A fuzzy rule-based control model for multipurpose real-time reservoir operation is constructed. A new, mathematically justified methodology for fuzzy inference—total fuzzy similarity—is used and compared with the more traditional Sugeno-style method. Specifically, the seasonal variation in both hydrological variables and operational targets is examined by considering the inputs as season-dependent relative values, instead of using absolute values. The inference drawn in several stages allows a simple, accessible model structure. The control model is illustrated using Lake Päijänne, a regulated lake in Finland. The model is calibrated to simulate the actual operation, but also to better fulfill the new multipurpose operational objectives determined by experts. Relatively similar results obtained with the inference methods and the strong mathematical background of total fuzzy similarity put fuzzy reasoning on a solid foundation.
The root of this work is on the one hand in Belnap's four valued paraconsistent logic, and on the other hand on Pavelka's papers further developed by Turunen. We do not introduce a new non-classical logic but, based on a related study of Perny and Tsoukias, we introduce paraconsistent semantics of Pavelka style fuzzy sentential logic. Restricted to Lukasiewicz t-norm, our approach and the approach of Perny and Tsoukias partly overlap; the main difference lies in the interpretation of the logical connectives implication and negation. The essential mathematical tool proved in this paper is a one-one correspondence between evidence couples and evidence matrices that holds in all injective MV-algebras. Evidence couples associate to each atomic formula p two values a and b that can be interpreted as the degrees of pros and cons for p, respectively. Four values t,f,k,u, interpreted as the degrees of the truth, falsehood, contradiction and unknownness of p, respectively, can then be calculated by means of a and b and finally, the degrees of the truth, falsehood, contradiction and unknownness of any well formed formula @a are available. The obtained logic is Pavelka style fuzzy sentential logic. In such an approach truth and falsehood are not each others complements. Moreover, we solve some open problems presented by Perny and Tsoukias.