We synthesized ion pair receptors 1 and 2 consisting of a benzocrown ether cation binding site and a ferrocene-supported squaramide anion binding domain and compared their binding ability with anion receptor 3, lacking a crown ether unit, using spectroscopic, spectrophotometric, and electrochemical measurements in acetonitrile solution. All receptors were obtained in a modular fashion by sequential amidation of dimethyl squarate with corresponding amines, which allows for the simple introduction of a ferrocene unit and enables them to act as sensors. We found that ion pair receptors 1 and 2 recognized the tested anions more strongly in the presence of cations, whereas the homotopic anion receptor 3 was unable to bind sodium or potassium salts more strongly than tetrabutylammonium salts. This enhancement in anion binding was attributed to a cation complexation induced alteration in the nature of the phenyl ring substituents, directly linked to the squaramide anion binding site, changing from electron-donating to more withdrawing. Solid state X-ray measurements support this design principle of the receptors and reveal strong coordination of anions and cations to the corresponding binding domains. In both 1·NaCl and 2·KCl systems, organic moieties linked by the cations form 1-D polymeric structures in the crystal lattice. However, in the case of the 2·NaCl complex the polymers’ shape and orientation result in the formation of porous crystals with approximately 12% of the space unoccupied. Electrochemical measurements showed when the ion pair receptors (but not the anion receptor) were pretreated with sodium or potassium cations, the addition of anions resulted in greater changes in oxidation and reduction potentials compared to the addition of anions to the same receptors in the absence of cations. Overall, the study demonstrates that squaramides offer a convenient platform for constructing ion pair sensors in modular fashion by varying the cation binding site and reporters. This opens up the possibility of recognizing salts in real life scenarios where simultaneous binding of anions and cations is needed.
Through the high dilution technique, we obtained macrocyclic ion pair receptors R1 and R2, an anion receptor R3, and a fluorescent sensor R4 using a combination of particular members of simple libraries consisting of synthesized diamines and methyl squarates, respectively. The receptors were investigated in terms of anion and ion pair binding using the 1H NMR titration method in DMSO-d6. We found that the major contribution to the anion binding comes from the interaction with the squaramide protons rather than with the amide functions of the receptors. The receptors demonstrated the highest affinity towards benzoates and sulfates over the anions tested, and in the case of sulfate binding more complex equilibria in solution were observed. Unlike the anion receptor R3, the ion pair receptor R1 was found to recognize anions in an enhanced manner with the assistance of sodium or potassium cations. Tethering of a simple fluorophore in close proximity to the amide function of receptor R4 resulted in an optical ion pair sensor selective towards sulfates. DFT calculations carried out for the 1 : 1 complexes of R3 with the anions helped clarify this selectivity, showing more effective participation of tetrahedral sulfate anions in binding with the amide function than in the case of benzoates or chlorides.
In contrast to monotopic receptor 3, the anthracene functionalized squaramide dual-host receptor 1 is capable of selectively extracting sulfate salts, as was evidenced unambiguously by DOSY, mass spectrometry, fluorescent and ion chromatography measurements. The receptors were investigated in terms of anion and ion pair binding using the UV–vis and 1H NMR titrations method in acetonitrile. The reference anion receptor 3, lacking a crown ether unit, was found to lose the enhancement in anion binding induced by the presence of cations. Besides the ability to bind anions in an enhanced manner exhibited by ion pair receptors 2 and 4, changing the 1-aminoanthracene substituent resulted in their exhibiting a lower anion affinity than receptor 1. By using receptor 1 and adjusting the water content in organic phase it was possible to selectively detect sulfates both by “turn-off” and “turn-on” fluorescence, and to do so homogenously and under interfacial conditions. Such properties of receptor 1 have allowed the development of a new type of sensor capable of recognizing and extracting potassium sulfate from the aqueous medium across a phase boundary, resulting in an appropriate fluorescent response in the organic solution.
A tripodal, squaramide-based ion-pair receptor 1 was synthesized in a modular fashion, and 1H NMR and UV-vis studies revealed its ability to interact more efficiently with anions with the assistance of cations. The reference tripodal anion receptor 2, lacking a crown ether unit, was found to lose the enhancement in anion binding induced by presence of cations. Besides the ability to bind anions in enhanced manner by the “single armed” ion-pair receptor 3, the lack of multiple and prearranged binding sites resulted in its much lower affinity towards anions than in the case of tripodal receptors. Unlike with receptors 2 or 3, the high affinity of 1 towards salts opens up the possibility of extracting extremely hydrophilic sulfate anions from aqueous to organic phase. The disparity in receptor 1 binding modes towards monovalent anions and divalent sulfates assures its selectivity towards sulfates over other lipophilic salts upon liquid–liquid extraction (LLE) and enables the Hofmeister bias to be overcome. By changing the extraction conditions from LLE to SLE (solid–liquid extraction), a switch of selectivity from sulfates to acetates was achieved. X-ray measurements support the ability of anion binding by cooperation of the arms of receptor 1 together with simultaneous binding of cations.
Misregulation of transmembrane ion transport in biological systems has been linked to a variety of diseases. As a result, supramolecular chemists have been trying to develop small molecules that facilitate the transmembrane transport of several ionic species. However, ion transport by small molecules is a passive process and needs to be overall charge neutral (i.e., when an ion is transported across a membrane, another ion needs to be transported as well to avoid charge separation). Ion pair receptors could therefore have great potential as transmembrane ion transporters because they can facilitate transport of an overall neutral species. Furthermore, ditopic ion pair receptors also have the potential to transport biologically important zwitterionic species, such as amino acids. In this manuscript, we report the synthesis of a series of ditopic receptors based on squaramides as the anion binding unit and 18-crown-6 as the cation binding unit. UV-vis and NMR titrations revealed that these compounds can bind a variety of chloride salts, especially KCl. Furthermore, liquid–liquid extractions and transport experiments using bulk liquid membranes and liposomes indicate that these ditopic receptors are capable of transporting chloride salts and hydrophilic amino acids. In fact, compound 5 was even able to facilitate the transport of amino acids with charged side chains at physiological pH (arginine and glutamate), making it the first example of a small molecule that can transport these highly polar and charge-dense species. These findings open up the possibility of using these receptors in a wide range of biological applications.
Here, we present a ditopic ion-pair sensor, B1, containing the BODIPY reporter unit in its structure, which is shown to be able—thanks to the presence of two heterogeneous binding domains—to interact with anions in an enhanced manner in the presence of cations. This enables it to interact with salts even in 99% aqueous solutions, making B1 a good candidate in terms of visual salt detection in the aquatic environment. Receptor B1’s ability to extract and release salt was applied in the transport of potassium chloride through a bulk liquid membrane. Working with a concentration of B1 in the organic phase and with the presence of a specific salt in an aqueous solution, an inverted transport experiment was also demonstrated. By varying the type and the amount of the anions added to B1, we were able to develop diverse optical responses, including a unique four-step ON1-OFF-ON2-ON3 output.