The paradoxical notion of ‘the adventure’ sold as a predictable, managed experience-commodity is explored here. The extant literature on the consumption of sport tourism adventure products is contrasted with definitional work drawn from adventure education, tourism and sociology sources and from Nietzsche's original ideas. In doing so ‘the adventure’ is presented as being located in the interstices between the controlled Apollonian and the chaotic Dionysiac forms of life. These efforts lead to the notion that the ‘true’ or ‘original’ adventure, in its ideal-type, has clear characteristics that the commodity version cannot allow. A model is then constructed; the adventure commodification continuum. This is designed to show that the products labelled as ‘adventures’ range from the controlled, rationalised and risk-managed ‘post-adventure’ experiences in the shallow end, to those experiences that allow greater levels of commitment, risk and responsibility at the deep end of the model. The continuum to some extent anticipates the potential criticisms of the definitional work for its essentialist stance by illustrating that the extent of the containment of adventure elements in adventure products varies considerably. Some are essentially just ‘adventure flavoured’ experiences – simply the product of marketing rhetoric and perhaps also the situational factors, such as an unusual physical environment. Other tourist products have rather more connection to ‘original adventure’ in terms of the definitional characteristics developed here. The final conclusion, however, is that only a lazy accommodation of the term ‘adventure’ would accept that this phenomenon is an experience that can be packaged and reliably offered to a customer in exchange for money. It is therefore proposed that the direct experience of the definitive, Dionysiac chaos at the heart of adventure is commodification-proof.
3 April 2015 in Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism
The potentially paradoxical concept of “slow adventure” is offered here as having a particularly North European potential and a peculiarly Nordic orientation towards outdoor tourism activity. An overview of the relationship between the slow movements and the frenetically paced, technologically wired lived experience of hypermodernity is considered in the light of the rise of the adventure tourism “industry”. We contrast the slow movement principles with mainstream, risk managed and rationalised “fast” adventure tourism products, which focus predominantly on thrill and rush. The concept of slow adventure, as distinct from slow tourism or slow travel per se is then further developed to include time, passage, comfort and nature, aligned with Scandinavian concepts of friluftsliv, as determining elements in what have become highly regarded tourist experiences. We conclude that there cannot be an essentialist separation of “slow” and “fast” adventure (or travel, or tourism, or food … ) per se. Rather, that these qualitative aspects of self-supported adventurous journeys illustrate significant, and hitherto largely ignored aspects in the analysis of adventure tourism, and point toward opportunities for well-trained outdoor professionals who can make the most of the Nordic great outdoors for small numbers of clients, enabling inclusive, environmentally responsible, high-value, place-specific experiences, all year round.
13 August 2018 in Journal of Place Management and Development
Purpose: Food tourism and events are often prefaced as tools for sustainability within national and intra-national food and agricultural policy contexts. Yet, the realities of enhancing sustainability through food tourism and events are problematic. Sustainability itself is often conceived broadly within policy proclaiming the benefits of food tourism and events, with a need for further deconstruction of the ways each dimension of sustainability – economic, environmental, social and cultural – independently enhances sustainability. The lack of clarity concerning the conceptual utilisation of sustainability works to compromise its value and utilisation for the development of food tourism and events in peripheral areas. In recognition, this paper aims to turn attention to social sustainability within the context of a local food festival, to ask the following: in what ways is social sustainability enhanced through a local food festival, who benefits from this sustainability, and how? Design/methodology/approach: The paper examines the development of a local food festival in a rural coastal community on Scotland’s west coast. The concept of social capital is used to examine the unfolding power relations between committee members, as well as the committee and other social groups. Observant participation undertaken over a 10-month period, between December 2015 and September 2016, renders insights into the ways event planning processes were dependent on the pre-existing accruement of social capital by certain individuals and groups. Findings: Local food festivals have the potential to enhance social sustainability, in offering opportunity to bridge relations across certain diverse groups and foster an environment conducive to cohabitation. Bridging, however, is dependent on preconceived social capital and power relations, which somewhat inhibits social integration for all members of a community. The temporally confined characteristics of events generates difficulties in overcoming the uneven enhancement of social sustainability. Care, thus, needs to be upheld in resolutely claiming enhancement of social sustainability through local food events. Further, broad conceptualisations of “community” need to be challenged during event planning processes; for it is difficult to develop a socially inclusive approach that ensures integration for diverse segments without recognising what constitutes a specific “community”. Originality/value: This paper is situated within the context of a peripheral yet growing body of literature exploring the potential of events to develop social sustainability. In extending work examining events and social sustainaility the paper turns attention to the gastronomic – examining the extent to which social sustainability is enhanced through a local food festival, for a rural coastal community – Mallaig, on Scotland’s west coast.
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to examine university applicants' choice processes using Kotler's five stage consumer buying process with a particular emphasis on the final stage of the process namely that of the purchase decision.Design/methodology/approach: Based on four focus groups with 22 students at one university in North‐west England, post‐enrolment.Findings: Applicants' choice processes are complex and not evenly supported by university departments. Using concepts from the field of services marketing, the student choice process as candidates progress through the Universities and Colleges Admissions Service system is critically interrogated. “Moments of truth” are seen to be critical in many students' decision to choose a specific university course. University personnel need to be mindful that the decision process is two way and takes place over an extended period of time.Research limitations/implications: This research has been conducted with respondents drawn from just one university and at one point in time.Practical implications: It is suggested that universities should refine and target their communications efforts, and pay close attention to the quality of the interactions with potential students throughout their relationship. In order to do this it is suggested that universities adopt a services marketing framework.Originality/value: Key themes from services marketing concepts are suggested to inform the analysis of what is and what could be done to maintain and enhance the university‐applicant relationship as it progresses.
The ethnographic data considered here were gathered over a seven‐month period on and around the Isle of Anglesey in North Wales. The data were partly collected during sea kayaking courses at a commercial outdoor centre and also during more informal outings with independent members of a sea kayaking club. Material recorded on accompanied journeys, during participation on group courses and on expeditions was triangulated with notes from semi‐structured interviews and spontaneous discussions. The notions of marginal danger and of apparently approaching the ‘edge’ are key characteristics of the late‐modern forms of adventurous leisure. It is proposed that, rather like the strange vertical world of the rock climber or the subterranean one of the potholer, the sea kayakers’ environment is an alien, marginal, liminoid world. The ocean is not the natural territory of human beings. The kayakers move from the land to the sea and from comfort to hardship, from security to uncertainty, passivity to commitment and from action governed via ocular experience to total bodily/sensual immersion. Importantly, these shared experiences provide belonging in the ecstatic, temporary, Dionysiac communities who meet in these marginal places and situations in search of adventure and escape. Danger is but a small part of the meaning of such activity; it is the liminoid experience that is of key importance to participants.