Aging is associated with modifications of several brain structures and functions. These modifications then manifest as modified behaviors. It has been proposed that some brain function modifications may compensate for some other deteriorated ones, thus maintaining behavioral performance. Through the concept of compensation versus deterioration, this article reviews the literature on motor function in healthy and pathological aging. We first highlight mechanistic studies that used paradigms, allowing us to identify precise compensation mechanisms in healthy aging. Subsequently, we review studies investigating motor function in two often-associated neurological conditions, i.e., mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease. We point out the need to expand the knowledge gained from descriptive studies with studies targeting specific motor control processes. Teasing apart deteriorated versus compensating processes represents precious knowledge that could significantly improve the prevention and rehabilitation of age-related loss of mobility.
The hypothesis of hemispheric specialization for feedforward and feedback control has been developed and is still debated. Here, taking advantage of recent knowledge on optimal planning and control of arm movements in the gravity field, we recorded kinematics and electromyographic activities during vertical arm movements performed with the dominant and nondominant arms. Our results reveal that the nondominant arm takes advantage of gravity effects to minimize muscle effort, but less than the dominant arm.
The central nervous system (CNS) is thought to use motor strategies that minimize several criteria, such as end-point variability or effort, to plan optimal motor patterns. In the case of vertical arm movements, a large body of literature demonstrated that the brain uses a motor strategy that takes advantage of the mechanical effects of gravity to minimize muscle effort. Results from other studies suggested that the relative importance of each criterion may vary according to the task’s constraints. For example, it could be hypothesized that reduced end-point variability driven by high accuracy demands is detrimental to effort minimization. The present study probes this specific hypothesis using the framework of gravity-related effort minimization. We asked twenty young healthy participants to perform vertical arm reaching movements towards targets whose size varied across conditions. We recorded the arm kinematics and electromyographic activities of the anterior deltoid to study two well-known motor signatures of the gravity-related optimization process; i.e., directional asymmetries on velocity profiles and negative epochs on phasic muscular activities. The results showed that both indices were reduced as target size decreased, demonstrating that the gravity-related optimization process was reduced under high accuracy constraints. This phenomenon is consistent with the use of a trade-off strategy between effort and end-point variability. More generally, it suggests that the CNS is able to appropriately modulate the relative importance of varied motor costs when facing varying task demands.
Several sensorimotor control studies have provided evidence supporting that the central nervous system optimizes gravity’s effects to minimize muscle effort. Recently, this hypothesis has been supported by the consistent observation of direction-specific negative epochs in the phasic electromyographic signal of antigravity muscles during vertical arm movements. This suggests that gravity torque is harvested to produce some of the arm’s motion. However, further investigation is needed to more finely understand how the CNS integrates gravity effects into muscle commands. Here, we aimed to analyze the phasic muscular activity across varying movement speeds during horizontal and vertical arm movements. We quantified the amount of negativity during acceleration and deceleration phases for all movement directions during fast, natural, and slow movements. We found that the negativity was more important during the acceleration phase of downward movements and during the deceleration phase of upward movements, resulting in diminished phasic activity compared to horizontal movements. Concomitantly, we found direction-specific effects of movement speed on phasic EMG activity of gravity muscles. This resulted in altered EMG to kinematics relationships in vertical movements compared to horizontal ones. These results support the Effort-minimization hypothesis and confirm that the negativity of phasic EMG is an important aspect of the motor command. Furthermore, the present results reveal that the CNS finely tunes this feature across a range of movement speeds and directions.
1 December 2021 in European Journal of Geriatrics and Gerontology
Several sensorimotor modifications are known to occur with aging, possibly leading to adverse outcomes such as falls. Recently, some of those modifications have been proposed to emerge from motor planning deteriorations. Motor planning of vertical movements is thought to engage an internal model of gravity to anticipate its mechanical effects on the body-limbs and thus to genuinely produce movements that minimize muscle effort. This is supported, amongst other results, by direction-dependent kinematics where relative durations to peak accelerations and peak velocity are shorter for upward than for downward movements. The present study compares motor planning of fast and slow vertical arm reaching movements between eighteen young (24 ± 3 years old) and seventeen older adults (70 ± 5 years old). We found that older participants still exhibit directional asymmetries (i.e., differences between upward and downward movements), indicating that optimization processes during motor planning persist with healthy aging. However, the size of these differences was increased in older participants, indicating that gravity-related motor planning changes with age. We discuss this increase as the possible result of an overestimation of gravity torque or increased weight of the effort cost in the optimization process. Overall, these results support the hypothesis that feedforward processes and, more precisely, optimal motor planning, remain active with healthy aging.