Levin (2006, Phys. Rev. D, 74, 124027) has given two contrary claims on the chaotic behaviour of a system in which only one body of comparable mass binaries spins and spin effects are restricted to the leading order spin–orbit couplings. Chaos in one set of second post-Newtonian (2PN) harmonic coordinate Lagrangian equations of motion was allowed via the fractal basin boundary method. However, in another set of 2PN Arnowitt–Deser–Misner (ADM) Hamiltonian equations of motion no chaos was confirmed with the aid of parametric solutions. Is there chaos for conservative PN Lagrangian and Hamiltonian approaches to the dynamics of comparable mass binaries when only one object spins? This is still an open question. A paper on canonical, conjugate spin variables (Wu and Xie, 2010, Phys. Rev. D, 81, 084045) has directly shown that these Hamiltonian approaches are integrable and non-chaotic regardless of PN orders and spin effects. In this sense, what we are required to answer is only the question of whether the Lagrangian approaches allow chaos. As recently confirmed by Wu et al. (2015, Phys. Rev. D, 91, 024042), in ADM coordinates, any one of these Lagrangian approaches at a certain order generally has an analytical mathematical equivalent Hamiltonian at an infinite order from an analytical point of view or at a certain high enough finite order from a numerical point of view. The Hamiltonian is completely canonical and has four integrals of the total energy and total angular momentum in an eight-dimensional phase space, and therefore it is typically integrable. We use this to show the absence of chaos in the Lagrangian. On the other hand, we use the method of fast Lyapunov exponents to revisit the 2PN harmonic coordinate Lagrangian dynamics with the leading-order spin–orbit coupling of one body spinning. It is found that the fractal method is not sufficient to support chaos in unstable merging binaries, even if the radiation reaction is turned off. In summary, neither the PN conservative Lagrangian formulations nor the PN conservative Hamiltonian formulations can be chaotic in ADM/harmonic coordinates for the case of one body spinning. With this result, it is possible to end the dispute in the related literature regarding the two different claims on the chaotic behaviour of comparable mass binaries with one body spinning.
3 December 2021 in The European Physical Journal Plus
A novel three-dimensional autonomous chaotic system from the LÜ chaotic system is given. By using the theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, we provide an insight into the dynamic properties and characterizations of this system, such as Hopf bifurcation. In particular, we are interested in focusing on the dependence of varying parameters on chaos with the help of some chaos indicators including the fast Lyapunov indicator, small alignment indexes and Lyapunov exponent. It is shown that growing the parameter c leads to the extent of chaos. Finally, a chaotic electronic circuit is designed for the realization of the chaotic attractor with aim of Multisim software, and it gives almost the same rules of types of orbits as numerical ones by an alternating value of a circuital resistor.
In this paper we propose a new way to detect sublunar-mass primordial black holes (PBHs) by direct observations of the Earth-Moon binary system. Our method is based on treating PBH as a perturbation term, by assuming that the PBH is sweeping across the Solar System with a sublunar mass and is far away from the Earth-Moon binary (much greater than 1 AU). This perturbation treatment allows us to develop a framework to calculate the orbits of a generic binary system such as the Earth-Moon binary system. Our numerical results show that the Earth-Moon distance is sensitive to the initial values of the system. In most cases, the long-duration interactions between the PBH and the Earth-Moon system can induce lasting imprints on the Earth-Moon’s orbit, and these imprints can accumulate over time, eventually giving rise to observable deviations which can be used to infer the properties of the PBH.
A brane-world metric with an external magnetic field is a modified theory of gravity. It is suitable for the description of compact sources on the brane such as stars and black holes. We design a class of explicit symplectic integrators for this spacetime and use one of the integrators to investigate how variations of the parameters affect the motion of test particles. When the magnetic field does not vanish, the integrability of the system is destroyed. Thus, the onset of chaos can be allowed under some circumstances. Chaos easily occurs when the electromagnetic parameter becomes large enough. Dark matter acts as a gravitational force, so that chaotic motion can become more obvious as dark matter increases. The gravity of the black hole is weakened with an increasing positive cosmological parameter; therefore, the extent of chaos can be also strengthened. The proposed symplectic integrator is applied to a ray-tracing method and the study of such chaotic dynamics will be a possible reference for future studies of brane-world black hole shadows with chaotic patterns of self-similar fractal structures based on the Event Horizon Telescope data for M87* and Sagittarius A*.
In this study, we construct symmetric explicit symplectic schemes for the non-rotating Konoplya and Zhidenko black hole spacetime that effectively maintain the stability of energy errors and solve the tangent vectors from the equations of motion and the variational equations of the system. The fast Lyapunov indicators and Poincaré section are calculated to verify the effectiveness of the smaller alignment index. Meanwhile, different algorithms are used to separately calculate the equations of motion and variation equations, resulting in correspondingly smaller alignment indexes. The numerical results indicate that the smaller alignment index obtained by using a global symplectic algorithm is the fastest method for distinguishing between regular and chaotic cases. The smaller alignment index is used to study the effects of parameters on the dynamic transition from order to chaos. If initial conditions and other parameters are appropriately chosen, we observe that an increase in energy E or the deformation parameter can easily lead to chaos. Similarly, chaos easily occurs when the angular momentum L is small enough or the magnetic parameter Q stays within a suitable range. By varying the initial conditions of the particles, a distribution plot of the smaller alignment in the X–Z plane of the black hole is obtained. It is found that the particle orbits exhibit a remarkably rich structure. Researching the motion of charged particles around a black hole contributes to our understanding of the mechanisms behind black hole accretion and provides valuable insights into the initial formation process of an accretion disk.