KBKirsty Blackstock
Kirsty Blackstock
JBJean Boucher
Jean Boucher
JGJames Glendinning
James Glendinning
AGAlexa Green
Alexa Green
STSteven Thomson
Steven Thomson
The multiple crises (climate, biodiversity, austerity) facing our socio-ecological systems require ambitious responses; with much of the responsibility for protecting public goods and developing sustainably lying with public policy. To tackle these wicked problems, there are increasing calls for policy coherence: to use the levers of government in a more holistic and systemic manner. Land use transformation is crucial to achieving these ambitions. However, there is limited scholarship that takes a comprehensive approach to analysing policy coherence (both horizontal and vertical). Common to many nation-states, the Scottish Government has made ambitious pledges to address climate action (mitigation and adaptation) and nature, with an emphasis on leaving no one behind e.g., net zero by 2045 using Just Transitions. In this research we examine the policy coherence of 66 Scottish land use related policies in addressing land use transformation, as well as an in-depth coherence analysis of 11 agricultural policies. We address three research questions on the synergies and problems in policy coherence for land use transformation, as well as opportunities for improvement. Overall, we found that half of the 66 policies examined advanced land use transformation, but we query the possibility of hidden conflicts. The in-depth coherence analysis highlighted that when looking at the agricultural policies as a collective, coherence was clear, however, on the individual level it was not. Our paper shows that whilst challenging to implement, paying attention to multiple forms of policy coherence can highlight opportunities to consider when revising or designing policies for these pressing problems.