Angle-resolved vibrational sum frequency generation experiments have been used to study the silica--water interface as a function of ionic strength. Well below the critical angle, the sum frequency intensity increases up to 0.1 mM NaCl, and then drops. However, near the critical angle, a plateau may be observed up to 0.1 mM. We first demonstrate that this is a result of the interaction of a long Debye length at low ionic strength with a long coherence length near the critical angles. In order to account for the behaviour at the lowest concentrations, it is necessary to consider an electrostatic potential that extends into the bulk aqueous phase beyond the Debye-Hückel approximation as a result of the large surface potential. Since the extent of the second- and third-order contributions to the nonlinear polarization can varying with ionic strength, but not with angle of incidence, we perform a global fit to the experimental data using our proposed model to extract the relative magnitude of the two susceptibilities. The ionic strength dependence of this ratio points to the critical nature of the silanol deprotonation and the development of surface charge, and illustrates how the surface water molecules respond. These results highlight the importance of varying the coherence length in order to probe water structure at charged interfaces.