Men are becoming increasingly concerned about misattributed paternity. The increasing use of genetic technologies in clinical research increases the potential for misattributed paternity to be identified. This review seeks to answer the question of whether the Tort of Deceit is effective in addressing issues of paternity fraud. The article assesses how the tort of deceit concepts and principles can be used to resolve misrepresentation cases of paternity fraud and to inform the effectiveness of the tort of deceit in resolving such matters. The article concludes that the tort of deceit can be used to claim settlement as it provided a form of legal solution for the damages suffered as a consequence of paternity fraud. Some of the elements of the tort of deceit include false representation, fact, Knowing or reckless as to whether the statement is false, whether there was reliance upon the representation and existence of damage suffered by the plaintiff. The association between material obligation and the burdens generated by parenthood implies that it is ethically acceptable for a man to establish that he is the legal and biological father of a child before accepting this financial liability. Therefore, the tort of deceit concepts can be used to resolve cases of paternity misrepresentation.
The common law views marriages and parental rights over children as a private economic relationship anchored in a civil contract. Contemporary family law abandoned the parental rights scheme grounded in Natural law justifications in favour of the Positivist parental responsibility scheme advocated for by John Locke. Even in this new legal conception of the status of being a parent, establishing the paternity of a child remains just as important as it was under the common law parental rights scheme since it is in the best interests of a child to know who his/her biological father is. Since the legal conception of fatherhood remains an obligation to pay for the upkeep of their biological children, the rebuttable presumption of legitimacy evolved to protect married men from the indignity of being misled into assuming parental rights for children who were the result of their wives adultery. For the study, a mixed-method research approach was used by combining black letter research and a systematic review to conduct a comparative analysis of case laws, legal commentaries, and procedures involving the application of the tort of deceit in the paternity fraud cases. By engaging in a comparative law analysis, the study focused on examining the following questions (i) Is there an overriding public interest in using the law to address paternity fraud? (ii) Can the tort of deceit be used to address paternity fraud? (iii) Does making paternity fraud a cause of action in the tort of deceit violate the res judicata rule when it involves divorced spouses? The study concludes that the application of the tort of deceit in the paternity fraud cases improves the equity and justice outcomes of the case stakeholders and at the same time, does not violate the res judicata rule for the divorced spouses.
Paternity fraud happens when women make representations to their male partner that he is the biological father of their child knowing that this may not be true because they have undisclosed sexual relationships with other men. Where the man acts on this information and the paternity of the child is subsequently discovered through DNA testing. With the shift from the parental rights regime to the parental responsibility system in most common law jurisdictions, more men are obliged by law to pay for the upkeep of their "child" or “children”. This legal conception of fatherhood has led to an increasing number of voices demanding that a legal remedy be sought for men victimized by paternity fraud. While there are several cases at the heart of paternity fraud, the case of PvB (Paternity Damages for Deceit)[2001] is a very interesting one. This article revisits this case making some very compelling discussions and analysis. It also reviews some of the flaws of the reproductive rights argument. It is of the position that the reproductive rights argument may be flawed since reproductive health rights have not been normatively expressed in any multilateral treaty (or in customary international law for that matter). It highlights the implications of the tort of deceit in paternity fraud cases for both married and divorced spouses. It also highlights how tort of deceit can be applied to fairly represent the interest of fathers and their needed relationship with their biological child.
Communicable diseases is as old as mankind. With recent advances in medical sciences and increased human activities, recent years have seen even more resilient infectious diseases. While sciences have made numerous advances in the fight and eradication of such diseases strong contentions still exists on ethics and processes. With innovations around vaccines, the importance of humans and the key stakeholders need to be emphasized. This paper looks at the various theories and ethical implications of vaccine trials and testings and how this might be impacting innovation and the law. It further highlights the importance of proper ethical processes to vaccine trials and how such would not only enhance the process but provide workable methods for future pandemics. It critically analyses some important theoretical frameworks related to vaccine trials and how these tie to protecting not just the human rights of volunteers but future patients and other stakeholders.
The structure and concept of the family have been gradually changing due to the dynamic nature of modern society. With these changes comes challenges; constantly evolving family structures, divorces, social issues and vices, among others. With all these challenges comes the place of the child, since they are considered a very important component of the family and the priority of any home. Paternity fraud is in the wider conversation in recent times and has brought about diverse views on the place of a child, particularly in very complex situations where such may hinder functional and biological parenthood. The article takes a look at the wider conversation on paternity fraud, particularly around the laws on these issues. It highlights some really important cases at the heart of this conversation. Through a critical analysis of literature and review of the law, it further highlights the place of the child in such complex situation and why their place as priority is a paramount and important consideration in paternity fraud cases.