The theory of the capital cost and the capital structure by Modigliani and Miller (MM) is based on many assumptions, removal of which significantly alters its conclusions. While the account of corporate and individual taxes, the possibility of bankruptcy and a number of other assumptions have received considerable attention, the MM assumption that all financial flows are perpetuity (the lifetime of the company is infinite) is much less studied. In fact, the lifetime of the company is always, of course, finite and the inclusion of this significantly changes formulae obtained by MM, in particular for the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC). In this article, we consider the WACC of the company in the theory of MM and modify MM's theory for a finite lifetime company. For the first time, we derive the analytical expression for WACC of the company with arbitrary lifetime. In two limited cases – 1 year and perpetuity companies – our expression gives the well-known results of Myers and MM, correspondingly. We have solved the obtained equation for a 2 year company and compared this result with those of Myers and MM. It shows that WACC values for 2 year company is closer to MM (perpetuity) limit than to Myers (1 year) one at small equity cost (just above the debt cost) while at bigger equity cost, it is closer to Myers limit than to MM one. Algorithm for finding of WACC in the case of arbitrary lifetime of the project has been developed. The use of the obtained equations for the projects of n years, and for companies operating in the market n years significantly alters the assessment of the WACC of the company.
The problem of the influence of debt financing on the effectiveness of the arbitrary duration investment project is studied and quantitative results are obtained for the first time. The effectiveness of the investment project is considered from two perspectives: the owners of equity and debt and equity holders only. It was shown, that NPV practically always decreases with leverage in case of a constant value of equity, and the maximum leverage level, at which the project is still effective (NPV > 0), was found. In case of a constant value of the total invested capital it is possible an increase of NPV with leverage as well as its decrease, depending on the relation between the parameters of the project.
The purpose of this review is to analyze all existing theories of the capital structure (with their advantages and disadvantages) in order to understand all aspects of the problem and make correct management decisions in practice. The role of the capital structure is that the correct determination of the optimal capital structure allows the company’s management to maximize the capitalization of the company and the long-term goal of the function of any company. The review examines the state of the capital structure and capital cost theory from the middle of the last century, when the first quantitative theory was created, to the present. The two main theories, Modigliani–Miller (MM) and Brusov–Filatova–Orekhova (BFO), are discussed and analyzed, as well as their numerous modifications and generalizations. Additionally, discussed is the latest stage in the development of the theory of capital structure, which began a couple of years ago and is associated with the adaptation of the two main theories of capital structure (Brusov–Filatova–Orekhova and Modigliani–Miller) to establish the practice of the function of companies. This generalization takes into account the real conditions of the work of the companies. It was noted that taking into account some effects that are present in economic practice (such as variable income, frequent payments of tax on income, advance payments of tax on income, etc.) brings both theories closer, and even the Modigliani–Miller theory, with all its many limitations, becomes more applicable in economic practice. However, it should be remembered that the Modigliani–Miller theory is only true for perpetual companies, while the BFO theory is valid for companies of any age, and from this point of view, they never coincide.
For the first time we have generalized the world-famous theory by Nobel Prize winners Modigliani and Miller for the case of variable profit, which significantly extends the application of the theory in practice, specifically in business valuation, ratings, corporate finance, etc. We demonstrate that all the theorems, statements and formulae of Modigliani and Miller are changed significantly. We combine theoretical and numerical (by MS Excel) considerations. The following results are obtained: (1) Discount rate for leverage company changes from the weighted average cost of capital, WACC, to WACC–g (where g is growing rate), for a financially independent company from k0 to k0–g. This means that WACC and k0 are no longer the discount rates as it takes place in case of classical Modigliani–Miller theory with constant profit. WACC grows with g, while real discount rates WACC–g and k0–g decrease with g. This leads to an increase of company capitalization with g. (2) The tilt angle of the equity cost ke(L) grows with g. This should change the dividend policy of the company, because the economically justified value of dividends is equal to equity cost. (3) A qualitatively new effect in corporate finance has been discovered: at rate g < g* the slope of the curve ke(L) turns out to be negative, which could significantly alter the principles of the company’s dividend policy.
The famous Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), widely used in practice, takes into account only the business risk associated with investments in a specific company [not the entire market (or industry)]. In practice, most listing companies use debt financing and operate at a non-zero leverage level. This means that the financial risk associated with the use of debt financing, along with business risk, must be taken into account. The purpose of this paper is to simultaneously account for business and financial risk. We combined the CAPM theory and the Modigliani-Miller (MM) theory, which is the perpetual limit of the BFO (Brusov-Filatova-Orekhova) theory. The article shows that R. Hamada’s attempt to take into account both business and financial risks has proved unsustainable, and the formulas he obtained, widely used in practice, are incorrect. The paper outlines the correct formulae that made it possible to generalize CAPM for the first time, taking into account both business and financial risk. The application of the new CAPM 2.0 model to a number of companies is considered and the difference between the results obtained within the framework of CAPM 2.0 and CAPM is demonstrated. CAPM is one of the main models [along with APT (arbitrage pricing theory) and WACC] within the income approach to business valuation. This significantly increases the value of the developed CAPM 2.0 approach, which can significantly improve the accuracy of the assessment.