Without decarbonizing cities energy and climate objectives cannot be achieved as cities account for approximately two thirds of energy consumption and emissions. This goal of decarbonizing cities has to be facilitated by promoting net-zero/positive energy buildings and districts and replicating them, driving cities towards sustainability goals. Many projects in smart cities demonstrate novel and groundbreaking low-carbon solutions in demonstration and lighthouse projects. However, as the historical, geographic, political, social and economic context of urban areas vary greatly, it is not always easy to repeat the solution in another city or even district. It is therefore important to look for the opportunities to scale up or repeat successful pilots. The purpose of this paper is to explore common trends in technologies and replication strategies for positive energy buildings or districts in smart city projects, based on the practical experience from a case study in Leipzig—one of the lighthouse cities in the project SPARCS. One of the key findings the paper has proven is the necessity of a profound replication modelling to deepen the understanding of upscaling processes. Three models analyzed in this article are able to provide a multidimensional representation of the solution to be replicated.
The concept of positive energy districts (PED) encompasses a range of policies and strategies in response to climate protection targets in urban areas. Due to the limited potential of renewable energy in urban neighborhoods, broader definitions of PED are proposed that allow for energy exchange through the grid infrastructure. This study evaluates demand side management in combination with a virtual power plant (VPP) to assess the impact on the design of PED. In particular, the optimal customer behavior in response to flexible electricity tariffs is analyzed. A techno-economic energy system model is proposed for an urban area in Germany that optimizes the customer cost and the VPP’s margin. This includes electrical energy generation, storage, demand, and access to the short-term electricity market. Based on economic analysis, a dynamic market-based tariff allows the VPP to maximize profit margins. Consumers benefit when the local balances of renewable energy supply and demand are integrated into the dynamic tariff.
The decarbonization of the heat supply is crucial for the German energy transition. Integrating Power-to-Heat technologies like heat pumps (HPs) into district heating grids (DHGs) can support this process. The efficiency of HPs can be increased through temperature reduction in the DHG, though decentralized reheating may be required to supply sufficient heat for the end consumers. In order to investigate the associated trade-off, this study evaluates the economic, ecological, and technical effects of temperature reduction in DHGs using the software tool nPro. In a three-step process heat demand, the DHG design and operation are modeled. Three operating temperature scenarios are considered: 60 °C, 50 °C, and an ambient dependent flow temperature varying between 40 and 50 °C. As the temperatures decrease, the balance shifts between centrally produced HP heat and decentralized heat from instantaneous electric water heaters (IEWHs). The initial temperature reduction leads to reduced CO2 emissions, primary energy demand, heat losses, and total annual cost (TAC). However, with a further reduction in the operating temperature, an increase in these parameters occurs. While the necessary cost and primary energy for central components decrease, an increase in the decentralized heat generation is necessary to properly supply the heat demand. This leads to higher TAC and CO2 emissions overall.